## Solver Square Comparison: Considers all models.

Results created on 11/21/12 12:10:36 using the PAVER Server/Performance tools available at http://www.gamsworld.eu/performance/paver

Compares all solver return outcomes (for example optimal, locally optimal, infeasible, unbounded, fail) of one solver with all return outcomes of another solver. Interrupt denotes resource or iteration limit has been reached.

Solver BARON_baron is represented on the left (rows) and solver LINDO_lindo on top (columns).

See the solver return definitions for return codes. Models having trace data only in one trace file are listed in the "no data" column of the other.

Input File Number Filename
Tracefile 1: minlplib_baron.pav
Tracefile 2: minlplib_lindo.pav
Solvers used : BARON_baron
LINDO_lindo
Modeltype(s)   MINLP

 LINDO_lindo: optimal LINDO_lindo: locally optimal LINDO_lindo: feasible LINDO_lindo: infeasible LINDO_lindo: unbounded LINDO_lindo: fail LINDO_lindo: no data total BARON_baron BARON_baron: optimal 126 - 9 - - 4 - 139 BARON_baron: locally optimal - - - - - - - - BARON_baron: feasible 7 - 43 - - 17 - 67 BARON_baron: infeasible - - - - - - - - BARON_baron: unbounded - - - - - - - - BARON_baron: fail 5 - 24 - - 17 - 46 BARON_baron: no data - - - - - - - - total LINDO_lindo 138 - 76 - - 38 - 252

### Solver return definitions:

Outcome Model Status Solver Status
optimal 1 or 15 1
locally optimal 2 any
feasible 8 or 16 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5
infeasible 4 or 5 or 10 or 19 1
unbounded 3 or 18 1
fail all other all other

### Solver Resource Times

• Models for each solver pair outcome. Listed are the solver resource times TIME(.) in seconds, as well as the ratio RATIO(./.) of resource times for the two solvers if both solved optimally.
• Also listed are the objective values OBJ(.) using both solvers. The better solution found is listed in boldface. A solution is considered better, if the relative objective function difference is greater than 1.50E-04. If both solutions are less than 1e-1, we use the absolute difference.
• Solver resource time ratios for a particular model are listed only if one solver has resource greater than 5.00E-02.

### BARON_baron: optimal -- LINDO_lindo: optimal

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Obj (BARON_baron) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
alan 0.8410 0.3160 2.661 2.92500000 2.92500000
batchdes 3.5860 2.0370 1.760 167428.00000000 167428.00000000
batch 4.7270 4.9730 0.951 285507.00000000 285507.00000000
csched1a 0.9380 2.4430 0.384 -30430.20000000 -30430.20000000
csched1 6.2770 12.1180 0.518 -30639.30000000 -30639.30000000
du-opt5 17.3280 5742.5300 0.003 8.07366000 8.07366000
elf 6.3430 6.1960 1.024 0.19166700 0.19166600
enpro48 8.3220 24.4050 0.341 187277.00000000 187277.00000000
enpro48pb 8.0960 28.8390 0.281 187277.00000000 187277.00000000
enpro56 29.3910 128.0530 0.230 263428.00000000 263428.00000000
enpro56pb 39.2040 142.0760 0.276 263428.00000000 263428.00000000
ex1221 4.6250 0.0560 82.589 7.66718000 7.66718000
ex1222 0.9410 0.0980 9.602 1.07654000 1.07654000
ex1223a 0.9960 0.1170 8.513 4.57958000 4.57958000
ex1223b 3.5870 0.1830 19.601 4.57958000 4.57958000
ex1223 4.7200 0.2040 23.137 4.57958000 4.57958000
ex1224 3.4960 0.6740 5.187 -0.94347000 -0.94347100
ex1225 1.9250 0.1060 18.160 31.00000000 31.00000000
ex1226 0.1470 0.1180 1.246 -17.00000000 -17.00000000
ex1243 2.3320 4.9850 0.468 83402.50000000 83402.50000000
ex1244 5.4590 34.4800 0.158 82042.90000000 82042.90000000
ex1263a 0.8300 3.6160 0.230 19.60000000 19.60000000
ex1263 1.5320 9.0530 0.169 19.60000000 19.60000000
ex1264a 0.7200 1.6440 0.438 8.60000000 8.60000000
ex1264 1.0750 38.1960 0.028 8.60000000 8.60000000
ex1265a 0.8950 2.3980 0.373 10.30000000 10.30000000
ex1265 1.6890 7.2020 0.235 10.30000000 10.30000000
ex1266a 0.2470 0.4140 0.597 16.30000000 16.30000000
ex1266 1.4940 2.4080 0.620 16.30000000 16.30000000
ex3 0.2840 0.3130 0.907 68.00960000 68.00970000
ex3pb 0.1460 0.3320 0.440 68.00960000 68.00970000
ex4 1.9890 5.9290 0.335 -8.06414000 -8.06414000
fac1 0.1330 0.9990 0.133 160913000.00000000 160913000.00000000
fac2 1.0550 8.0990 0.130 331837000.00000000 331837000.00000000
fac3 1.0260 31.7350 0.032 31982300.00000000 31982300.00000000
feedtray2 2.3100 24.3880 0.095 0.00000000 0.00000000
fuel 0.1730 0.2480 0.698 8566.12000000 8566.12000000
gastrans 1.7280 2.2190 0.779 89.08580000 89.08580000
gbd 0.0760 0.1000 0.760 2.20000000 2.20000000
gear2 0.4280 0.2710 1.579 0.00000000 0.00000027
gear3 0.3100 0.2290 1.354 0.00000000 0.00000046
gear4 0.4840 74.4940 0.006 1.64343000 1.64343000
gear 0.2550 0.1440 1.771 0.00000000 0.00000080
gkocis 0.1640 0.1310 1.252 -1.92311000 -1.92310000
hmittelman 0.3040 0.1080 2.815 13.00000000 13.00000000
johnall 3.7800 52.8910 0.071 -224.73000000 -224.73000000
m3 1.0260 1.5800 0.649 37.80000000 37.80000000
m6 397.4010 142.3350 2.792 82.25690000 82.25690000
m7_ar2_1 132.9040 683.3690 0.194 190.23500000 190.23500000
m7_ar25_1 220.4240 314.9880 0.700 143.58500000 143.58500000
m7_ar4_1 6447.2300 709.4140 9.088 106.75700000 106.75700000
m7_ar5_1 7018.6900 1976.4200 3.551 106.46000000 106.46000000
meanvarx 0.0850 1.1950 0.071 14.36920000 14.36920000
nous1 172.5990 36.0880 4.783 1.56707000 1.56707000
nous2 0.5070 0.9110 0.557 0.62596700 0.62596700
nvs01 0.2490 0.2590 0.961 12.46970000 12.46970000
nvs02 0.0950 0.4470 0.213 5.96418000 5.96418000
nvs03 0.0960 0.1560 0.615 16.00000000 16.00000000
nvs04 0.0980 0.2230 0.439 0.72000000 0.72000000
nvs06 0.0790 0.1670 0.473 1.77031000 1.77031000
nvs07 0.0990 0.1250 0.792 4.00000000 4.00000000
nvs08 0.1260 0.2560 0.492 23.44970000 23.44970000
nvs09 0.1450 8.1030 0.018 -43.13430000 -43.13430000
nvs10 0.0770 0.1450 0.531 -310.80000000 -310.80000000
nvs11 0.1110 1.0820 0.103 -431.00000000 -431.00000000
nvs12 0.1490 4.5430 0.033 -481.20000000 -481.20000000
nvs13 0.2400 19.9060 0.012 -585.20000000 -585.20000000
nvs14 0.1190 0.3350 0.355 -40358.20000000 -40358.20000000
nvs15 0.0900 0.1580 0.570 1.00000000 1.00000000
nvs16 0.1010 0.1500 0.673 0.70312500 0.70312500
nvs17 1.2240 3255.3100 0.000 -1100.40000000 -1100.40000000
nvs18 0.5640 610.2380 0.001 -778.40000000 -778.40000000
nvs20 1.1640 5.8950 0.197 230.92200000 230.92200000
nvs21 0.1070 1.2620 0.085 -5.68478000 -5.68478000
nvs22 2.4260 0.5980 4.057 6.05822000 6.05822000
oaer 0.1290 0.1270 1.016 -1.92310000 -1.92310000
ortez 0.3190 2.4330 0.131 -9532.04000000 -9532.04000000
parallel 10.3680 223.7820 0.046 924.25100000 924.29600000
prob02 0.1230 0.1250 0.984 112235.00000000 112235.00000000
prob03 0.0780 0.1200 0.650 10.00000000 10.00000000
procsel 0.1140 0.1220 0.934 -1.92310000 -1.92310000
ravem 1.1560 20.9290 0.055 269590.00000000 269590.00000000
ravempb 1.1740 13.0570 0.090 269590.00000000 269590.00000000
risk2b 1.3880 5.4320 0.256 -55.87610000 -55.87610000
risk2bpb 1.3060 2.7810 0.470 -55.87610000 -55.87610000
sep1 0.3170 0.3030 1.046 -510.08100000 -510.08100000
spectra2 2.4300 39.6700 0.061 13.97830000 13.97830000
spring 0.5960 1.8270 0.326 0.84624600 0.84624600
st_e13 0.0750 0.0890 0.843 2.00000000 2.00000000
st_e14 0.1410 0.2040 0.691 4.57958000 4.57958000
st_e15 0.0880 0.1130 0.779 7.66718000 7.66718000
st_e27 0.0860 0.1050 0.819 2.00000000 2.00000000
st_e29 0.1810 0.6770 0.267 -0.94347000 -0.94347100
st_e31 1.1750 3.9680 0.296 -2.00001000 -2.00000000
st_e32 0.8920 23.6710 0.038 -1.43041000 -1.43041000
st_e35 3.2430 37.7480 0.086 64868.10000000 64868.10000000
st_e36 0.3160 2.1420 0.148 -246.00000000 -246.00000000
st_e38 0.1200 0.4090 0.293 7197.73000000 7197.73000000
st_miqp1 0.0920 0.1170 0.786 281.00000000 281.00000000
st_miqp2 0.0790 0.1490 0.530 2.00000000 2.00000000
st_miqp3 0.0770 0.1110 0.694 -6.00000000 -6.00000000
st_miqp4 0.0880 0.1040 0.846 -4574.00000000 -4574.00000000
st_miqp5 0.0940 0.1120 0.839 -333.88900000 -333.88900000
stockcycle 44.8540 122.0880 0.367 119949.00000000 119949.00000000
st_test1 0.1130 0.1600 0.706 0.00000000 0.00000000
st_test2 0.0900 0.1210 0.744 -9.25000000 -9.25000000
st_test3 0.0790 0.5000 0.158 -7.00000000 -7.00000000
st_test4 0.0920 0.1590 0.579 -7.00000000 -7.00000000
st_test5 0.1070 0.1060 1.009 -110.00000000 -110.00000000
st_test6 0.1100 0.0670 1.642 471.00000000 471.00000000
st_test8 0.0960 0.5710 0.168 -29605.00000000 -29605.00000000
st_testgr1 0.2020 1.4780 0.137 -12.81160000 -12.81160000
st_testgr3 0.5700 1.8040 0.316 -20.59000000 -20.59000000
st_testph4 0.0750 0.0540 1.389 -80.50000000 -80.50000000
synheat 102.2550 1981.7200 0.052 154997.00000000 154997.00000000
synthes1 0.1190 0.1460 0.815 6.00976000 6.00976000
synthes2 0.1870 0.3150 0.594 73.03530000 73.03530000
synthes3 0.2550 1.3490 0.189 68.00970000 68.00970000
tln2 0.1250 0.2210 0.566 5.30000000 5.30000000
tln4 1.1160 7.4460 0.150 8.30000000 8.30000000
tln5 2.5170 163.3880 0.015 10.30000000 10.30000000
tln6 4.1990 158.9370 0.026 15.30000000 15.30000000
tloss 0.2650 0.8970 0.295 16.30000000 16.30000000
tls4 624.1230 713.9240 0.874 8.30000000 8.30000000
tltr 0.5170 1.2040 0.429 48.06670000 48.06670000
util 0.9890 4.3570 0.227 999.57900000 999.57900000

### BARON_baron: optimal -- LINDO_lindo: feasible

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Obj (BARON_baron) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
du-opt 15.5250 7200.7400 0.002 3.55634000 3.62371000
ex1233 52.1050 7200.3200 0.007 155011.00000000 155011.00000000
fo7_ar2_1 1579.9900 7200.3000 0.219 24.83980000 42.79820000
netmod_dol2 4619.1300 7203.9900 0.641 -0.56000800 -0.52958200
netmod_kar1 621.6800 7202.5300 0.086 -0.41979000 -0.41740600
netmod_kar2 623.5150 7200.4700 0.087 -0.41979000 -0.41979000
nvs19 2.0690 7200.8600 0.000 -1098.40000000 -1098.40000000
nvs23 12.4410 7202.4100 0.002 -1125.20000000 -1125.20000000
nvs24 17.6910 7200.4100 0.002 -1033.20000000 -1033.20000000

### BARON_baron: optimal -- LINDO_lindo: fail

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Obj (BARON_baron) Status (LINDO_lindo)
eniplac 3489.9700 192.1720 --- -132117.00000000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
ghg_1veh 9.0520 5.8060 --- 7.78163000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
st_e40 0.3290 0.1060 --- 30.41420000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
tls2 0.7250 2.1220 --- 5.30000000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)

### BARON_baron: feasible -- LINDO_lindo: optimal

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Obj (BARON_baron) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
cecil_13 7219.2000 6793.2000 1.063 -115584.00000000 -115656.00000000
eg_disc2_s 7220.1600 2316.0100 3.117 5.64951000 5.64210000
gasnet 7219.0200 351.6060 20.532 6999380.00000000 6999380.00000000
m7_ar3_1 7220.2600 1468.8600 4.916 143.58500000 143.58500000
m7 7219.6100 1110.1000 6.504 106.75700000 106.75700000
oil2 7219.8900 105.5430 68.407 -0.73311100 -0.73326000
space25a 7219.0800 129.2880 55.837 493.91400000 484.32900000

### BARON_baron: feasible -- LINDO_lindo: feasible

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Obj (BARON_baron) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
csched2a 7223.5000 7200.7900 1.003 -161625.00000000 -164274.00000000
csched2 7224.0200 7200.6500 1.003 -156416.00000000 -165364.00000000
eg_disc_s 7223.1900 7202.4800 1.003 5.76054000 5.76054000
feedtray 7219.3500 7201.4400 1.002 -13.40600000 -13.40600000
fo7_2 7221.1300 7201.6700 1.003 17.74930000 28.21090000
fo7_ar25_1 7219.7800 7200.9300 1.003 24.97350000 23.12100000
fo7_ar3_1 7221.0400 7200.3300 1.003 22.51750000 28.71720000
fo7_ar4_1 7219.5800 7201.1500 1.003 20.72980000 32.73630000
fo7_ar5_1 7219.6000 7200.2000 1.003 20.78760000 26.34560000
fo7 7219.3400 7200.9500 1.003 22.83330000 29.97440000
ghg_2veh 7219.0100 7200.1900 1.003 7.77090000 7.77091000
lop97ic 7223.0200 7795.8300 0.927 5338.05000000 4119.16000000
lop97icx 7219.0100 7203.0000 1.002 4180.26000000 4184.32000000
netmod_dol1 7219.4000 7202.1200 1.002 -0.50451800 -0.09880490
no7_ar2_1 7219.4300 7200.7200 1.003 107.87100000 141.39300000
no7_ar25_1 7219.3300 7200.3100 1.003 123.52200000 146.65000000
no7_ar3_1 7221.1300 7200.6200 1.003 109.39800000 116.37000000
no7_ar4_1 7219.8200 7200.8000 1.003 98.88350000 116.84900000
no7_ar5_1 7219.1300 7200.4800 1.003 102.91400000 117.07500000
nuclear14a 7221.3800 7202.2600 1.003 -1.12876000 -1.12925000
nuclear14b 7220.6100 7201.2700 1.003 -1.11842000 -1.11029000
nuclear14 7220.9200 7202.0000 1.003 -1.12792000 -1.12632000
nuclear24a 7221.6300 7201.0900 1.003 -1.12876000 -1.12925000
nuclear24b 7219.8700 7204.4900 1.002 -1.11842000 -1.11029000
nuclear24 7219.3400 7201.0000 1.003 -1.12792000 -1.12632000
nuclear49a 7219.3300 7201.4800 1.002 -1.15119000 -1.15121000
nuclearvc 7219.2100 7201.0900 1.003 -1.00036000 -1.00105000
nuclearve 7219.4400 7200.6900 1.003 -1.03430000 -1.03635000
o7_2 7219.5800 7201.0400 1.003 121.06200000 148.48000000
o7_ar25_1 7219.4000 7200.9600 1.003 146.50800000 169.16100000
o7_ar3_1 7219.0700 7200.6900 1.003 145.21800000 157.35100000
o7_ar4_1 7221.2700 7200.2700 1.003 138.36600000 154.27300000
o7_ar5_1 7219.2200 7201.3000 1.002 128.40400000 146.65300000
o7 7220.7600 7201.3700 1.003 151.72400000 152.25600000
pb302035 7220.4900 7340.7800 0.984 4432220.00000000 3923680.00000000
qap 7220.8500 7216.7600 1.001 392834.00000000 431074.00000000
tln12 7218.9300 7201.3200 1.002 123.80000000 104.50000000
tln7 7218.9500 7201.0900 1.002 15.70000000 16.50000000
tls5 7219.0200 7200.3100 1.003 10.60000000 10.60000000
tls6 7218.9700 7200.7600 1.003 19.00000000 27.50000000
tls7 7218.9600 7202.2400 1.002 28.10000000 27.30000000
waste 7219.3100 7207.5100 1.002 598.91900000 745.90500000
waterx 7219.0100 7200.8500 1.003 940.08500000 948.93000000

### BARON_baron: feasible -- LINDO_lindo: fail

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Obj (BARON_baron) Status (LINDO_lindo)
eg_all_s 7220.9300 739.7370 --- 7.82182000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
eg_int_s 7222.3200 678.4570 --- 6.45310000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
fo8_ar2_1 7219.9500 7203.6800 --- 47.42120000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo8_ar4_1 7219.6600 7200.7500 --- 32.36230000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo8_ar5_1 7219.9400 7200.4600 --- 37.39010000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo8 7219.1600 7200.9500 --- 39.50440000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9_ar25_1 7219.8400 7201.2900 --- 54.72000000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
ghg_3veh 7219.1200 1.2830 --- 7.75432000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
mbtd 7219.5500 0.0000 --- 5.49999000 mstat(13)sstat(13)
nuclear49b 7219.9500 7200.7900 --- -1.12214000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclearva 7219.6800 0.0000 --- -1.01323000 mstat(13)sstat(13)
nuclearvb 7219.2100 58.9170 --- -1.02782000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
nuclearvd 7220.5600 123.4360 --- -1.03763000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
nuclearvf 7219.8100 260.5250 --- -1.02293000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)
o7_ar2_1 7219.0500 7200.4300 --- 140.41200000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
o8_ar4_1 7223.4400 7201.2500 --- 297.75000000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
space25 7219.3300 147.8500 --- 531.36200000 mstat(13)sstat( 1)

### BARON_baron: fail -- LINDO_lindo: optimal

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Status (BARON_baron) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
ex1252a 11.8420 122.5510 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 128894.00000000
ex1252 20.6600 1033.4000 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 128894.00000000
nvs05 8.4010 0.3060 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 5.47093000
product 6.8260 3728.0700 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) -2142.95000000
pump 10.4700 118.7040 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 128894.00000000

### BARON_baron: fail -- LINDO_lindo: feasible

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Status (BARON_baron) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
4stufen 116.7660 7200.5500 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 117099.00000000
beuster 18.1440 7200.2800 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 117147.00000000
contvar 7219.3300 7201.1600 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 809150.00000000
fo8_ar25_1 7220.8600 7200.6000 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 34.54870000
fo8_ar3_1 7219.7700 7200.6400 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 54.82100000
fo9_ar2_1 7219.1800 7200.6000 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 41.12500000
fo9_ar4_1 7219.8800 7200.9000 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 48.43550000
minlphix 7219.1300 7200.2700 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 316.69300000
nuclear25a 7219.3200 7203.8100 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) -1.12022000
nuclear25b 7221.9800 7202.6300 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) -1.07663000
nuclear25 7219.1400 7202.9600 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) -1.11536000
pb302055 7220.5200 7507.7400 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 4158700.00000000
pb302075 7220.2200 7636.4400 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 4449650.00000000
pb302095 7220.2800 8484.8100 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 6006690.00000000
pb351535 0.0000 7401.4600 --- mstat(13)sstat(13) 5116370.00000000
pb351555 0.0000 7549.7100 --- mstat(13)sstat(13) 5206860.00000000
pb351575 0.0000 7457.2300 --- mstat(13)sstat(13) 6527830.00000000
pb351595 0.0000 8704.5100 --- mstat(13)sstat(13) 7206560.00000000
product2 6.0350 7200.6700 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) -2099.14000000
qapw 0.9160 7200.6100 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 410614.00000000
saa_2 7219.8100 8397.6700 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) 12.71370000
super3t 7219.4200 7201.5600 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) -0.65348300
water4 0.9450 7201.1200 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 923.75100000
waterz 1.1950 7200.8100 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) 958.68700000

### BARON_baron: fail -- LINDO_lindo: fail

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Time (LINDO_lindo) Ratio (BARON_baron/LINDO_lindo) Status (BARON_baron) Status (LINDO_lindo)
chp_partload 7223.6000 7204.7200 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9_ar3_1 7219.2200 7201.7100 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9_ar5_1 7219.6900 7200.3000 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9 7219.7200 7200.3800 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
hda 421.8540 32.1550 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) mstat(13)sstat( 1)
nuclear104 7219.7800 7205.0900 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclear10a 7224.1400 7202.1600 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclear10b 7220.9400 7200.8900 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclear49 7220.2500 7201.2900 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
o9_ar4_1 7220.3800 7200.6800 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
oil 7219.3900 1511.8400 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(13)sstat( 1)
space960 7219.3300 7200.8100 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
super1 0.3380 0.0000 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) mstat(13)sstat(13)
super2 0.3400 0.0000 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) mstat(13)sstat(13)
super3 0.3410 7204.7100 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
tls12 7219.0500 7202.5100 --- mstat(14)sstat( 3) mstat(14)sstat( 3)
uselinear 163.2310 148.0770 --- mstat(13)sstat( 1) mstat(13)sstat( 1)

### BARON_baron: optimal:

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Obj (BARON_baron)
alan 0.8410 2.92500000
batchdes 3.5860 167428.00000000
batch 4.7270 285507.00000000
csched1a 0.9380 -30430.20000000
csched1 6.2770 -30639.30000000
du-opt5 17.3280 8.07366000
du-opt 15.5250 3.55634000
elf 6.3430 0.19166700
eniplac 3489.9700 -132117.00000000
enpro48 8.3220 187277.00000000
enpro48pb 8.0960 187277.00000000
enpro56 29.3910 263428.00000000
enpro56pb 39.2040 263428.00000000
ex1221 4.6250 7.66718000
ex1222 0.9410 1.07654000
ex1223a 0.9960 4.57958000
ex1223b 3.5870 4.57958000
ex1223 4.7200 4.57958000
ex1224 3.4960 -0.94347000
ex1225 1.9250 31.00000000
ex1226 0.1470 -17.00000000
ex1233 52.1050 155011.00000000
ex1243 2.3320 83402.50000000
ex1244 5.4590 82042.90000000
ex1263a 0.8300 19.60000000
ex1263 1.5320 19.60000000
ex1264a 0.7200 8.60000000
ex1264 1.0750 8.60000000
ex1265a 0.8950 10.30000000
ex1265 1.6890 10.30000000
ex1266a 0.2470 16.30000000
ex1266 1.4940 16.30000000
ex3 0.2840 68.00960000
ex3pb 0.1460 68.00960000
ex4 1.9890 -8.06414000
fac1 0.1330 160913000.00000000
fac2 1.0550 331837000.00000000
fac3 1.0260 31982300.00000000
feedtray2 2.3100 0.00000000
fo7_ar2_1 1579.9900 24.83980000
fuel 0.1730 8566.12000000
gastrans 1.7280 89.08580000
gbd 0.0760 2.20000000
ghg_1veh 9.0520 7.78163000
gear2 0.4280 0.00000000
gear3 0.3100 0.00000000
gear4 0.4840 1.64343000
gear 0.2550 0.00000000
gkocis 0.1640 -1.92311000
hmittelman 0.3040 13.00000000
johnall 3.7800 -224.73000000
m3 1.0260 37.80000000
m6 397.4010 82.25690000
m7_ar2_1 132.9040 190.23500000
m7_ar25_1 220.4240 143.58500000
m7_ar4_1 6447.2300 106.75700000
m7_ar5_1 7018.6900 106.46000000
meanvarx 0.0850 14.36920000
netmod_dol2 4619.1300 -0.56000800
netmod_kar1 621.6800 -0.41979000
netmod_kar2 623.5150 -0.41979000
nous1 172.5990 1.56707000
nous2 0.5070 0.62596700
nvs01 0.2490 12.46970000
nvs02 0.0950 5.96418000
nvs03 0.0960 16.00000000
nvs04 0.0980 0.72000000
nvs06 0.0790 1.77031000
nvs07 0.0990 4.00000000
nvs08 0.1260 23.44970000
nvs09 0.1450 -43.13430000
nvs10 0.0770 -310.80000000
nvs11 0.1110 -431.00000000
nvs12 0.1490 -481.20000000
nvs13 0.2400 -585.20000000
nvs14 0.1190 -40358.20000000
nvs15 0.0900 1.00000000
nvs16 0.1010 0.70312500
nvs17 1.2240 -1100.40000000
nvs18 0.5640 -778.40000000
nvs19 2.0690 -1098.40000000
nvs20 1.1640 230.92200000
nvs21 0.1070 -5.68478000
nvs22 2.4260 6.05822000
nvs23 12.4410 -1125.20000000
nvs24 17.6910 -1033.20000000
oaer 0.1290 -1.92310000
ortez 0.3190 -9532.04000000
parallel 10.3680 924.25100000
prob02 0.1230 112235.00000000
prob03 0.0780 10.00000000
procsel 0.1140 -1.92310000
ravem 1.1560 269590.00000000
ravempb 1.1740 269590.00000000
risk2b 1.3880 -55.87610000
risk2bpb 1.3060 -55.87610000
sep1 0.3170 -510.08100000
spectra2 2.4300 13.97830000
spring 0.5960 0.84624600
st_e13 0.0750 2.00000000
st_e14 0.1410 4.57958000
st_e15 0.0880 7.66718000
st_e27 0.0860 2.00000000
st_e29 0.1810 -0.94347000
st_e31 1.1750 -2.00001000
st_e32 0.8920 -1.43041000
st_e35 3.2430 64868.10000000
st_e36 0.3160 -246.00000000
st_e38 0.1200 7197.73000000
st_e40 0.3290 30.41420000
st_miqp1 0.0920 281.00000000
st_miqp2 0.0790 2.00000000
st_miqp3 0.0770 -6.00000000
st_miqp4 0.0880 -4574.00000000
st_miqp5 0.0940 -333.88900000
stockcycle 44.8540 119949.00000000
st_test1 0.1130 0.00000000
st_test2 0.0900 -9.25000000
st_test3 0.0790 -7.00000000
st_test4 0.0920 -7.00000000
st_test5 0.1070 -110.00000000
st_test6 0.1100 471.00000000
st_test8 0.0960 -29605.00000000
st_testgr1 0.2020 -12.81160000
st_testgr3 0.5700 -20.59000000
st_testph4 0.0750 -80.50000000
synheat 102.2550 154997.00000000
synthes1 0.1190 6.00976000
synthes2 0.1870 73.03530000
synthes3 0.2550 68.00970000
tln2 0.1250 5.30000000
tln4 1.1160 8.30000000
tln5 2.5170 10.30000000
tln6 4.1990 15.30000000
tloss 0.2650 16.30000000
tls2 0.7250 5.30000000
tls4 624.1230 8.30000000
tltr 0.5170 48.06670000
util 0.9890 999.57900000

### BARON_baron: feasible:

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Obj (BARON_baron)
cecil_13 7219.2000 -115584.00000000
csched2a 7223.5000 -161625.00000000
csched2 7224.0200 -156416.00000000
eg_all_s 7220.9300 7.82182000
eg_disc2_s 7220.1600 5.64951000
eg_disc_s 7223.1900 5.76054000
eg_int_s 7222.3200 6.45310000
feedtray 7219.3500 -13.40600000
fo7_2 7221.1300 17.74930000
fo7_ar25_1 7219.7800 24.97350000
fo7_ar3_1 7221.0400 22.51750000
fo7_ar4_1 7219.5800 20.72980000
fo7_ar5_1 7219.6000 20.78760000
fo7 7219.3400 22.83330000
fo8_ar2_1 7219.9500 47.42120000
fo8_ar4_1 7219.6600 32.36230000
fo8_ar5_1 7219.9400 37.39010000
fo8 7219.1600 39.50440000
fo9_ar25_1 7219.8400 54.72000000
gasnet 7219.0200 6999380.00000000
ghg_2veh 7219.0100 7.77090000
ghg_3veh 7219.1200 7.75432000
lop97ic 7223.0200 5338.05000000
lop97icx 7219.0100 4180.26000000
m7_ar3_1 7220.2600 143.58500000
m7 7219.6100 106.75700000
mbtd 7219.5500 5.49999000
netmod_dol1 7219.4000 -0.50451800
no7_ar2_1 7219.4300 107.87100000
no7_ar25_1 7219.3300 123.52200000
no7_ar3_1 7221.1300 109.39800000
no7_ar4_1 7219.8200 98.88350000
no7_ar5_1 7219.1300 102.91400000
nuclear14a 7221.3800 -1.12876000
nuclear14b 7220.6100 -1.11842000
nuclear14 7220.9200 -1.12792000
nuclear24a 7221.6300 -1.12876000
nuclear24b 7219.8700 -1.11842000
nuclear24 7219.3400 -1.12792000
nuclear49a 7219.3300 -1.15119000
nuclear49b 7219.9500 -1.12214000
nuclearva 7219.6800 -1.01323000
nuclearvb 7219.2100 -1.02782000
nuclearvc 7219.2100 -1.00036000
nuclearvd 7220.5600 -1.03763000
nuclearve 7219.4400 -1.03430000
nuclearvf 7219.8100 -1.02293000
o7_2 7219.5800 121.06200000
o7_ar2_1 7219.0500 140.41200000
o7_ar25_1 7219.4000 146.50800000
o7_ar3_1 7219.0700 145.21800000
o7_ar4_1 7221.2700 138.36600000
o7_ar5_1 7219.2200 128.40400000
o7 7220.7600 151.72400000
o8_ar4_1 7223.4400 297.75000000
oil2 7219.8900 -0.73311100
pb302035 7220.4900 4432220.00000000
qap 7220.8500 392834.00000000
space25a 7219.0800 493.91400000
space25 7219.3300 531.36200000
tln12 7218.9300 123.80000000
tln7 7218.9500 15.70000000
tls5 7219.0200 10.60000000
tls6 7218.9700 19.00000000
tls7 7218.9600 28.10000000
waste 7219.3100 598.91900000
waterx 7219.0100 940.08500000

### BARON_baron: fail:

Modelname Time (BARON_baron) Status (BARON_baron)
4stufen -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
beuster -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
contvar -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
ex1252a -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
ex1252 -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
fo8_ar25_1 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
fo8_ar3_1 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
fo9_ar2_1 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
fo9_ar3_1 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
fo9_ar4_1 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
fo9_ar5_1 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
fo9 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
hda -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
minlphix -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
nuclear104 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
nuclear10a -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
nuclear10b -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
nuclear25a -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
nuclear25b -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
nuclear25 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
nuclear49 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
nvs05 -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
o9_ar4_1 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
oil -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
pb302055 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
pb302075 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
pb302095 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
pb351535 -- mstat(13) sstat(13)
pb351555 -- mstat(13) sstat(13)
pb351575 -- mstat(13) sstat(13)
pb351595 -- mstat(13) sstat(13)
product2 -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
product -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
pump -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
qapw -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
saa_2 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
space960 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
super1 -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
super2 -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
super3 -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
super3t -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
tls12 -- mstat(14) sstat( 3)
uselinear -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
water4 -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)
waterz -- mstat(13) sstat( 1)

### LINDO_lindo: optimal:

Modelname Time (LINDO_lindo) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
alan 0.3160 2.92500000
batchdes 2.0370 167428.00000000
batch 4.9730 285507.00000000
cecil_13 6793.2000 -115656.00000000
csched1a 2.4430 -30430.20000000
csched1 12.1180 -30639.30000000
du-opt5 5742.5300 8.07366000
eg_disc2_s 2316.0100 5.64210000
elf 6.1960 0.19166600
enpro48 24.4050 187277.00000000
enpro48pb 28.8390 187277.00000000
enpro56 128.0530 263428.00000000
enpro56pb 142.0760 263428.00000000
ex1221 0.0560 7.66718000
ex1222 0.0980 1.07654000
ex1223a 0.1170 4.57958000
ex1223b 0.1830 4.57958000
ex1223 0.2040 4.57958000
ex1224 0.6740 -0.94347100
ex1225 0.1060 31.00000000
ex1226 0.1180 -17.00000000
ex1243 4.9850 83402.50000000
ex1244 34.4800 82042.90000000
ex1252a 122.5510 128894.00000000
ex1252 1033.4000 128894.00000000
ex1263a 3.6160 19.60000000
ex1263 9.0530 19.60000000
ex1264a 1.6440 8.60000000
ex1264 38.1960 8.60000000
ex1265a 2.3980 10.30000000
ex1265 7.2020 10.30000000
ex1266a 0.4140 16.30000000
ex1266 2.4080 16.30000000
ex3 0.3130 68.00970000
ex3pb 0.3320 68.00970000
ex4 5.9290 -8.06414000
fac1 0.9990 160913000.00000000
fac2 8.0990 331837000.00000000
fac3 31.7350 31982300.00000000
feedtray2 24.3880 0.00000000
fuel 0.2480 8566.12000000
gasnet 351.6060 6999380.00000000
gastrans 2.2190 89.08580000
gbd 0.1000 2.20000000
gear2 0.2710 0.00000027
gear3 0.2290 0.00000046
gear4 74.4940 1.64343000
gear 0.1440 0.00000080
gkocis 0.1310 -1.92310000
hmittelman 0.1080 13.00000000
johnall 52.8910 -224.73000000
m3 1.5800 37.80000000
m6 142.3350 82.25690000
m7_ar2_1 683.3690 190.23500000
m7_ar25_1 314.9880 143.58500000
m7_ar3_1 1468.8600 143.58500000
m7_ar4_1 709.4140 106.75700000
m7_ar5_1 1976.4200 106.46000000
m7 1110.1000 106.75700000
meanvarx 1.1950 14.36920000
nous1 36.0880 1.56707000
nous2 0.9110 0.62596700
nvs01 0.2590 12.46970000
nvs02 0.4470 5.96418000
nvs03 0.1560 16.00000000
nvs04 0.2230 0.72000000
nvs05 0.3060 5.47093000
nvs06 0.1670 1.77031000
nvs07 0.1250 4.00000000
nvs08 0.2560 23.44970000
nvs09 8.1030 -43.13430000
nvs10 0.1450 -310.80000000
nvs11 1.0820 -431.00000000
nvs12 4.5430 -481.20000000
nvs13 19.9060 -585.20000000
nvs14 0.3350 -40358.20000000
nvs15 0.1580 1.00000000
nvs16 0.1500 0.70312500
nvs17 3255.3100 -1100.40000000
nvs18 610.2380 -778.40000000
nvs20 5.8950 230.92200000
nvs21 1.2620 -5.68478000
nvs22 0.5980 6.05822000
oaer 0.1270 -1.92310000
oil2 105.5430 -0.73326000
ortez 2.4330 -9532.04000000
parallel 223.7820 924.29600000
prob02 0.1250 112235.00000000
prob03 0.1200 10.00000000
procsel 0.1220 -1.92310000
product 3728.0700 -2142.95000000
pump 118.7040 128894.00000000
ravem 20.9290 269590.00000000
ravempb 13.0570 269590.00000000
risk2b 5.4320 -55.87610000
risk2bpb 2.7810 -55.87610000
sep1 0.3030 -510.08100000
space25a 129.2880 484.32900000
spectra2 39.6700 13.97830000
spring 1.8270 0.84624600
st_e13 0.0890 2.00000000
st_e14 0.2040 4.57958000
st_e15 0.1130 7.66718000
st_e27 0.1050 2.00000000
st_e29 0.6770 -0.94347100
st_e31 3.9680 -2.00000000
st_e32 23.6710 -1.43041000
st_e35 37.7480 64868.10000000
st_e36 2.1420 -246.00000000
st_e38 0.4090 7197.73000000
st_miqp1 0.1170 281.00000000
st_miqp2 0.1490 2.00000000
st_miqp3 0.1110 -6.00000000
st_miqp4 0.1040 -4574.00000000
st_miqp5 0.1120 -333.88900000
stockcycle 122.0880 119949.00000000
st_test1 0.1600 0.00000000
st_test2 0.1210 -9.25000000
st_test3 0.5000 -7.00000000
st_test4 0.1590 -7.00000000
st_test5 0.1060 -110.00000000
st_test6 0.0670 471.00000000
st_test8 0.5710 -29605.00000000
st_testgr1 1.4780 -12.81160000
st_testgr3 1.8040 -20.59000000
st_testph4 0.0540 -80.50000000
synheat 1981.7200 154997.00000000
synthes1 0.1460 6.00976000
synthes2 0.3150 73.03530000
synthes3 1.3490 68.00970000
tln2 0.2210 5.30000000
tln4 7.4460 8.30000000
tln5 163.3880 10.30000000
tln6 158.9370 15.30000000
tloss 0.8970 16.30000000
tls4 713.9240 8.30000000
tltr 1.2040 48.06670000
util 4.3570 999.57900000

### LINDO_lindo: feasible:

Modelname Time (LINDO_lindo) Obj (LINDO_lindo)
4stufen 7200.5500 117099.00000000
beuster 7200.2800 117147.00000000
contvar 7201.1600 809150.00000000
csched2a 7200.7900 -164274.00000000
csched2 7200.6500 -165364.00000000
du-opt 7200.7400 3.62371000
eg_disc_s 7202.4800 5.76054000
ex1233 7200.3200 155011.00000000
feedtray 7201.4400 -13.40600000
fo7_2 7201.6700 28.21090000
fo7_ar2_1 7200.3000 42.79820000
fo7_ar25_1 7200.9300 23.12100000
fo7_ar3_1 7200.3300 28.71720000
fo7_ar4_1 7201.1500 32.73630000
fo7_ar5_1 7200.2000 26.34560000
fo7 7200.9500 29.97440000
fo8_ar25_1 7200.6000 34.54870000
fo8_ar3_1 7200.6400 54.82100000
fo9_ar2_1 7200.6000 41.12500000
fo9_ar4_1 7200.9000 48.43550000
ghg_2veh 7200.1900 7.77091000
lop97ic 7795.8300 4119.16000000
lop97icx 7203.0000 4184.32000000
minlphix 7200.2700 316.69300000
netmod_dol1 7202.1200 -0.09880490
netmod_dol2 7203.9900 -0.52958200
netmod_kar1 7202.5300 -0.41740600
netmod_kar2 7200.4700 -0.41979000
no7_ar2_1 7200.7200 141.39300000
no7_ar25_1 7200.3100 146.65000000
no7_ar3_1 7200.6200 116.37000000
no7_ar4_1 7200.8000 116.84900000
no7_ar5_1 7200.4800 117.07500000
nuclear14a 7202.2600 -1.12925000
nuclear14b 7201.2700 -1.11029000
nuclear14 7202.0000 -1.12632000
nuclear24a 7201.0900 -1.12925000
nuclear24b 7204.4900 -1.11029000
nuclear24 7201.0000 -1.12632000
nuclear25a 7203.8100 -1.12022000
nuclear25b 7202.6300 -1.07663000
nuclear25 7202.9600 -1.11536000
nuclear49a 7201.4800 -1.15121000
nuclearvc 7201.0900 -1.00105000
nuclearve 7200.6900 -1.03635000
nvs19 7200.8600 -1098.40000000
nvs23 7202.4100 -1125.20000000
nvs24 7200.4100 -1033.20000000
o7_2 7201.0400 148.48000000
o7_ar25_1 7200.9600 169.16100000
o7_ar3_1 7200.6900 157.35100000
o7_ar4_1 7200.2700 154.27300000
o7_ar5_1 7201.3000 146.65300000
o7 7201.3700 152.25600000
pb302035 7340.7800 3923680.00000000
pb302055 7507.7400 4158700.00000000
pb302075 7636.4400 4449650.00000000
pb302095 8484.8100 6006690.00000000
pb351535 7401.4600 5116370.00000000
pb351555 7549.7100 5206860.00000000
pb351575 7457.2300 6527830.00000000
pb351595 8704.5100 7206560.00000000
product2 7200.6700 -2099.14000000
qap 7216.7600 431074.00000000
qapw 7200.6100 410614.00000000
saa_2 8397.6700 12.71370000
super3t 7201.5600 -0.65348300
tln12 7201.3200 104.50000000
tln7 7201.0900 16.50000000
tls5 7200.3100 10.60000000
tls6 7200.7600 27.50000000
tls7 7202.2400 27.30000000
waste 7207.5100 745.90500000
water4 7201.1200 923.75100000
waterx 7200.8500 948.93000000
waterz 7200.8100 958.68700000

### LINDO_lindo: fail:

Modelname Time (LINDO_lindo) Status (LINDO_lindo)
eg_all_s -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
eg_int_s -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
eniplac -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
fo8_ar2_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo8_ar4_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo8_ar5_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo8 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9_ar25_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9_ar3_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9_ar5_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
fo9 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
ghg_1veh -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
ghg_3veh -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
hda -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
mbtd -- mstat(13)sstat(13)
nuclear104 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclear10a -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclear10b -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclear49b -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclear49 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
nuclearva -- mstat(13)sstat(13)
nuclearvb -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
nuclearvd -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
nuclearvf -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
o7_ar2_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
o8_ar4_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
o9_ar4_1 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
oil -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
space25 -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
space960 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
st_e40 -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
super1 -- mstat(13)sstat(13)
super2 -- mstat(13)sstat(13)
super3 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
tls12 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
tls2 -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)
uselinear -- mstat(13)sstat( 1)