====vvvv==== miplibbench ====vvvv==== CPLEX(default) | CBC(default) | GUROBI(default) | SCIP(default) | --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- Name |F| Nodes | Time |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ | bounds check --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- * 30n20b8 46338 791.0 # 182760 > 3607.2 3.94 4.56 42500 1530.7 0.92 1.94 1950 > 3624.5 0.04 4.58 ok * acc-tight5 42 10.2 658 230.8 15.67 22.63 368 51.6 8.76 5.06 4744 795.7 112.95 78.01 ok * aflow40b 87132 531.0 322945 > 3607.9 3.71 6.79 209194 1282.0 2.40 2.41 201225 1755.9 2.31 3.31 ok * air04 1107 20.1 741 138.6 0.67 6.90 421 32.9 0.38 1.64 144 109.3 0.13 5.44 ok * app1-2 1977 177.0 # 1799 > 3644.1 0.91 20.59 286 94.7 0.14 0.54 222 1423.5 0.11 8.04 ok * ash608gpia-3col # 1 61.9 # 1 418.6 1.00 6.76 # 1 396.1 1.00 6.40 # 7 66.6 7.00 1.08 ok * bab5 61351 > 3600.2 15818 > 3602.2 0.26 1.00 5860 521.2 0.10 0.14 6864 > 3615.3 0.11 1.00 ok * beasleyC3 536 10.0 83555 > 3643.9 155.89 364.39 693 20.8 1.29 2.08 621572 > 3662.4 Large 366.24 ok * biella1 4643 442.8 9990 2997.6 2.15 6.77 2242 846.3 0.48 1.91 4546 1661.1 0.98 3.75 ok * bienst2 104321 127.7 66224 920.0 0.63 7.20 101635 45.8 0.97 0.36 83671 383.6 0.80 3.00 ok * binkar10_1 5996 14.1 100032 1096.8 16.68 77.79 48642 44.9 8.11 3.18 154591 326.2 25.78 23.13 ok * bley_xl1 1 12.1 20 655.2 20.00 54.15 1 12.8 1.00 1.06 21 398.2 21.00 32.91 ok * bnatt350 # 1 > 3600.0 # 5334 > 3600.5 Large 1.00 21489 2655.6 Large 0.74 5355 541.7 Large 0.15 ok * core2536-691 627 47.9 755 230.2 1.20 4.81 725 183.5 1.16 3.83 5243 2459.8 8.36 51.35 ok * cov1075 10964 52.9 148831 > 3623.7 13.57 68.50 219 5.4 0.02 0.10 399965 > 3651.9 36.48 69.03 ok csched010 385902 > 3600.1 349547 > 3605.9 0.91 1.00 336329 > 3600.2 0.87 1.00 368982 > 3661.0 0.96 1.02 ok danoint 346317 > 3600.1 158141 > 3607.7 0.46 1.00 590588 > 3600.2 1.71 1.00 414006 > 3661.2 1.20 1.02 ok * dfn-gwin-UUM 25265 110.3 580199 2663.9 22.96 24.15 269763 326.1 10.68 2.96 105910 242.0 4.19 2.19 ok * eil33-2 12306 79.7 11312 401.4 0.92 5.04 10948 182.8 0.89 2.29 12398 170.0 1.01 2.13 ok * eilB101 12725 202.3 26493 > 3600.4 2.08 17.80 11258 230.8 0.88 1.14 9128 909.3 0.72 4.49 ok * enlight13 75288 22.7 # 193563 > 3619.1 2.57 159.43 24271 10.6 0.32 0.47 747534 657.2 9.93 28.95 ok * enlight14 # 1 39.4 # 213716 > 3606.7 Large 91.54 # 1 12.1 1.00 0.31 # 2006548 2083.0 Large 52.87 ok * ex9 1 8.3 # 1 > 3600.0 1.00 433.73 1 56.4 1.00 6.80 1 165.7 1.00 19.96 ok * glass4 6428492 > 3600.5 282577 > 3613.8 0.04 1.00 250481 646.4 0.04 0.18 3185206 > 3635.5 0.50 1.01 ok gmu-35-40 1829062 872.6 2011319 > 3614.1 1.10 4.14 14645887 > 3601.0 8.01 4.13 1 ! 4022.0 0.00 4.61 fail * iis-100-0-cov 270111 > 3600.1 11054 > 3617.9 0.04 1.00 129881 1749.3 0.48 0.49 106874 2343.5 0.40 0.65 ok * iis-bupa-cov 128526 > 3600.2 21086 > 3610.9 0.16 1.00 125929 > 3600.1 0.98 1.00 58452 > 3633.5 0.45 1.01 ok * iis-pima-cov 50723 1981.7 12604 > 3622.4 0.25 1.83 55011 2079.7 1.08 1.05 13011 1366.0 0.26 0.69 ok * lectsched-4-obj 1832 11.2 1700 418.4 0.93 37.36 54 4.9 0.03 0.44 13103 457.9 7.15 40.88 ok m100n500k4r1 1382398 > 3600.0 783129 > 3606.2 0.57 1.00 3146293 > 3600.0 2.28 1.00 2724981 > 3657.0 1.97 1.02 ok * macrophage 17854 338.9 4361 > 3608.7 0.24 10.65 12084 208.2 0.68 0.61 267458 > 3637.5 14.98 10.73 ok * map18 1033 290.4 927 2598.9 0.90 8.95 1155 304.6 1.12 1.05 387 891.1 0.37 3.07 ok * map20 1240 231.1 2057 3363.9 1.66 14.56 1181 232.4 0.95 1.01 299 731.5 0.24 3.17 ok * mcsched 52980 264.8 80730 > 3604.1 1.52 13.61 23043 236.4 0.43 0.89 14351 306.6 0.27 1.16 ok * mik-250-1-100-1 238548 30.2 796493 1616.8 3.34 53.54 174056 26.1 0.73 0.86 1092220 347.6 4.58 11.51 ok * mine-166-5 5076 25.1 1445 159.6 0.28 6.36 12472 35.5 2.46 1.41 6949 93.3 1.37 3.72 ok * mine-90-10 153207 479.7 60624 1029.4 0.40 2.15 840270 1259.3 5.48 2.63 92851 485.2 0.61 1.01 ok * msc98-ip 5614 > 3600.2 408 > 3600.0 0.07 1.00 6198 1516.0 1.10 0.42 # 352 > 3616.6 0.06 1.00 ok mspp16 175 1512.0 # 1 ! 0.5 0.01 0.00 1 2549.7 0.01 1.69 # 1 > 5324.1 0.01 3.52 fail * mzzv11 3520 97.6 1284 374.0 0.36 3.83 8 28.6 0.00 0.29 2110 607.4 0.60 6.22 ok n3div36 89829 > 3600.3 28541 > 3600.0 0.32 1.00 77877 > 3600.5 0.87 1.00 59441 > 3616.0 0.66 1.00 ok * n3seq24 2453 135.1 4747 > 3600.0 1.94 26.65 31200 420.4 12.72 3.11 337 > 3617.8 0.14 26.78 ok * n4-3 17410 694.5 242545 > 3621.5 13.93 5.21 101634 1959.2 5.84 2.82 26527 694.6 1.52 1.00 ok * neos-1109824 9385 46.6 23511 681.2 2.51 14.62 7999 91.2 0.85 1.96 15792 218.4 1.68 4.69 ok * neos-1337307 76094 > 3600.2 11166 > 3628.3 0.15 1.01 111895 > 3600.1 1.47 1.00 118234 > 3633.1 1.55 1.01 ok * neos-1396125 16244 96.9 56391 2970.2 3.47 30.65 7026 81.7 0.43 0.84 38350 > 3617.2 2.36 37.33 ok * neos13 1687 46.5 16152 > 3641.6 9.57 78.31 955 70.3 0.57 1.51 10239 > 3606.8 6.07 77.57 ok * neos-1601936 6121 559.4 21480 > 3604.7 3.51 6.44 2332 262.7 0.38 0.47 9458 > 3623.1 1.55 6.48 ok * neos18 10771 34.7 22074 3542.7 2.05 102.10 9420 52.9 0.87 1.52 5818 49.0 0.54 1.41 ok * neos-476283 1370 190.2 944 3185.4 0.69 16.75 1101 312.8 0.80 1.64 521 591.0 0.38 3.11 ok * neos-686190 4343 34.8 3460 150.0 0.80 4.31 14086 310.7 3.24 8.93 8976 175.5 2.07 5.04 ok * neos-849702 5808 221.1 # 87451 > 3602.8 15.06 16.29 14020 319.8 2.41 1.45 26386 818.7 4.54 3.70 ok * neos-916792 69296 394.2 120622 > 3610.0 1.74 9.16 72842 727.1 1.05 1.84 67696 460.5 0.98 1.17 ok * neos-934278 90 277.5 10211 > 3606.2 113.46 13.00 1 189.6 0.01 0.68 2006 > 3615.3 22.29 13.03 ok * net12 2790 750.2 1268 > 3607.7 0.45 4.81 1934 540.0 0.69 0.72 4517 > 3619.1 1.62 4.82 ok * netdiversion 196 321.4 353 1461.2 1.80 4.55 94 648.4 0.48 2.02 71 > 3612.8 0.36 11.24 ok * newdano 135557 > 3600.1 74249 > 3622.8 0.55 1.01 1467418 2953.1 10.83 0.82 1643761 > 3647.7 12.13 1.01 ok * noswot 2244350 311.9 1709802 1835.7 0.76 5.89 255648 69.7 0.11 0.22 522393 205.2 0.23 0.66 ok * ns1208400 46579 2979.5 # 47676 > 3605.0 1.02 1.21 611 84.1 0.01 0.03 15624 2870.3 0.34 0.96 ok ns1688347 2818 91.2 # 1 ! 447.0 0.00 4.90 735 33.6 0.26 0.37 34320 2994.7 12.18 32.84 fail ns1758913 1 162.3 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 1 50.2 1.00 0.31 1 > 3619.2 1.00 22.30 fail * ns1766074 # 1 127.1 # 947918 450.0 Large 3.54 # 1 166.6 1.00 1.31 # 923320 1229.8 Large 9.68 ok * ns1830653 18660 381.2 18196 > 3608.0 0.98 9.46 11056 435.1 0.59 1.14 79846 1195.5 4.28 3.14 ok * opm2-z7-s2 1179 141.1 1472 954.8 1.25 6.77 1299 248.4 1.10 1.76 4401 1805.5 3.73 12.80 ok * pg5_34 113092 322.7 84360 1931.0 0.75 5.98 196472 573.3 1.74 1.78 326269 2359.4 2.88 7.31 ok * pigeon-10 5802311 1238.0 712986 > 3648.4 0.12 2.95 6270758 1280.4 1.08 1.03 2378246 > 3640.9 0.41 2.94 ok * pw-myciel4 15518 100.6 46658 > 3603.6 3.01 35.82 157099 719.5 10.12 7.15 207313 > 3647.7 13.36 36.26 ok * qiu 4559 26.0 9946 181.0 2.18 6.96 5755 37.1 1.26 1.43 10637 79.8 2.33 3.07 ok * rail507 9638 884.1 14885 > 3609.3 1.54 4.08 2525 337.3 0.26 0.38 1472 2252.3 0.15 2.55 ok * ran16x16 63425 112.6 154335 755.3 2.43 6.71 116899 137.4 1.84 1.22 468581 391.1 7.39 3.47 ok * reblock67 565165 885.3 174657 2026.6 0.31 2.29 410137 746.6 0.73 0.84 140594 493.7 0.25 0.56 ok * rmatr100-p10 1017 38.3 3242 231.3 3.19 6.04 1612 64.9 1.59 1.69 877 264.0 0.86 6.89 ok * rmatr100-p5 683 72.4 1518 218.8 2.22 3.02 1358 155.8 1.99 2.15 433 811.6 0.63 11.21 ok * rmine6 1025861 3584.4 321466 > 3609.2 0.31 1.01 425503 641.5 0.41 0.18 440802 > 3637.6 0.43 1.01 ok rocII-4-11 138989 329.4 14771 > 3600.0 0.11 10.93 11152 216.3 0.08 0.66 29263 ! 728.1 0.21 2.21 fail * rococoC10-001000 36279 520.5 42014 2035.3 1.16 3.91 816140 3203.0 22.50 6.15 481705 2804.2 13.28 5.39 ok * roll3000 15873 92.4 26705 2157.0 1.68 23.34 4889 68.3 0.31 0.74 497371 > 3614.3 31.33 39.12 ok * satellites1-25 13648 795.2 20904 2785.7 1.53 3.50 825 167.4 0.06 0.21 4591 > 3621.8 0.34 4.55 ok * sp98ic 108015 849.5 80576 > 3613.3 0.75 4.25 9482 236.5 0.09 0.28 33476 > 3618.6 0.31 4.26 ok * sp98ir 4523 34.9 6352 128.6 1.40 3.68 3966 50.6 0.88 1.45 8310 147.7 1.84 4.23 ok * tanglegram1 29 2292.3 101 > 3624.8 3.48 1.58 31 8.3 1.07 0.00 33 2293.3 1.14 1.00 ok * tanglegram2 3 98.9 202 206.7 67.33 2.09 15 0.9 5.00 0.01 3 10.3 1.00 0.10 ok * timtab1 556184 646.5 1031163 > 3631.7 1.85 5.62 626996 622.3 1.13 0.96 1702639 1171.4 3.06 1.81 ok * triptim1 1 106.8 1 193.8 1.00 1.81 1 74.3 1.00 0.70 # 18 > 3610.6 18.00 33.81 ok * unitcal_7 1460 173.4 1804 2406.0 1.24 13.88 2534 263.7 1.74 1.52 20157 3583.5 13.81 20.67 ok * vpphard 5432 488.0 # 272 > 3605.9 0.05 7.39 41425 > 3600.7 7.63 7.38 1541 > 3608.1 0.28 7.39 ok * zib54-UUE 12780 > 3600.1 77261 > 3632.8 6.05 1.01 39784 1925.8 3.11 0.53 388611 > 3652.4 30.41 1.01 ok --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- total (82) 21039705 74420 10794551 205193 17780206 63331 23430624 157672 geom. mean 6149 249.1 12857 1732.8 2.09 6.96 5682 232.7 0.92 0.93 15391 1084.6 2.50 4.35 shifted geom. 10079 271.1 16101 1743.7 1.60 6.43 9480 261.0 0.94 0.96 19496 1105.4 1.93 4.08 --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- all proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score CPLEX(default) 87 82 0 13 74 49 0 0 0 0 83 6149 10079 1.00 1.00 249.1 271.1 1.00 1.00 1.00 CBC(default) 87 82 3 43 39 6 0 69 1 17 73 12857 16101 2.09 1.60 1732.8 1743.7 6.96 6.43 0.22 GUROBI(default) 87 82 0 7 79 41 32 38 3 0 84 5682 9480 0.92 0.94 232.7 261.0 0.93 0.96 0.98 SCIP(default) 87 82 2 30 53 12 6 60 3 10 81 15391 19496 2.50 1.93 1084.6 1105.4 4.35 4.08 0.32 optimal auto settings 0 6 81 33 4 84 2106 3886 0.34 0.39 151.4 174.2 0.61 0.64 diff proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score CBC(default) 42 39 3 0 39 0 0 39 0 0 37 5759 7903 2.43 1.81 770.5 777.8 8.59 8.03 0.17 GUROBI(default) 71 67 0 0 71 29 25 36 0 0 68 3475 6043 0.77 0.85 147.5 167.1 0.95 1.00 0.94 SCIP(default) 52 49 2 0 50 5 4 40 0 0 49 10981 13829 2.76 2.08 537.1 551.0 4.11 3.88 0.30 equal proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score GUROBI(default) 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 1.00 1.00 56.4 56.4 6.80 6.80 0.15 SCIP(default) 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 1.00 1.00 165.7 165.7 19.96 19.96 0.10 timeout proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score CBC(default) 45 43 0 43 0 6 0 30 1 17 36 26638 30614 1.82 1.43 3613.7 3613.7 5.75 5.43 0.28 GUROBI(default) 15 14 0 7 7 12 7 1 3 0 15 110815 111089 2.15 1.55 2285.0 2287.8 0.73 0.73 1.37 SCIP(default) 34 32 0 30 2 7 2 19 3 10 31 34885 38866 2.22 1.77 3374.5 3375.6 4.53 4.35 0.34 all optimal proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score CPLEX(default) 34 34 0 0 35 27 0 0 0 0 32 2719 4753 1.00 1.00 80.4 87.3 1.00 1.00 1.00 CBC(default) 34 34 0 0 34 0 0 34 0 0 32 6941 8671 2.55 1.82 707.0 713.8 8.80 8.18 0.16 GUROBI(default) 34 34 0 0 34 9 7 24 0 0 32 3026 5471 1.11 1.15 109.5 126.5 1.36 1.45 0.68 SCIP(default) 34 34 0 0 34 3 3 29 0 0 32 7754 10238 2.85 2.15 385.4 398.4 4.79 4.57 0.27 total time over all settings: 534386.2 sec = 148.4 hours = 6.2 days = 0.9 weeks = 0.2 months ====^^^^==== miplibbench ====^^^^====