## Resource Times:

Results created on 09/14/12 19:33:57 using the PAVER Server/Performance tools available at http://www.gamsworld.eu/performance/paver

See the solver return definitions for optimal/feasible model and solve statuses. Solutions are not checked for how close they are to eachother.

Resource times are considered the same, if they are within 10% of eachother. A solver is considered faster than another, if it is less than 50% faster than the other. A solver is considered much faster than another, if it is more than 50% faster than the other.

If a model was not solved optimal/feasible by both solvers, the resource time is considered the same. If a model was solved optimal/feasible by solver A but not by solver B, then solver A is considered infinitely faster than solver B. Similarly, if one solver has trace data and the other has no data, then the first solver is consideredinfinitely faster.

A solver is considered to have a better objective function value, if the relative objective value difference is greater than 1.50E-04 For objective values below 1e-1 we use absolute differences.

Input File Number Filename
Tracefile 1: minlpconvex_bonmin-hyb.pav
Tracefile 2: minlpconvex_bonmin-bb.pav
Solvers used : BONMIN_bonmin-hyb
BONMIN_bonmin-bb
Modeltype(s)   MINLP
Threshold: Solver Faster 10%
Threshold: Solver Much Faster 50%
Threshold: Solver Infinitely Faster Other solver failed

Total Obj BONMIN_bonmin-hyb better Obj same Obj BONMIN_bonmin-bb better
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb infinitely faster : 11 11 - -
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb much faster : 83 25 58 -
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb faster : 14 2 12 -
Solvers perform the same : 19 12 6 1
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb faster : 10 - 10 -
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb much faster : 14 - 13 1
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb infinitely faster : 2 - - 2
Both solvers failed to solve optimally : 2 - 2 -
Total models: : 155501014

### Solver return definition:

Outcome Model Status Solver Status
globally optimal 1 or 15 1
locally optimal/feasible 2 or 8 or 16 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 or 8

### Resource Times:

• Models for each resource time category. Listed are the solver resource times TIME(.) in seconds, as well as the ratio of resource times RATIO(.)for the two solvers if both solved optimally. Models not solved optimally by a solver have status listed instead of resource time.
• Also listed are the objective values OBJ(.) using both solvers. The better solution found is listed in boldface. A solution is considered better, if the relative objective function difference is greater than 1.50E-04.
• Solver resource time ratios for a particular model are listed only if both solvers are optimal and if one solver has resource time greater than 5.00E-02.

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb infinitely faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-hyb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Syn20M03M 2.9490 fail -- 2.64695000E+03 2.62995000E+03 Syn20M04M 9.0510 fail -- 3.53274000E+03 1.39395000E+03 fo8_ar25_1 3448.7200 fail -- 2.80452000E+01 1.00000000E+20 fo9_ar2_1 7262.2100 fail -- 3.44313000E+01 1.00000000E+20 fo9_ar25_1 7280.0400 fail -- 3.23750000E+01 1.00000000E+20 fo9_ar3_1 4415.4200 fail -- 2.48155000E+01 1.00000000E+20 fo9_ar4_1 2857.2600 fail -- 2.34643000E+01 1.00000000E+20 fo9_ar5_1 5114.2900 fail -- 2.34643000E+01 1.00000000E+20 o9_ar4_1 7273.9800 fail -- 2.77698000E+02 1.00000000E+20 tls5 7236.9600 fail -- 1.10000000E+01 1.00000000E+20 tls6 7234.6800 fail -- 1.70000000E+01 1.00000000E+20

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb much faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-hyb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) RSyn0810M02M 83.8960 7375.6600 0.011 1.74139000E+03 1.71269000E+03 RSyn0810M03M 1045.3900 7323.3200 0.143 2.72245000E+03 2.71225000E+03 RSyn0810M04M 1295.9100 7294.0800 0.178 6.58193000E+03 6.51167000E+03 RSyn0820M02M 544.8660 7354.5600 0.074 1.09209000E+03 9.73262000E+02 RSyn0840M 16.7770 7448.0700 0.002 3.25555000E+02 3.18555000E+02 Syn40M02M 9.7590 7384.0100 0.001 3.88772000E+02 3.60415000E+02 Syn40M03M 3068.0700 7331.7900 0.418 3.95148000E+02 3.31144000E+02 sssd-16-8-3 761.9770 7649.9500 0.100 6.15763000E+05 6.16043000E+05 nd-12 183.5050 7239.3100 0.025 5.66696000E+01 5.83036000E+01 fo7_ar25_1 220.1330 7485.8900 0.029 2.30936000E+01 2.55891000E+01 fo7_ar3_1 192.7660 7504.2700 0.026 2.25175000E+01 2.41955000E+01 fo8_ar2_1 2301.8800 7456.9100 0.309 3.03406000E+01 4.86817000E+01 fo8_ar3_1 1526.5000 7454.6600 0.205 2.39101000E+01 3.96525000E+01 fo8_ar4_1 802.0580 7459.2200 0.108 2.23819000E+01 2.84665000E+01 fo8_ar5_1 748.5300 7462.5000 0.100 2.23819000E+01 2.44226000E+01 m7_ar4_1 134.7340 7488.2500 0.018 1.06757000E+02 1.48620000E+02 no7_ar2_1 204.2040 7503.1200 0.027 1.07815000E+02 1.25589000E+02 no7_ar25_1 613.4560 7492.9500 0.082 1.07815000E+02 1.15100000E+02 no7_ar3_1 1017.7600 7500.7900 0.136 1.07815000E+02 1.17224000E+02 no7_ar4_1 879.8670 7496.5500 0.117 9.85184000E+01 1.00419000E+02 o7_ar2_1 596.8440 7480.0300 0.080 1.40412000E+02 1.53249000E+02 o7_ar25_1 1431.4000 7497.6300 0.191 1.40412000E+02 1.51014000E+02 o7_ar3_1 1752.8300 7488.1600 0.234 1.37932000E+02 1.46096000E+02 o7_ar4_1 2517.3300 7482.3300 0.336 1.31653000E+02 1.36731000E+02 o7_ar5_1 1246.5100 7488.1200 0.166 1.16946000E+02 1.18767000E+02

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb much faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) clay0204h 11.4310 52.7820 0.217 6.54500000E+03 6.54500000E+03 clay0204m 4.4130 9.1500 0.482 6.54500000E+03 6.54500000E+03 clay0205h 110.8940 1775.5400 0.062 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 clay0205m 16.6980 708.5470 0.024 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 clay0305h 171.6710 1662.5000 0.103 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 clay0305m 11.6780 250.6350 0.047 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 FLay04H 18.5320 38.9700 0.476 5.44059000E+01 5.44059000E+01 FLay05H 315.7480 3506.4800 0.090 6.44981000E+01 6.44981000E+01 FLay05M 75.7710 617.4280 0.123 6.44981000E+01 6.44981000E+01 RSyn0810H 1.1150 3.0840 0.362 1.72145000E+03 1.72145000E+03 RSyn0810M02H 4.0870 18.2470 0.224 1.74139000E+03 1.74139000E+03 RSyn0810M03H 10.8450 53.8100 0.202 2.72245000E+03 2.72245000E+03 RSyn0810M04H 7.6860 30.9780 0.248 6.58194000E+03 6.58194000E+03 RSyn0810M 1.4900 450.3500 0.003 1.72145000E+03 1.72145000E+03 RSyn0820H 2.5190 5.5110 0.457 1.15030000E+03 1.15030000E+03 RSyn0820M02H 4.1210 22.9370 0.180 1.09209000E+03 1.09209000E+03 RSyn0820M03H 12.2690 75.2470 0.163 2.02881000E+03 2.02881000E+03 RSyn0820M04H 12.3980 91.3950 0.136 2.45077000E+03 2.45077000E+03 RSyn0820M 8.0470 3363.6400 0.002 1.15030000E+03 1.15030000E+03 RSyn0840H 1.4330 3.7300 0.384 3.25555000E+02 3.25555000E+02 RSyn0840M02H 3.3540 23.3200 0.144 7.34984000E+02 7.34984000E+02 RSyn0840M04H 21.5470 240.4630 0.090 2.56450000E+03 2.56450000E+03 SLay05M 1.2310 2.5770 0.478 2.26647000E+04 2.26647000E+04 SLay06H 25.8010 54.5440 0.473 3.27570000E+04 3.27570000E+04 SLay06M 3.0400 27.4070 0.111 3.27570000E+04 3.27570000E+04 SLay07M 5.1260 66.4610 0.077 6.47488000E+04 6.47488000E+04 SLay08M 14.1080 67.5310 0.209 8.49602000E+04 8.49602000E+04 Syn10M02M 0.5760 4.5530 0.127 2.31030000E+03 2.31030000E+03 Syn10M03M 0.6150 19.6690 0.031 3.35468000E+03 3.35468000E+03 Syn10M04M 1.0700 56.4720 0.019 4.55706000E+03 4.55706000E+03 Syn20M02M 1.3020 458.7050 0.003 1.75213000E+03 1.75213000E+03 Syn20M03H 2.0970 4.2170 0.497 2.64695000E+03 2.64695000E+03 Syn20M04H 2.9870 7.6110 0.392 3.53274000E+03 3.53274000E+03 Syn20M 0.4590 4.8100 0.095 9.24263000E+02 9.24263000E+02 Syn40M02H 1.5640 3.5190 0.444 3.88773000E+02 3.88773000E+02 Syn40M04H 15.3270 53.4430 0.287 9.01752000E+02 9.01752000E+02 Syn40M 1.2650 973.0320 0.001 6.77133000E+01 6.77133000E+01 sssd-8-4-3 1.3250 9.6910 0.137 1.97181000E+05 1.97181000E+05 sssd-10-4-3 1.6560 12.5650 0.132 1.52710000E+05 1.52710000E+05 sssd-15-6-3 61.3160 231.9490 0.264 4.40711000E+05 4.40711000E+05 sssd-18-8-3 841.6700 7643.5000 0.110 5.24063000E+05 5.24139000E+05 nd-10 42.5860 1189.2800 0.036 5.24611000E+01 5.24611000E+01 fo7_2 99.3470 2031.2700 0.049 1.77493000E+01 1.77493000E+01 fo7_ar2_1 401.3470 7489.7600 0.054 2.48398000E+01 2.48398000E+01 fo7_ar4_1 259.7450 7491.1600 0.035 2.07298000E+01 2.07298000E+01 fo7_ar5_1 55.1540 4544.9200 0.012 1.77493000E+01 1.77493000E+01 fo7 1100.1200 7510.0700 0.146 2.07298000E+01 2.07298000E+01 m3 0.4080 1.3530 0.302 3.78000000E+01 3.78000000E+01 m6 17.3510 46.2730 0.375 8.22569000E+01 8.22569000E+01 m7_ar2_1 79.1760 2569.7700 0.031 1.90235000E+02 1.90235000E+02 m7_ar25_1 20.5300 166.4970 0.123 1.43585000E+02 1.43585000E+02 m7_ar3_1 84.1390 7483.3400 0.011 1.43585000E+02 1.43585000E+02 m7_ar5_1 173.0310 7487.6700 0.023 1.06460000E+02 1.06460000E+02 m7 57.0230 507.3050 0.112 1.06757000E+02 1.06757000E+02 netmod_dol2 337.4090 1936.8100 0.174 -5.60008000E-01 -5.60008000E-01 no7_ar5_1 373.7740 7486.4200 0.050 9.06227000E+01 9.06227000E+01 o7_2 1688.1700 7514.5300 0.225 1.16946000E+02 1.16946000E+02 tls4 1252.1500 7676.4700 0.163 8.30000000E+00 8.30000000E+00

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-hyb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Syn40M04M 5722.4800 7295.7900 0.784 9.01751000E+02 8.08852000E+02 fo8 3903.7200 7478.3600 0.522 2.23819000E+01 2.68626000E+01

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-hyb faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) BatchS151208M 60.0490 110.9250 0.541 1.54347000E+06 1.54347000E+06 BatchS201210M 79.8440 144.9750 0.551 2.29535000E+06 2.29535000E+06 clay0203h 4.1880 6.8740 0.609 4.15733000E+04 4.15733000E+04 clay0203m 2.6970 4.2890 0.629 4.15733000E+04 4.15733000E+04 clay0303h 9.6990 18.6050 0.521 2.66691000E+04 2.66691000E+04 clay0303m 3.8930 5.5580 0.700 2.66691000E+04 2.66691000E+04 FLay03H 1.9520 2.2550 0.866 4.89898000E+01 4.89898000E+01 SLay09M 42.7860 69.8780 0.612 1.07806000E+05 1.07806000E+05 Syn20M02H 1.1640 2.2460 0.518 1.75213000E+03 1.75213000E+03 Syn40H 1.2300 1.5330 0.802 6.77134000E+01 6.77134000E+01 sssd-12-5-3 42.0410 52.5360 0.800 2.61143000E+05 2.61143000E+05 o7 4029.9400 7521.1600 0.536 1.31653000E+02 1.31653000E+02

### Solvers perform the same - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-hyb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) RSyn0820M03M 7324.1500 7306.8100 1.002 2.02881000E+03 1.95237000E+03 RSyn0820M04M 7561.4700 7273.8100 1.040 2.36693000E+03 2.34774000E+03 RSyn0840M02M 7264.9200 7321.5600 0.992 7.30188000E+02 6.36571000E+02 RSyn0840M03M 7250.8900 7282.9700 0.996 2.71387000E+03 2.64392000E+03 RSyn0840M04M 7526.7300 7267.4400 1.036 2.50236000E+03 2.29365000E+03 sssd-20-9-3 7256.2400 7616.2900 0.953 4.78366000E+05 4.78924000E+05 sssd-22-8-3 7409.5600 7614.5400 0.973 5.96029000E+05 5.96139000E+05 nd-13 7221.9700 7237.1500 0.998 6.30051000E+01 6.49835000E+01 nd-15 7221.2500 7227.0400 0.999 8.20272000E+01 8.33353000E+01 nd-16 7221.4800 7227.7000 0.999 9.87609000E+01 9.90439000E+01 fo9 7273.4200 7445.8100 0.977 2.34643000E+01 3.04643000E+01 o8_ar4_1 7344.6000 7450.2100 0.986 2.53219000E+02 2.98512000E+02

### Solvers perform the same - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) clay0304m 56.5330 61.5350 0.919 4.02624000E+04 4.02624000E+04 FLay04M 12.1130 12.8400 0.943 5.44059000E+01 5.44059000E+01 FLay06H 7283.5900 7394.3800 0.985 6.69328000E+01 6.69328000E+01 FLay06M 7285.6700 7661.7800 0.951 6.69328000E+01 6.69328000E+01 Syn10M04H 1.0810 1.0620 1.018 4.55706000E+03 4.55706000E+03 Syn40M03H 15.4660 17.1110 0.904 3.95149000E+02 3.95149000E+02

### Solvers perform the same - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-bb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) netmod_dol1 7225.1600 7250.5400 0.996 -5.57823000E-01 -5.60008000E-01

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) BatchS101006M 25.8700 18.3460 1.410 7.69440000E+05 7.69440000E+05 BatchS121208M 46.4590 37.3690 1.243 1.24113000E+06 1.24113000E+06 FLay03M 1.0510 0.8650 1.215 4.89898000E+01 4.89898000E+01 SLay05H 8.4460 4.4500 1.898 2.26647000E+04 2.26647000E+04 SLay07H 89.7690 67.9740 1.321 6.47488000E+04 6.47488000E+04 Syn10H 0.6440 0.3520 1.830 1.26735000E+03 1.26735000E+03 Syn10M03H 1.0360 0.7190 1.441 3.35468000E+03 3.35468000E+03 netmod_kar1 29.9370 15.0230 1.993 -4.19790000E-01 -4.19790000E-01 netmod_kar2 29.9190 15.0430 1.989 -4.19790000E-01 -4.19790000E-01 tls2 11.3150 5.9730 1.894 5.30000000E+00 5.30000000E+00

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb much faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) clay0304h 493.1600 208.0350 2.371 4.02624000E+04 4.02624000E+04 SLay08H 231.4060 69.2590 3.341 8.49602000E+04 8.49602000E+04 SLay09H 3633.1000 79.2830 45.824 1.07806000E+05 1.07806000E+05 SLay10M 483.9660 144.9750 3.338 1.29580000E+05 1.29580000E+05 Syn10M02H 0.8510 0.3180 2.676 2.31030000E+03 2.31030000E+03 Syn20H 0.9380 0.4150 2.260 9.24263000E+02 9.24263000E+02 uflquad-15-60 55.1940 12.4560 4.431 1.06319000E+03 1.06319000E+03 uflquad-15-80 124.7640 22.6090 5.518 1.21799000E+03 1.21799000E+03 uflquad-20-40 58.3210 17.2550 3.380 8.60961000E+02 8.60961000E+02 uflquad-20-50 7234.9200 225.1360 32.136 3.75919000E+02 3.75919000E+02 uflquad-25-25 28.7690 10.5160 2.736 6.73697000E+02 6.73697000E+02 uflquad-25-30 26.8910 12.5240 2.147 6.69840000E+02 6.69840000E+02 uflquad-25-40 107.6530 23.3470 4.611 8.28165000E+02 8.28165000E+02

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb much faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-bb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) SLay10H 7222.4000 336.6470 21.454 1.29810000E+05 1.29580000E+05

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb infinitely faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-bb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb / BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-hyb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) RSyn0840M03H fail 66.9090 -- 2.74120000E+03 2.74265000E+03 Syn10M fail 0.6270 -- 1.25435000E+03 1.26735000E+03