Solver Square Comparison

Solver Square Comparison: Considers all models.

Results created on 09/14/12 19:33:54 using the PAVER Server/Performance tools available at http://www.gamsworld.eu/performance/paver

Compares all solver return outcomes (for example optimal, locally optimal, infeasible, unbounded, fail) of one solver with all return outcomes of another solver. Interrupt denotes resource or iteration limit has been reached.

Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb is represented on the left (rows) and solver SBB_sbb on top (columns).

See the solver return definitions for return codes. Models having trace data only in one trace file are listed in the "no data" column of the other.

Input File Number	Filename
Tracefile 1:	minlpconvex_bonmin-bb.pav
Tracefile 2:	minlpconvex_sbb.pav
Solvers used :	BONMIN_bonmin-bb
	SBB_sbb
Modeltype(s)	`MINLP`

	SBB_sbb: optimal	SBB_sbb: locally optimal	SBB_sbb: feasible	SBB_sbb: infeasible	SBB_sbb: unbounded	SBB_sbb: fail	SBB_sbb: no data	total BONMIN_bonmin-bb
BONMIN_bonmin-bb: optimal	`76`	-	`11`	-	-	`3`	-	`90`
BONMIN_bonmin-bb: locally optimal	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
BONMIN_bonmin-bb: feasible	`2`	-	`49`	-	-	`1`	-	`52`
BONMIN_bonmin-bb: infeasible	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
BONMIN_bonmin-bb: unbounded	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
BONMIN_bonmin-bb: fail	-	-	`6`	-	-	`7`	-	`13`
BONMIN_bonmin-bb: no data	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
total SBB_sbb	`78`	`-`	`66`	`-`	`-`	`11`	`-`	`155`

Solver return definitions:

Outcome	Model Status	Solver Status
optimal	1 or 15	1
locally optimal	2	any
feasible	8 or 16	1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5
infeasible	4 or 5 or 10 or 19	1
unbounded	3 or 18	1
fail	all other	all other

Solver Resource Times

Models for each solver pair outcome. Listed are the solver resource times TIME(.) in seconds, as well as the ratio RATIO(./.) of resource times for the two solvers if both solved optimally.
Also listed are the objective values OBJ(.) using both solvers. The better solution found is listed in boldface. A solution is considered better, if the relative objective function difference is greater than 1.50E-04. If both solutions are less than 1e-1, we use the absolute difference.
Solver resource time ratios for a particular model are listed only if one solver has resource greater than 5.00E-02.

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: optimal -- SBB_sbb: optimal

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)
`BatchS101006M`	`18.3460`	`81.6070`	`0.225`	`769440.00000000`	`769440.00000000`
`BatchS121208M`	`37.3690`	`99.3970`	`0.376`	`1241130.00000000`	`1241130.00000000`
`BatchS151208M`	`110.9250`	`123.5030`	`0.898`	`1543470.00000000`	`1543470.00000000`
`BatchS201210M`	`144.9750`	`517.8210`	`0.280`	`2295350.00000000`	`2295350.00000000`
`clay0203h`	`6.8740`	`3.9370`	`1.746`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`
`clay0203m`	`4.2890`	`1.8450`	`2.325`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`
`clay0204h`	`52.7820`	`43.6850`	`1.208`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`
`clay0204m`	`9.1500`	`10.9330`	`0.837`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`
`clay0205h`	`1775.5400`	`688.0400`	`2.581`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0205m`	`708.5470`	`231.4940`	`3.061`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0303h`	`18.6050`	`6.9610`	`2.673`	`26669.10000000`	`26669.10000000`
`clay0304h`	`208.0350`	`510.2070`	`0.408`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`
`clay0304m`	`61.5350`	`94.4630`	`0.651`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`
`clay0305h`	`1662.5000`	`1521.9900`	`1.092`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0305m`	`250.6350`	`186.2620`	`1.346`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`
`FLay03H`	`2.2550`	`1.0190`	`2.213`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`
`FLay03M`	`0.8650`	`0.6440`	`1.343`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`
`FLay04H`	`38.9700`	`25.2120`	`1.546`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`
`FLay04M`	`12.8400`	`10.0850`	`1.273`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`
`FLay05M`	`617.4280`	`504.3070`	`1.224`	`64.49810000`	`64.49810000`
`RSyn0810H`	`3.0840`	`2.9460`	`1.047`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`
`RSyn0810M02H`	`18.2470`	`20.7120`	`0.881`	`1741.39000000`	`1741.39000000`
`RSyn0810M03H`	`53.8100`	`106.6050`	`0.505`	`2722.45000000`	`2722.45000000`
`RSyn0810M04H`	`30.9780`	`30.6420`	`1.011`	`6581.94000000`	`6581.94000000`
`RSyn0810M`	`450.3500`	`788.8410`	`0.571`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`
`RSyn0820H`	`5.5110`	`4.6940`	`1.174`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`
`RSyn0820M02H`	`22.9370`	`58.5700`	`0.392`	`1092.09000000`	`1092.09000000`
`RSyn0820M03H`	`75.2470`	`514.5710`	`0.146`	`2028.81000000`	`2028.81000000`
`RSyn0820M04H`	`91.3950`	`427.0530`	`0.214`	`2450.77000000`	`2450.77000000`
`RSyn0820M`	`3363.6400`	`7190.5900`	`0.468`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`
`RSyn0840H`	`3.7300`	`2.1890`	`1.704`	`325.55500000`	`325.55500000`
`RSyn0840M02H`	`23.3200`	`18.9290`	`1.232`	`734.98400000`	`734.98400000`
`RSyn0840M03H`	`66.9090`	`113.8710`	`0.588`	`2742.65000000`	`2742.65000000`
`RSyn0840M04H`	`240.4630`	`740.9130`	`0.325`	`2564.50000000`	`2564.50000000`
`SLay05H`	`4.4500`	`22.2240`	`0.200`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`
`SLay05M`	`2.5770`	`2.3020`	`1.119`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`
`SLay06H`	`54.5440`	`387.8510`	`0.141`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`
`SLay06M`	`27.4070`	`1.1210`	`24.449`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`
`SLay07M`	`66.4610`	`13.6680`	`4.863`	`64748.80000000`	`64748.80000000`
`SLay08M`	`67.5310`	`4.8160`	`14.022`	`84960.20000000`	`84960.20000000`
`SLay09M`	`69.8780`	`330.1600`	`0.212`	`107806.00000000`	`107806.00000000`
`SLay10M`	`144.9750`	`538.4240`	`0.269`	`129580.00000000`	`129580.00000000`
`Syn10H`	`0.3520`	`0.1120`	`3.143`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`
`Syn10M02H`	`0.3180`	`0.2850`	`1.116`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`
`Syn10M02M`	`4.5530`	`3.3410`	`1.363`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`
`Syn10M03H`	`0.7190`	`0.4480`	`1.605`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`
`Syn10M03M`	`19.6690`	`13.2780`	`1.481`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`
`Syn10M04H`	`1.0620`	`0.5910`	`1.797`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`
`Syn10M04M`	`56.4720`	`58.3070`	`0.969`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`
`Syn10M`	`0.6270`	`0.2170`	`2.889`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`
`Syn20H`	`0.4150`	`0.2040`	`2.034`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`
`Syn20M02H`	`2.2460`	`0.9990`	`2.248`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`
`Syn20M02M`	`458.7050`	`819.5300`	`0.560`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`
`Syn20M03H`	`4.2170`	`1.1720`	`3.598`	`2646.95000000`	`2646.95000000`
`Syn20M04H`	`7.6110`	`1.7440`	`4.364`	`3532.74000000`	`3532.74000000`
`Syn20M`	`4.8100`	`3.3160`	`1.451`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`
`Syn40H`	`1.5330`	`0.8680`	`1.766`	`67.71340000`	`67.71340000`
`Syn40M02H`	`3.5190`	`3.8970`	`0.903`	`388.77300000`	`388.77300000`
`Syn40M03H`	`17.1110`	`16.2270`	`1.054`	`395.14900000`	`395.14900000`
`Syn40M04H`	`53.4430`	`60.9210`	`0.877`	`901.75200000`	`901.75200000`
`sssd-8-4-3`	`9.6910`	`931.0760`	`0.010`	`197181.00000000`	`197181.00000000`
`uflquad-15-60`	`12.4560`	`15.8290`	`0.787`	`1063.19000000`	`1063.19000000`
`uflquad-15-80`	`22.6090`	`37.1940`	`0.608`	`1217.99000000`	`1217.99000000`
`uflquad-20-40`	`17.2550`	`19.0030`	`0.908`	`860.96100000`	`860.96100000`
`uflquad-20-50`	`225.1360`	`1623.3800`	`0.139`	`375.91900000`	`375.91900000`
`uflquad-25-25`	`10.5160`	`5.7650`	`1.824`	`673.69700000`	`673.69700000`
`uflquad-25-30`	`12.5240`	`4.6730`	`2.680`	`669.84000000`	`669.84000000`
`uflquad-25-40`	`23.3470`	`27.5040`	`0.849`	`828.16500000`	`828.16500000`
`nd-10`	`1189.2800`	`472.2360`	`2.518`	`52.46110000`	`52.46110000`
`m3`	`1.3530`	`0.4660`	`2.903`	`37.80000000`	`37.80000000`
`m6`	`46.2730`	`1321.2900`	`0.035`	`82.25690000`	`82.25690000`
`m7_ar2_1`	`2569.7700`	`2283.0700`	`1.126`	`190.23500000`	`190.23500000`
`m7_ar25_1`	`166.4970`	`4391.6700`	`0.038`	`143.58500000`	`143.58500000`
`netmod_kar1`	`15.0230`	`204.3500`	`0.074`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`
`netmod_kar2`	`15.0430`	`202.6730`	`0.074`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`
`tls2`	`5.9730`	`4.2320`	`1.411`	`5.30000000`	`5.30000000`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: optimal -- SBB_sbb: feasible

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)
`SLay07H`	`67.9740`	`7383.1600`	`0.009`	`64748.80000000`	`64748.80000000`
`SLay08H`	`69.2590`	`7413.2200`	`0.009`	`84960.20000000`	`85115.00000000`
`SLay09H`	`79.2830`	`7412.7900`	`0.011`	`107806.00000000`	`122507.00000000`
`SLay10H`	`336.6470`	`7356.2200`	`0.046`	`129580.00000000`	`153256.00000000`
`Syn40M`	`973.0320`	`10415.2000`	`0.093`	`67.71330000`	`67.71330000`
`sssd-10-4-3`	`12.5650`	`12944.6000`	`0.001`	`152710.00000000`	`159329.00000000`
`sssd-12-5-3`	`52.5360`	`19374.5000`	`0.003`	`261143.00000000`	`330320.00000000`
`sssd-15-6-3`	`231.9490`	`15779.7000`	`0.015`	`440711.00000000`	`513871.00000000`
`fo7_2`	`2031.2700`	`7403.9100`	`0.274`	`17.74930000`	`17.74930000`
`fo7_ar5_1`	`4544.9200`	`7340.0900`	`0.619`	`17.74930000`	`19.01200000`
`m7`	`507.3050`	`7448.1800`	`0.068`	`106.75700000`	`106.75700000`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: optimal -- SBB_sbb: fail

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Status (SBB_sbb)
`clay0303m`	`5.5580`	`1.7160`	---	`26669.10000000`	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`
`FLay05H`	`3506.4800`	`2611.9300`	---	`64.49810000`	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`
`netmod_dol2`	`1936.8100`	`5.3840`	---	`-0.56000800`	`mstat(13)sstat(13)`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: feasible -- SBB_sbb: optimal

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)
`nd-12`	`7239.3100`	`2721.8200`	`2.660`	`58.30360000`	`56.66960000`
`m7_ar4_1`	`7488.2500`	`7134.8100`	`1.050`	`148.62000000`	`106.75700000`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: feasible -- SBB_sbb: feasible

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)
`FLay06H`	`7394.3800`	`7451.7700`	`0.992`	`66.93280000`	`66.93280000`
`RSyn0810M02M`	`7375.6600`	`8679.9900`	`0.850`	`1712.69000000`	`1592.16000000`
`RSyn0810M03M`	`7323.3200`	`7569.2100`	`0.968`	`2712.25000000`	`2368.77000000`
`RSyn0810M04M`	`7294.0800`	`7495.6000`	`0.973`	`6511.67000000`	`5433.33000000`
`RSyn0820M02M`	`7354.5600`	`7627.2200`	`0.964`	`973.26200000`	`669.53700000`
`RSyn0820M03M`	`7306.8100`	`7451.4200`	`0.981`	`1952.37000000`	`1439.77000000`
`RSyn0820M04M`	`7273.8100`	`7396.6400`	`0.983`	`2347.74000000`	`1563.83000000`
`RSyn0840M02M`	`7321.5600`	`8159.1100`	`0.897`	`636.57100000`	`191.12600000`
`RSyn0840M03M`	`7282.9700`	`7609.5000`	`0.957`	`2643.92000000`	`2241.35000000`
`RSyn0840M04M`	`7267.4400`	`7575.0000`	`0.959`	`2293.65000000`	`2301.43000000`
`RSyn0840M`	`7448.0700`	`11688.7000`	`0.637`	`318.55500000`	`247.39700000`
`Syn40M02M`	`7384.0100`	`8804.5400`	`0.839`	`360.41500000`	`344.48700000`
`Syn40M03M`	`7331.7900`	`7548.5800`	`0.971`	`331.14400000`	`294.29000000`
`Syn40M04M`	`7295.7900`	`7557.2600`	`0.965`	`808.85200000`	`831.89600000`
`sssd-16-8-3`	`7649.9500`	`13118.5000`	`0.583`	`616043.00000000`	`709652.00000000`
`sssd-18-8-3`	`7643.5000`	`12851.3000`	`0.595`	`524139.00000000`	`637320.00000000`
`sssd-20-9-3`	`7616.2900`	`11853.3000`	`0.643`	`478924.00000000`	`510261.00000000`
`sssd-22-8-3`	`7614.5400`	`12055.5000`	`0.632`	`596139.00000000`	`730203.00000000`
`nd-13`	`7237.1500`	`7251.3700`	`0.998`	`64.98350000`	`65.90790000`
`nd-15`	`7227.0400`	`7230.4100`	`1.000`	`83.33530000`	`86.92650000`
`nd-16`	`7227.7000`	`7227.5800`	`1.000`	`99.04390000`	`102.09800000`
`fo7_ar2_1`	`7489.7600`	`7545.5400`	`0.993`	`24.83980000`	`34.87130000`
`fo7_ar25_1`	`7485.8900`	`7414.1500`	`1.010`	`25.58910000`	`25.67840000`
`fo7_ar3_1`	`7504.2700`	`7413.0500`	`1.012`	`24.19550000`	`23.12100000`
`fo7_ar4_1`	`7491.1600`	`7368.0300`	`1.017`	`20.72980000`	`29.47550000`
`fo7`	`7510.0700`	`7431.2200`	`1.011`	`20.72980000`	`28.45230000`
`fo8_ar2_1`	`7456.9100`	`7498.4800`	`0.994`	`48.68170000`	`48.41990000`
`fo8_ar3_1`	`7454.6600`	`7329.2200`	`1.017`	`39.65250000`	`40.79120000`
`fo8_ar4_1`	`7459.2200`	`7294.2400`	`1.023`	`28.46650000`	`33.46530000`
`fo8_ar5_1`	`7462.5000`	`7299.6800`	`1.022`	`24.42260000`	`45.65780000`
`fo8`	`7478.3600`	`7381.7800`	`1.013`	`26.86260000`	`41.06960000`
`fo9`	`7445.8100`	`7344.6400`	`1.014`	`30.46430000`	`49.96150000`
`m7_ar3_1`	`7483.3400`	`7479.4900`	`1.001`	`143.58500000`	`143.58500000`
`m7_ar5_1`	`7487.6700`	`7336.1600`	`1.021`	`106.46000000`	`106.46000000`
`netmod_dol1`	`7250.5400`	`7214.8800`	`1.005`	`-0.56000800`	`-0.55139800`
`no7_ar2_1`	`7503.1200`	`7471.5700`	`1.004`	`125.58900000`	`151.86000000`
`no7_ar25_1`	`7492.9500`	`7380.7300`	`1.015`	`115.10000000`	`148.78600000`
`no7_ar3_1`	`7500.7900`	`7374.7100`	`1.017`	`117.22400000`	`134.42700000`
`no7_ar4_1`	`7496.5500`	`7367.5900`	`1.018`	`100.41900000`	`120.70100000`
`no7_ar5_1`	`7486.4200`	`7343.6400`	`1.019`	`90.62270000`	`118.38200000`
`o7_2`	`7514.5300`	`7409.9700`	`1.014`	`116.94600000`	`122.35300000`
`o7_ar2_1`	`7480.0300`	`7458.1000`	`1.003`	`153.24900000`	`177.94600000`
`o7_ar25_1`	`7497.6300`	`7424.6000`	`1.010`	`151.01400000`	`180.92200000`
`o7_ar3_1`	`7488.1600`	`7369.9300`	`1.016`	`146.09600000`	`163.97700000`
`o7_ar4_1`	`7482.3300`	`7346.2800`	`1.019`	`136.73100000`	`183.00000000`
`o7_ar5_1`	`7488.1200`	`7350.2000`	`1.019`	`118.76700000`	`129.23900000`
`o7`	`7521.1600`	`7424.4200`	`1.013`	`131.65300000`	`165.39600000`
`o8_ar4_1`	`7450.2100`	`7302.2300`	`1.020`	`298.51200000`	`304.80900000`
`tls4`	`7676.4700`	`15208.6000`	`0.505`	`8.30000000`	`13.70000000`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: feasible -- SBB_sbb: fail

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Status (SBB_sbb)
`FLay06M`	`7661.7800`	`11788.9000`	---	`66.93280000`	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: fail -- SBB_sbb: feasible

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Status (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)
`Syn20M03M`	`4346.9500`	`7954.4200`	---	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`	`2646.95000000`
`Syn20M04M`	`12.8750`	`7781.6900`	---	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`	`3500.74000000`
`fo8_ar25_1`	`7466.7000`	`7372.1000`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`41.63040000`
`fo9_ar5_1`	`7424.9100`	`7263.1100`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`41.66030000`
`tls5`	`7597.7300`	`10552.2000`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`15.60000000`
`tls6`	`7535.5100`	`9148.5200`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`21.40000000`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: fail -- SBB_sbb: fail

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/SBB_sbb)	Status (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Status (SBB_sbb)
`fo9_ar2_1`	`7427.4000`	`7424.3900`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar25_1`	`7422.6000`	`7375.1300`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar3_1`	`7423.6500`	`7292.3500`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar4_1`	`7424.4900`	`7268.4700`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`o9_ar4_1`	`7422.0700`	`7297.6900`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`tls12`	`7370.2300`	`7667.1300`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`tls7`	`7489.1300`	`8474.5600`	---	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: optimal:

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)
`BatchS101006M`	`18.3460`	`769440.00000000`
`BatchS121208M`	`37.3690`	`1241130.00000000`
`BatchS151208M`	`110.9250`	`1543470.00000000`
`BatchS201210M`	`144.9750`	`2295350.00000000`
`clay0203h`	`6.8740`	`41573.30000000`
`clay0203m`	`4.2890`	`41573.30000000`
`clay0204h`	`52.7820`	`6545.00000000`
`clay0204m`	`9.1500`	`6545.00000000`
`clay0205h`	`1775.5400`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0205m`	`708.5470`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0303h`	`18.6050`	`26669.10000000`
`clay0303m`	`5.5580`	`26669.10000000`
`clay0304h`	`208.0350`	`40262.40000000`
`clay0304m`	`61.5350`	`40262.40000000`
`clay0305h`	`1662.5000`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0305m`	`250.6350`	`8092.50000000`
`FLay03H`	`2.2550`	`48.98980000`
`FLay03M`	`0.8650`	`48.98980000`
`FLay04H`	`38.9700`	`54.40590000`
`FLay04M`	`12.8400`	`54.40590000`
`FLay05H`	`3506.4800`	`64.49810000`
`FLay05M`	`617.4280`	`64.49810000`
`RSyn0810H`	`3.0840`	`1721.45000000`
`RSyn0810M02H`	`18.2470`	`1741.39000000`
`RSyn0810M03H`	`53.8100`	`2722.45000000`
`RSyn0810M04H`	`30.9780`	`6581.94000000`
`RSyn0810M`	`450.3500`	`1721.45000000`
`RSyn0820H`	`5.5110`	`1150.30000000`
`RSyn0820M02H`	`22.9370`	`1092.09000000`
`RSyn0820M03H`	`75.2470`	`2028.81000000`
`RSyn0820M04H`	`91.3950`	`2450.77000000`
`RSyn0820M`	`3363.6400`	`1150.30000000`
`RSyn0840H`	`3.7300`	`325.55500000`
`RSyn0840M02H`	`23.3200`	`734.98400000`
`RSyn0840M03H`	`66.9090`	`2742.65000000`
`RSyn0840M04H`	`240.4630`	`2564.50000000`
`SLay05H`	`4.4500`	`22664.70000000`
`SLay05M`	`2.5770`	`22664.70000000`
`SLay06H`	`54.5440`	`32757.00000000`
`SLay06M`	`27.4070`	`32757.00000000`
`SLay07H`	`67.9740`	`64748.80000000`
`SLay07M`	`66.4610`	`64748.80000000`
`SLay08H`	`69.2590`	`84960.20000000`
`SLay08M`	`67.5310`	`84960.20000000`
`SLay09H`	`79.2830`	`107806.00000000`
`SLay09M`	`69.8780`	`107806.00000000`
`SLay10H`	`336.6470`	`129580.00000000`
`SLay10M`	`144.9750`	`129580.00000000`
`Syn10H`	`0.3520`	`1267.35000000`
`Syn10M02H`	`0.3180`	`2310.30000000`
`Syn10M02M`	`4.5530`	`2310.30000000`
`Syn10M03H`	`0.7190`	`3354.68000000`
`Syn10M03M`	`19.6690`	`3354.68000000`
`Syn10M04H`	`1.0620`	`4557.06000000`
`Syn10M04M`	`56.4720`	`4557.06000000`
`Syn10M`	`0.6270`	`1267.35000000`
`Syn20H`	`0.4150`	`924.26300000`
`Syn20M02H`	`2.2460`	`1752.13000000`
`Syn20M02M`	`458.7050`	`1752.13000000`
`Syn20M03H`	`4.2170`	`2646.95000000`
`Syn20M04H`	`7.6110`	`3532.74000000`
`Syn20M`	`4.8100`	`924.26300000`
`Syn40H`	`1.5330`	`67.71340000`
`Syn40M02H`	`3.5190`	`388.77300000`
`Syn40M03H`	`17.1110`	`395.14900000`
`Syn40M04H`	`53.4430`	`901.75200000`
`Syn40M`	`973.0320`	`67.71330000`
`sssd-8-4-3`	`9.6910`	`197181.00000000`
`sssd-10-4-3`	`12.5650`	`152710.00000000`
`sssd-12-5-3`	`52.5360`	`261143.00000000`
`sssd-15-6-3`	`231.9490`	`440711.00000000`
`uflquad-15-60`	`12.4560`	`1063.19000000`
`uflquad-15-80`	`22.6090`	`1217.99000000`
`uflquad-20-40`	`17.2550`	`860.96100000`
`uflquad-20-50`	`225.1360`	`375.91900000`
`uflquad-25-25`	`10.5160`	`673.69700000`
`uflquad-25-30`	`12.5240`	`669.84000000`
`uflquad-25-40`	`23.3470`	`828.16500000`
`nd-10`	`1189.2800`	`52.46110000`
`fo7_2`	`2031.2700`	`17.74930000`
`fo7_ar5_1`	`4544.9200`	`17.74930000`
`m3`	`1.3530`	`37.80000000`
`m6`	`46.2730`	`82.25690000`
`m7_ar2_1`	`2569.7700`	`190.23500000`
`m7_ar25_1`	`166.4970`	`143.58500000`
`m7`	`507.3050`	`106.75700000`
`netmod_dol2`	`1936.8100`	`-0.56000800`
`netmod_kar1`	`15.0230`	`-0.41979000`
`netmod_kar2`	`15.0430`	`-0.41979000`
`tls2`	`5.9730`	`5.30000000`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: feasible:

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)
`FLay06H`	`7394.3800`	`66.93280000`
`FLay06M`	`7661.7800`	`66.93280000`
`RSyn0810M02M`	`7375.6600`	`1712.69000000`
`RSyn0810M03M`	`7323.3200`	`2712.25000000`
`RSyn0810M04M`	`7294.0800`	`6511.67000000`
`RSyn0820M02M`	`7354.5600`	`973.26200000`
`RSyn0820M03M`	`7306.8100`	`1952.37000000`
`RSyn0820M04M`	`7273.8100`	`2347.74000000`
`RSyn0840M02M`	`7321.5600`	`636.57100000`
`RSyn0840M03M`	`7282.9700`	`2643.92000000`
`RSyn0840M04M`	`7267.4400`	`2293.65000000`
`RSyn0840M`	`7448.0700`	`318.55500000`
`Syn40M02M`	`7384.0100`	`360.41500000`
`Syn40M03M`	`7331.7900`	`331.14400000`
`Syn40M04M`	`7295.7900`	`808.85200000`
`sssd-16-8-3`	`7649.9500`	`616043.00000000`
`sssd-18-8-3`	`7643.5000`	`524139.00000000`
`sssd-20-9-3`	`7616.2900`	`478924.00000000`
`sssd-22-8-3`	`7614.5400`	`596139.00000000`
`nd-12`	`7239.3100`	`58.30360000`
`nd-13`	`7237.1500`	`64.98350000`
`nd-15`	`7227.0400`	`83.33530000`
`nd-16`	`7227.7000`	`99.04390000`
`fo7_ar2_1`	`7489.7600`	`24.83980000`
`fo7_ar25_1`	`7485.8900`	`25.58910000`
`fo7_ar3_1`	`7504.2700`	`24.19550000`
`fo7_ar4_1`	`7491.1600`	`20.72980000`
`fo7`	`7510.0700`	`20.72980000`
`fo8_ar2_1`	`7456.9100`	`48.68170000`
`fo8_ar3_1`	`7454.6600`	`39.65250000`
`fo8_ar4_1`	`7459.2200`	`28.46650000`
`fo8_ar5_1`	`7462.5000`	`24.42260000`
`fo8`	`7478.3600`	`26.86260000`
`fo9`	`7445.8100`	`30.46430000`
`m7_ar3_1`	`7483.3400`	`143.58500000`
`m7_ar4_1`	`7488.2500`	`148.62000000`
`m7_ar5_1`	`7487.6700`	`106.46000000`
`netmod_dol1`	`7250.5400`	`-0.56000800`
`no7_ar2_1`	`7503.1200`	`125.58900000`
`no7_ar25_1`	`7492.9500`	`115.10000000`
`no7_ar3_1`	`7500.7900`	`117.22400000`
`no7_ar4_1`	`7496.5500`	`100.41900000`
`no7_ar5_1`	`7486.4200`	`90.62270000`
`o7_2`	`7514.5300`	`116.94600000`
`o7_ar2_1`	`7480.0300`	`153.24900000`
`o7_ar25_1`	`7497.6300`	`151.01400000`
`o7_ar3_1`	`7488.1600`	`146.09600000`
`o7_ar4_1`	`7482.3300`	`136.73100000`
`o7_ar5_1`	`7488.1200`	`118.76700000`
`o7`	`7521.1600`	`131.65300000`
`o8_ar4_1`	`7450.2100`	`298.51200000`
`tls4`	`7676.4700`	`8.30000000`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: fail:

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Status (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)
`Syn20M03M`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat( 1)`
`Syn20M04M`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat( 1)`
`fo8_ar25_1`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar2_1`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar25_1`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar3_1`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar4_1`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar5_1`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`o9_ar4_1`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`tls12`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`tls5`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`tls6`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`tls7`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`

SBB_sbb: optimal:

Modelname	Time (SBB_sbb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)
`BatchS101006M`	`81.6070`	`769440.00000000`
`BatchS121208M`	`99.3970`	`1241130.00000000`
`BatchS151208M`	`123.5030`	`1543470.00000000`
`BatchS201210M`	`517.8210`	`2295350.00000000`
`clay0203h`	`3.9370`	`41573.30000000`
`clay0203m`	`1.8450`	`41573.30000000`
`clay0204h`	`43.6850`	`6545.00000000`
`clay0204m`	`10.9330`	`6545.00000000`
`clay0205h`	`688.0400`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0205m`	`231.4940`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0303h`	`6.9610`	`26669.10000000`
`clay0304h`	`510.2070`	`40262.40000000`
`clay0304m`	`94.4630`	`40262.40000000`
`clay0305h`	`1521.9900`	`8092.50000000`
`clay0305m`	`186.2620`	`8092.50000000`
`FLay03H`	`1.0190`	`48.98980000`
`FLay03M`	`0.6440`	`48.98980000`
`FLay04H`	`25.2120`	`54.40590000`
`FLay04M`	`10.0850`	`54.40590000`
`FLay05M`	`504.3070`	`64.49810000`
`RSyn0810H`	`2.9460`	`1721.45000000`
`RSyn0810M02H`	`20.7120`	`1741.39000000`
`RSyn0810M03H`	`106.6050`	`2722.45000000`
`RSyn0810M04H`	`30.6420`	`6581.94000000`
`RSyn0810M`	`788.8410`	`1721.45000000`
`RSyn0820H`	`4.6940`	`1150.30000000`
`RSyn0820M02H`	`58.5700`	`1092.09000000`
`RSyn0820M03H`	`514.5710`	`2028.81000000`
`RSyn0820M04H`	`427.0530`	`2450.77000000`
`RSyn0820M`	`7190.5900`	`1150.30000000`
`RSyn0840H`	`2.1890`	`325.55500000`
`RSyn0840M02H`	`18.9290`	`734.98400000`
`RSyn0840M03H`	`113.8710`	`2742.65000000`
`RSyn0840M04H`	`740.9130`	`2564.50000000`
`SLay05H`	`22.2240`	`22664.70000000`
`SLay05M`	`2.3020`	`22664.70000000`
`SLay06H`	`387.8510`	`32757.00000000`
`SLay06M`	`1.1210`	`32757.00000000`
`SLay07M`	`13.6680`	`64748.80000000`
`SLay08M`	`4.8160`	`84960.20000000`
`SLay09M`	`330.1600`	`107806.00000000`
`SLay10M`	`538.4240`	`129580.00000000`
`Syn10H`	`0.1120`	`1267.35000000`
`Syn10M02H`	`0.2850`	`2310.30000000`
`Syn10M02M`	`3.3410`	`2310.30000000`
`Syn10M03H`	`0.4480`	`3354.68000000`
`Syn10M03M`	`13.2780`	`3354.68000000`
`Syn10M04H`	`0.5910`	`4557.06000000`
`Syn10M04M`	`58.3070`	`4557.06000000`
`Syn10M`	`0.2170`	`1267.35000000`
`Syn20H`	`0.2040`	`924.26300000`
`Syn20M02H`	`0.9990`	`1752.13000000`
`Syn20M02M`	`819.5300`	`1752.13000000`
`Syn20M03H`	`1.1720`	`2646.95000000`
`Syn20M04H`	`1.7440`	`3532.74000000`
`Syn20M`	`3.3160`	`924.26300000`
`Syn40H`	`0.8680`	`67.71340000`
`Syn40M02H`	`3.8970`	`388.77300000`
`Syn40M03H`	`16.2270`	`395.14900000`
`Syn40M04H`	`60.9210`	`901.75200000`
`sssd-8-4-3`	`931.0760`	`197181.00000000`
`uflquad-15-60`	`15.8290`	`1063.19000000`
`uflquad-15-80`	`37.1940`	`1217.99000000`
`uflquad-20-40`	`19.0030`	`860.96100000`
`uflquad-20-50`	`1623.3800`	`375.91900000`
`uflquad-25-25`	`5.7650`	`673.69700000`
`uflquad-25-30`	`4.6730`	`669.84000000`
`uflquad-25-40`	`27.5040`	`828.16500000`
`nd-10`	`472.2360`	`52.46110000`
`nd-12`	`2721.8200`	`56.66960000`
`m3`	`0.4660`	`37.80000000`
`m6`	`1321.2900`	`82.25690000`
`m7_ar2_1`	`2283.0700`	`190.23500000`
`m7_ar25_1`	`4391.6700`	`143.58500000`
`m7_ar4_1`	`7134.8100`	`106.75700000`
`netmod_kar1`	`204.3500`	`-0.41979000`
`netmod_kar2`	`202.6730`	`-0.41979000`
`tls2`	`4.2320`	`5.30000000`

SBB_sbb: feasible:

Modelname	Time (SBB_sbb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)
`FLay06H`	`7451.7700`	`66.93280000`
`RSyn0810M02M`	`8679.9900`	`1592.16000000`
`RSyn0810M03M`	`7569.2100`	`2368.77000000`
`RSyn0810M04M`	`7495.6000`	`5433.33000000`
`RSyn0820M02M`	`7627.2200`	`669.53700000`
`RSyn0820M03M`	`7451.4200`	`1439.77000000`
`RSyn0820M04M`	`7396.6400`	`1563.83000000`
`RSyn0840M02M`	`8159.1100`	`191.12600000`
`RSyn0840M03M`	`7609.5000`	`2241.35000000`
`RSyn0840M04M`	`7575.0000`	`2301.43000000`
`RSyn0840M`	`11688.7000`	`247.39700000`
`SLay07H`	`7383.1600`	`64748.80000000`
`SLay08H`	`7413.2200`	`85115.00000000`
`SLay09H`	`7412.7900`	`122507.00000000`
`SLay10H`	`7356.2200`	`153256.00000000`
`Syn20M03M`	`7954.4200`	`2646.95000000`
`Syn20M04M`	`7781.6900`	`3500.74000000`
`Syn40M02M`	`8804.5400`	`344.48700000`
`Syn40M03M`	`7548.5800`	`294.29000000`
`Syn40M04M`	`7557.2600`	`831.89600000`
`Syn40M`	`10415.2000`	`67.71330000`
`sssd-10-4-3`	`12944.6000`	`159329.00000000`
`sssd-12-5-3`	`19374.5000`	`330320.00000000`
`sssd-15-6-3`	`15779.7000`	`513871.00000000`
`sssd-16-8-3`	`13118.5000`	`709652.00000000`
`sssd-18-8-3`	`12851.3000`	`637320.00000000`
`sssd-20-9-3`	`11853.3000`	`510261.00000000`
`sssd-22-8-3`	`12055.5000`	`730203.00000000`
`nd-13`	`7251.3700`	`65.90790000`
`nd-15`	`7230.4100`	`86.92650000`
`nd-16`	`7227.5800`	`102.09800000`
`fo7_2`	`7403.9100`	`17.74930000`
`fo7_ar2_1`	`7545.5400`	`34.87130000`
`fo7_ar25_1`	`7414.1500`	`25.67840000`
`fo7_ar3_1`	`7413.0500`	`23.12100000`
`fo7_ar4_1`	`7368.0300`	`29.47550000`
`fo7_ar5_1`	`7340.0900`	`19.01200000`
`fo7`	`7431.2200`	`28.45230000`
`fo8_ar2_1`	`7498.4800`	`48.41990000`
`fo8_ar25_1`	`7372.1000`	`41.63040000`
`fo8_ar3_1`	`7329.2200`	`40.79120000`
`fo8_ar4_1`	`7294.2400`	`33.46530000`
`fo8_ar5_1`	`7299.6800`	`45.65780000`
`fo8`	`7381.7800`	`41.06960000`
`fo9_ar5_1`	`7263.1100`	`41.66030000`
`fo9`	`7344.6400`	`49.96150000`
`m7_ar3_1`	`7479.4900`	`143.58500000`
`m7_ar5_1`	`7336.1600`	`106.46000000`
`m7`	`7448.1800`	`106.75700000`
`netmod_dol1`	`7214.8800`	`-0.55139800`
`no7_ar2_1`	`7471.5700`	`151.86000000`
`no7_ar25_1`	`7380.7300`	`148.78600000`
`no7_ar3_1`	`7374.7100`	`134.42700000`
`no7_ar4_1`	`7367.5900`	`120.70100000`
`no7_ar5_1`	`7343.6400`	`118.38200000`
`o7_2`	`7409.9700`	`122.35300000`
`o7_ar2_1`	`7458.1000`	`177.94600000`
`o7_ar25_1`	`7424.6000`	`180.92200000`
`o7_ar3_1`	`7369.9300`	`163.97700000`
`o7_ar4_1`	`7346.2800`	`183.00000000`
`o7_ar5_1`	`7350.2000`	`129.23900000`
`o7`	`7424.4200`	`165.39600000`
`o8_ar4_1`	`7302.2300`	`304.80900000`
`tls4`	`15208.6000`	`13.70000000`
`tls5`	`10552.2000`	`15.60000000`
`tls6`	`9148.5200`	`21.40000000`

SBB_sbb: fail:

Modelname	Time (SBB_sbb)	Status (SBB_sbb)
`clay0303m`	`--`	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`
`FLay05H`	`--`	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`
`FLay06M`	`--`	`mstat(13)sstat( 1)`
`fo9_ar2_1`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar25_1`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar3_1`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`fo9_ar4_1`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`netmod_dol2`	`--`	`mstat(13)sstat(13)`
`o9_ar4_1`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`tls12`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`tls7`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`

BONMIN_bonmin-bb: all -- SBB_sbb: all

A "(max)" behind a model names indicates that this model is a maximization model.

Rows with red background in the model name mark inconsistencies, caused by negative gaps or objective values of one solver that are better than the objestive estimate of the other solver.

A model is counted as solved if the gap reported by the solver is at most 0.00015. The gap is in this case displayed with a green background.

A shifted geometric mean of the solver time is computed, where unsolved instances and instances above the timelimit are counted with the timelimit (19374.50 seconds). The shift is 10s.

Modelname	Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Time (SBB_sbb)	Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb/ SBB_sbb)	Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Obj (SBB_sbb)	ObjEst (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	ObjEst (SBB_sbb)	Gap (BONMIN_bonmin-bb)	Gap (SBB_sbb)
`BatchS101006M`	`18.3460`	`81.6070`	`0.225`	`769440.00000000`	`769440.00000000`	`769440.00000000`	`769440.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`BatchS121208M`	`37.3690`	`99.3970`	`0.376`	`1241130.00000000`	`1241130.00000000`	`1241130.00000000`	`1241130.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`BatchS151208M`	`110.9250`	`123.5030`	`0.898`	`1543470.00000000`	`1543470.00000000`	`1543470.00000000`	`1543470.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`BatchS201210M`	`144.9750`	`517.8210`	`0.280`	`2295350.00000000`	`2295350.00000000`	`2295350.00000000`	`2295350.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0203h`	`6.8740`	`3.9370`	`1.746`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0203m`	`4.2890`	`1.8450`	`2.325`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`	`41573.30000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0204h`	`52.7820`	`43.6850`	`1.208`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0204m`	`9.1500`	`10.9330`	`0.837`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`	`6545.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0205h`	`1775.5400`	`688.0400`	`2.581`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0205m`	`708.5470`	`231.4940`	`3.061`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0303h`	`18.6050`	`6.9610`	`2.673`	`26669.10000000`	`26669.10000000`	`26669.10000000`	`26669.10000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0303m`	`5.5580`	`1.7160`	---	`26669.10000000`	`mstat(13) sstat(1)`	`26669.10000000`	---	`0.0000`	`---`
`clay0304h`	`208.0350`	`510.2070`	`0.408`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0304m`	`61.5350`	`94.4630`	`0.651`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`	`40262.40000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0305h`	`1662.5000`	`1521.9900`	`1.092`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`clay0305m`	`250.6350`	`186.2620`	`1.346`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`8092.50000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`FLay03H`	`2.2550`	`1.0190`	`2.213`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`FLay03M`	`0.8650`	`0.6440`	`1.343`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`	`48.98980000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`FLay04H`	`38.9700`	`25.2120`	`1.546`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`FLay04M`	`12.8400`	`10.0850`	`1.273`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`	`54.40590000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`FLay05H`	`3506.4800`	`2611.9300`	---	`64.49810000`	`mstat(13) sstat(1)`	`64.49810000`	---	`0.0000`	`---`
`FLay05M`	`617.4280`	`504.3070`	`1.224`	`64.49810000`	`64.49810000`	`64.49810000`	`64.49810000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`FLay06H`	`7394.3800`	`7451.7700`	`0.992`	`66.93280000`	`66.93280000`	`60.00000000`	`51.70410000`	`0.1155`	`0.2945`
`FLay06M`	`7661.7800`	`11788.9000`	---	`66.93280000`	`mstat(13) sstat(1)`	`64.49810000`	---	`0.0377`	`---`
`RSyn0810H (max)`	`3.0840`	`2.9460`	`1.047`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0810M02H (max)`	`18.2470`	`20.7120`	`0.881`	`1741.39000000`	`1741.39000000`	`1741.39000000`	`1741.39000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0810M02M (max)`	`7375.6600`	`8679.9900`	`0.850`	`1712.69000000`	`1592.16000000`	`2660.89000000`	`3137.64000000`	`0.3563`	`0.4926`
`RSyn0810M03H (max)`	`53.8100`	`106.6050`	`0.505`	`2722.45000000`	`2722.45000000`	`2722.45000000`	`2722.45000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0810M03M (max)`	`7323.3200`	`7569.2100`	`0.968`	`2712.25000000`	`2368.77000000`	`3758.91000000`	`5509.95000000`	`0.2784`	`0.5701`
`RSyn0810M04H (max)`	`30.9780`	`30.6420`	`1.011`	`6581.94000000`	`6581.94000000`	`6581.94000000`	`6581.94000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0810M04M (max)`	`7294.0800`	`7495.6000`	`0.973`	`6511.67000000`	`5433.33000000`	`8852.77000000`	`10821.10000000`	`0.2644`	`0.4979`
`RSyn0810M (max)`	`450.3500`	`788.8410`	`0.571`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`	`1721.45000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0820H (max)`	`5.5110`	`4.6940`	`1.174`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0820M02H (max)`	`22.9370`	`58.5700`	`0.392`	`1092.09000000`	`1092.09000000`	`1092.09000000`	`1092.09000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0820M02M (max)`	`7354.5600`	`7627.2200`	`0.964`	`973.26200000`	`669.53700000`	`2383.29000000`	`4051.07000000`	`0.5916`	`0.8347`
`RSyn0820M03H (max)`	`75.2470`	`514.5710`	`0.146`	`2028.81000000`	`2028.81000000`	`2028.81000000`	`2028.81000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0820M03M (max)`	`7306.8100`	`7451.4200`	`0.981`	`1952.37000000`	`1439.77000000`	`4591.76000000`	`5861.88000000`	`0.5748`	`0.7544`
`RSyn0820M04H (max)`	`91.3950`	`427.0530`	`0.214`	`2450.77000000`	`2450.77000000`	`2450.77000000`	`2450.77000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0820M04M (max)`	`7273.8100`	`7396.6400`	`0.983`	`2347.74000000`	`1563.83000000`	`6735.90000000`	`8372.19000000`	`0.6515`	`0.8132`
`RSyn0820M (max)`	`3363.6400`	`7190.5900`	`0.468`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`	`1150.30000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0840H (max)`	`3.7300`	`2.1890`	`1.704`	`325.55500000`	`325.55500000`	`325.55500000`	`325.55500000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0840M02H (max)`	`23.3200`	`18.9290`	`1.232`	`734.98400000`	`734.98400000`	`734.98400000`	`734.98400000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0840M02M (max)`	`7321.5600`	`8159.1100`	`0.897`	`636.57100000`	`191.12600000`	`3524.62000000`	`4639.90000000`	`0.8194`	`0.9588`
`RSyn0840M03H (max)`	`66.9090`	`113.8710`	`0.588`	`2742.65000000`	`2742.65000000`	`2742.65000000`	`2742.65000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0840M03M (max)`	`7282.9700`	`7609.5000`	`0.957`	`2643.92000000`	`2241.35000000`	`6439.72000000`	`7850.66000000`	`0.5894`	`0.7145`
`RSyn0840M04H (max)`	`240.4630`	`740.9130`	`0.325`	`2564.50000000`	`2564.50000000`	`2564.50000000`	`2564.50000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`RSyn0840M04M (max)`	`7267.4400`	`7575.0000`	`0.959`	`2293.65000000`	`2301.43000000`	`10426.00000000`	`12846.10000000`	`0.7800`	`0.8208`
`RSyn0840M (max)`	`7448.0700`	`11688.7000`	`0.637`	`318.55500000`	`247.39700000`	`628.57700000`	`1497.16000000`	`0.4932`	`0.8348`
`SLay05H`	`4.4500`	`22.2240`	`0.200`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`SLay05M`	`2.5770`	`2.3020`	`1.119`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`	`22664.70000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`SLay06H`	`54.5440`	`387.8510`	`0.141`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`SLay06M`	`27.4070`	`1.1210`	`24.449`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`	`32757.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`SLay07H`	`67.9740`	`7383.1600`	`0.009`	`64748.80000000`	`64748.80000000`	`64748.80000000`	`64698.40000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0008`
`SLay07M`	`66.4610`	`13.6680`	`4.863`	`64748.80000000`	`64748.80000000`	`64748.80000000`	`64748.80000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`SLay08H`	`69.2590`	`7413.2200`	`0.009`	`84960.20000000`	`85115.00000000`	`84960.20000000`	`82023.90000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0377`
`SLay08M`	`67.5310`	`4.8160`	`14.022`	`84960.20000000`	`84960.20000000`	`84960.20000000`	`84960.20000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`SLay09H`	`79.2830`	`7412.7900`	`0.011`	`107806.00000000`	`122507.00000000`	`107806.00000000`	`103264.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.1863`
`SLay09M`	`69.8780`	`330.1600`	`0.212`	`107806.00000000`	`107806.00000000`	`107806.00000000`	`107806.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`SLay10H`	`336.6470`	`7356.2200`	`0.046`	`129580.00000000`	`153256.00000000`	`129580.00000000`	`119326.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.2843`
`SLay10M`	`144.9750`	`538.4240`	`0.269`	`129580.00000000`	`129580.00000000`	`129580.00000000`	`129580.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10H (max)`	`0.3520`	`0.1120`	`3.143`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10M02H (max)`	`0.3180`	`0.2850`	`1.116`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10M02M (max)`	`4.5530`	`3.3410`	`1.363`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`	`2310.30000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10M03H (max)`	`0.7190`	`0.4480`	`1.605`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10M03M (max)`	`19.6690`	`13.2780`	`1.481`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`	`3354.68000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10M04H (max)`	`1.0620`	`0.5910`	`1.797`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10M04M (max)`	`56.4720`	`58.3070`	`0.969`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`	`4557.06000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn10M (max)`	`0.6270`	`0.2170`	`2.889`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`	`1267.35000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn20H (max)`	`0.4150`	`0.2040`	`2.034`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn20M02H (max)`	`2.2460`	`0.9990`	`2.248`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn20M02M (max)`	`458.7050`	`819.5300`	`0.560`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`	`1752.13000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn20M03H (max)`	`4.2170`	`1.1720`	`3.598`	`2646.95000000`	`2646.95000000`	`2646.95000000`	`2646.95000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn20M03M (max)`	`4346.9500`	`7954.4200`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(1)`	`2646.95000000`	---	`2658.98000000`	`---`	`0.0045`
`Syn20M04H (max)`	`7.6110`	`1.7440`	`4.364`	`3532.74000000`	`3532.74000000`	`3532.74000000`	`3532.74000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn20M04M (max)`	`12.8750`	`7781.6900`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(1)`	`3500.74000000`	---	`4698.66000000`	`---`	`0.2549`
`Syn20M (max)`	`4.8100`	`3.3160`	`1.451`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`	`924.26300000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn40H (max)`	`1.5330`	`0.8680`	`1.766`	`67.71340000`	`67.71340000`	`67.71340000`	`67.71340000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn40M02H (max)`	`3.5190`	`3.8970`	`0.903`	`388.77300000`	`388.77300000`	`388.77300000`	`388.77300000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn40M02M (max)`	`7384.0100`	`8804.5400`	`0.839`	`360.41500000`	`344.48700000`	`838.70100000`	`1726.45000000`	`0.5703`	`0.8005`
`Syn40M03H (max)`	`17.1110`	`16.2270`	`1.054`	`395.14900000`	`395.14900000`	`395.14900000`	`395.14900000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn40M03M (max)`	`7331.7900`	`7548.5800`	`0.971`	`331.14400000`	`294.29000000`	`2046.18000000`	`4342.80000000`	`0.8382`	`0.9322`
`Syn40M04H (max)`	`53.4430`	`60.9210`	`0.877`	`901.75200000`	`901.75200000`	`901.75200000`	`901.75200000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`Syn40M04M (max)`	`7295.7900`	`7557.2600`	`0.965`	`808.85200000`	`831.89600000`	`3468.91000000`	`5965.61000000`	`0.7668`	`0.8606`
`Syn40M (max)`	`973.0320`	`10415.2000`	`0.093`	`67.71330000`	`67.71330000`	`67.71330000`	`257.14600000`	`0.0000`	`0.7367`
`sssd-8-4-3`	`9.6910`	`931.0760`	`0.010`	`197181.00000000`	`197181.00000000`	`197181.00000000`	`197181.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`sssd-10-4-3`	`12.5650`	`12944.6000`	`0.001`	`152710.00000000`	`159329.00000000`	`152710.00000000`	`143244.00000000`	`0.0000`	`0.1123`
`sssd-12-5-3`	`52.5360`	`19374.5000`	`0.003`	`261143.00000000`	`330320.00000000`	`261143.00000000`	`101530.00000000`	`0.0000`	`2.2534`
`sssd-15-6-3`	`231.9490`	`15779.7000`	`0.015`	`440711.00000000`	`513871.00000000`	`440711.00000000`	`155381.00000000`	`0.0000`	`2.3072`
`sssd-16-8-3`	`7649.9500`	`13118.5000`	`0.583`	`616043.00000000`	`709652.00000000`	`615229.00000000`	`223552.00000000`	`0.0013`	`2.1744`
`sssd-18-8-3`	`7643.5000`	`12851.3000`	`0.595`	`524139.00000000`	`637320.00000000`	`523745.00000000`	`192178.00000000`	`0.0008`	`2.3163`
`sssd-20-9-3`	`7616.2900`	`11853.3000`	`0.643`	`478924.00000000`	`510261.00000000`	`477253.00000000`	`180409.00000000`	`0.0035`	`1.8284`
`sssd-22-8-3`	`7614.5400`	`12055.5000`	`0.632`	`596139.00000000`	`730203.00000000`	`595726.00000000`	`216626.00000000`	`0.0007`	`2.3708`
`uflquad-15-60`	`12.4560`	`15.8290`	`0.787`	`1063.19000000`	`1063.19000000`	`1063.19000000`	`1063.19000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`uflquad-15-80`	`22.6090`	`37.1940`	`0.608`	`1217.99000000`	`1217.99000000`	`1217.99000000`	`1217.99000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`uflquad-20-40`	`17.2550`	`19.0030`	`0.908`	`860.96100000`	`860.96100000`	`860.96100000`	`860.96100000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`uflquad-20-50`	`225.1360`	`1623.3800`	`0.139`	`375.91900000`	`375.91900000`	`375.91900000`	`375.91900000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`uflquad-25-25`	`10.5160`	`5.7650`	`1.824`	`673.69700000`	`673.69700000`	`673.69700000`	`673.69700000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`uflquad-25-30`	`12.5240`	`4.6730`	`2.680`	`669.84000000`	`669.84000000`	`669.84000000`	`669.84000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`uflquad-25-40`	`23.3470`	`27.5040`	`0.849`	`828.16500000`	`828.16500000`	`828.16500000`	`828.16500000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`nd-10`	`1189.2800`	`472.2360`	`2.518`	`52.46110000`	`52.46110000`	`52.46110000`	`52.46110000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`nd-12`	`7239.3100`	`2721.8200`	`2.660`	`58.30360000`	`56.66960000`	`54.74920000`	`56.66960000`	`0.0649`	`0.0000`
`nd-13`	`7237.1500`	`7251.3700`	`0.998`	`64.98350000`	`65.90790000`	`50.34500000`	`54.66070000`	`0.2908`	`0.2058`
`nd-15`	`7227.0400`	`7230.4100`	`1.000`	`83.33530000`	`86.92650000`	`60.07600000`	`65.11490000`	`0.3872`	`0.3350`
`nd-16`	`7227.7000`	`7227.5800`	`1.000`	`99.04390000`	`102.09800000`	`81.15100000`	`78.22420000`	`0.2205`	`0.3052`
`fo7_2`	`2031.2700`	`7403.9100`	`0.274`	`17.74930000`	`17.74930000`	`17.74930000`	`11.09430000`	`0.0000`	`0.5999`
`fo7_ar2_1`	`7489.7600`	`7545.5400`	`0.993`	`24.83980000`	`34.87130000`	`24.24210000`	`19.42240000`	`0.0247`	`0.7954`
`fo7_ar25_1`	`7485.8900`	`7414.1500`	`1.010`	`25.58910000`	`25.67840000`	`20.66020000`	`17.25980000`	`0.2386`	`0.4878`
`fo7_ar3_1`	`7504.2700`	`7413.0500`	`1.012`	`24.19550000`	`23.12100000`	`19.48500000`	`15.69890000`	`0.2418`	`0.4728`
`fo7_ar4_1`	`7491.1600`	`7368.0300`	`1.017`	`20.72980000`	`29.47550000`	`20.20060000`	`14.72570000`	`0.0262`	`1.0016`
`fo7_ar5_1`	`4544.9200`	`7340.0900`	`0.619`	`17.74930000`	`19.01200000`	`17.74930000`	`14.63770000`	`0.0000`	`0.2988`
`fo7`	`7510.0700`	`7431.2200`	`1.011`	`20.72980000`	`28.45230000`	`20.65930000`	`10.19240000`	`0.0034`	`1.7915`
`fo8_ar2_1`	`7456.9100`	`7498.4800`	`0.994`	`48.68170000`	`48.41990000`	`23.75590000`	`16.71750000`	`1.0492`	`1.8964`
`fo8_ar25_1`	`7466.7000`	`7372.1000`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`41.63040000`	---	`14.27250000`	`---`	`1.9168`
`fo8_ar3_1`	`7454.6600`	`7329.2200`	`1.017`	`39.65250000`	`40.79120000`	`21.45650000`	`11.67870000`	`0.8480`	`2.4928`
`fo8_ar4_1`	`7459.2200`	`7294.2400`	`1.023`	`28.46650000`	`33.46530000`	`19.75000000`	`11.17020000`	`0.4413`	`1.9959`
`fo8_ar5_1`	`7462.5000`	`7299.6800`	`1.022`	`24.42260000`	`45.65780000`	`17.50910000`	`12.09400000`	`0.3949`	`2.7752`
`fo8`	`7478.3600`	`7381.7800`	`1.013`	`26.86260000`	`41.06960000`	`19.65960000`	`7.74500000`	`0.3664`	`4.3027`
`fo9_ar2_1`	`7427.4000`	`7424.3900`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	---	---	---	---
`fo9_ar25_1`	`7422.6000`	`7375.1300`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	---	---	---	---
`fo9_ar3_1`	`7423.6500`	`7292.3500`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	---	---	---	---
`fo9_ar4_1`	`7424.4900`	`7268.4700`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	---	---	---	---
`fo9_ar5_1`	`7424.9100`	`7263.1100`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`41.66030000`	---	`7.82468000`	`---`	`4.3242`
`fo9`	`7445.8100`	`7344.6400`	`1.014`	`30.46430000`	`49.96150000`	`15.34770000`	`6.50795000`	`0.9849`	`6.6770`
`m3`	`1.3530`	`0.4660`	`2.903`	`37.80000000`	`37.80000000`	`37.80000000`	`37.80000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`m6`	`46.2730`	`1321.2900`	`0.035`	`82.25690000`	`82.25690000`	`82.25690000`	`82.25690000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`m7_ar2_1`	`2569.7700`	`2283.0700`	`1.126`	`190.23500000`	`190.23500000`	`190.23500000`	`190.23500000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`m7_ar25_1`	`166.4970`	`4391.6700`	`0.038`	`143.58500000`	`143.58500000`	`143.58500000`	`143.58500000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`m7_ar3_1`	`7483.3400`	`7479.4900`	`1.001`	`143.58500000`	`143.58500000`	`132.58100000`	`119.94100000`	`0.0830`	`0.1971`
`m7_ar4_1`	`7488.2500`	`7134.8100`	`1.050`	`148.62000000`	`106.75700000`	`93.12320000`	`106.75700000`	`0.5960`	`0.0000`
`m7_ar5_1`	`7487.6700`	`7336.1600`	`1.021`	`106.46000000`	`106.46000000`	`95.02320000`	`94.28920000`	`0.1204`	`0.1291`
`m7`	`507.3050`	`7448.1800`	`0.068`	`106.75700000`	`106.75700000`	`106.75700000`	`98.71500000`	`0.0000`	`0.0815`
`netmod_dol1`	`7250.5400`	`7214.8800`	`1.005`	`-0.56000800`	`-0.55139800`	`-0.61127200`	`-0.65233400`	`0.0839`	`0.1547`
`netmod_dol2`	`1936.8100`	`5.3840`	---	`-0.56000800`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`-0.56000800`	---	`0.0000`	`---`
`netmod_kar1`	`15.0230`	`204.3500`	`0.074`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`netmod_kar2`	`15.0430`	`202.6730`	`0.074`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`	`-0.41979000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`no7_ar2_1`	`7503.1200`	`7471.5700`	`1.004`	`125.58900000`	`151.86000000`	`84.26260000`	`71.94960000`	`0.4904`	`1.1106`
`no7_ar25_1`	`7492.9500`	`7380.7300`	`1.015`	`115.10000000`	`148.78600000`	`86.25610000`	`60.32300000`	`0.3344`	`1.4665`
`no7_ar3_1`	`7500.7900`	`7374.7100`	`1.017`	`117.22400000`	`134.42700000`	`81.15050000`	`56.45360000`	`0.4445`	`1.3812`
`no7_ar4_1`	`7496.5500`	`7367.5900`	`1.018`	`100.41900000`	`120.70100000`	`82.50910000`	`55.14560000`	`0.2171`	`1.1888`
`no7_ar5_1`	`7486.4200`	`7343.6400`	`1.019`	`90.62270000`	`118.38200000`	`86.93780000`	`50.43270000`	`0.0424`	`1.3473`
`o7_2`	`7514.5300`	`7409.9700`	`1.014`	`116.94600000`	`122.35300000`	`90.89210000`	`59.31550000`	`0.2866`	`1.0627`
`o7_ar2_1`	`7480.0300`	`7458.1000`	`1.003`	`153.24900000`	`177.94600000`	`106.53200000`	`81.91440000`	`0.4385`	`1.1723`
`o7_ar25_1`	`7497.6300`	`7424.6000`	`1.010`	`151.01400000`	`180.92200000`	`98.40300000`	`78.99120000`	`0.5346`	`1.2904`
`o7_ar3_1`	`7488.1600`	`7369.9300`	`1.016`	`146.09600000`	`163.97700000`	`99.94000000`	`77.16780000`	`0.4618`	`1.1249`
`o7_ar4_1`	`7482.3300`	`7346.2800`	`1.019`	`136.73100000`	`183.00000000`	`97.48570000`	`69.24490000`	`0.4026`	`1.6428`
`o7_ar5_1`	`7488.1200`	`7350.2000`	`1.019`	`118.76700000`	`129.23900000`	`92.16150000`	`74.41120000`	`0.2887`	`0.7368`
`o7`	`7521.1600`	`7424.4200`	`1.013`	`131.65300000`	`165.39600000`	`96.09110000`	`51.96060000`	`0.3701`	`2.1831`
`o8_ar4_1`	`7450.2100`	`7302.2300`	`1.020`	`298.51200000`	`304.80900000`	`133.62500000`	`108.77000000`	`1.2340`	`1.8023`
`o9_ar4_1`	`7422.0700`	`7297.6900`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	---	---	---	---
`tls12`	`7370.2300`	`7667.1300`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	---	---	---	---
`tls2`	`5.9730`	`4.2320`	`1.411`	`5.30000000`	`5.30000000`	`5.30000000`	`5.30000000`	`0.0000`	`0.0000`
`tls4`	`7676.4700`	`15208.6000`	`0.505`	`8.30000000`	`13.70000000`	`5.65847000`	`2.27539000`	`0.4668`	`5.0209`
`tls5`	`7597.7300`	`10552.2000`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`15.60000000`	---	`1.81080000`	`---`	`7.6150`
`tls6`	`7535.5100`	`9148.5200`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`21.40000000`	---	`1.92937000`	`---`	`10.0917`
`tls7`	`7489.1300`	`8474.5600`	---	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`	---	---	---	---
Shifted Geometric Mean (Solved)	698.09	1170.83
% Unsolved	41.94%	49.68%