## Resource Times:

Results created on 09/14/12 19:33:58 using the PAVER Server/Performance tools available at http://www.gamsworld.eu/performance/paver

See the solver return definitions for optimal/feasible model and solve statuses. Solutions are not checked for how close they are to eachother.

Resource times are considered the same, if they are within 10% of eachother. A solver is considered faster than another, if it is less than 50% faster than the other. A solver is considered much faster than another, if it is more than 50% faster than the other.

If a model was not solved optimal/feasible by both solvers, the resource time is considered the same. If a model was solved optimal/feasible by solver A but not by solver B, then solver A is considered infinitely faster than solver B. Similarly, if one solver has trace data and the other has no data, then the first solver is consideredinfinitely faster.

A solver is considered to have a better objective function value, if the relative objective value difference is greater than 1.50E-04 For objective values below 1e-1 we use absolute differences.

Input File Number Filename
Tracefile 1: minlpconvex_bonmin-bb.pav
Tracefile 2: minlpconvex_sbb.pav
Solvers used : BONMIN_bonmin-bb
SBB_sbb
Modeltype(s)   MINLP
Threshold: Solver Faster 10%
Threshold: Solver Much Faster 50%
Threshold: Solver Infinitely Faster Other solver failed

Total Obj BONMIN_bonmin-bb better Obj same Obj SBB_sbb better
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb infinitely faster : 4 4 - -
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb much faster : 29 6 23 -
Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb faster : 22 10 12 -
Solvers perform the same : 48 33 10 5
Solver SBB_sbb faster : 21 - 21 -
Solver SBB_sbb much faster : 18 - 17 1
Solver SBB_sbb infinitely faster : 6 - - 6
Both solvers failed to solve optimally : 7 - 7 -
Total models: : 155539012

### Solver return definition:

Outcome Model Status Solver Status
globally optimal 1 or 15 1
locally optimal/feasible 2 or 8 or 16 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 or 8

### Resource Times:

• Models for each resource time category. Listed are the solver resource times TIME(.) in seconds, as well as the ratio of resource times RATIO(.)for the two solvers if both solved optimally. Models not solved optimally by a solver have status listed instead of resource time.
• Also listed are the objective values OBJ(.) using both solvers. The better solution found is listed in boldface. A solution is considered better, if the relative objective function difference is greater than 1.50E-04.
• Solver resource time ratios for a particular model are listed only if both solvers are optimal and if one solver has resource time greater than 5.00E-02.

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb infinitely faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-bb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) clay0303m 5.5580 fail -- 2.66691000E+04 2.75883000E+04 FLay05H 3506.4800 fail -- 6.44981000E+01 6.40444000E+01 FLay06M 7661.7800 fail -- 6.69328000E+01 6.67916000E+01 netmod_dol2 1936.8100 fail -- -5.60008000E-01 -6.47293000E-01

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb much faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-bb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) SLay08H 69.2590 7413.2200 0.009 8.49602000E+04 8.51150000E+04 SLay09H 79.2830 7412.7900 0.011 1.07806000E+05 1.22507000E+05 SLay10H 336.6470 7356.2200 0.046 1.29580000E+05 1.53256000E+05 sssd-10-4-3 12.5650 12944.6000 0.001 1.52710000E+05 1.59329000E+05 sssd-12-5-3 52.5360 19374.5000 0.003 2.61143000E+05 3.30320000E+05 sssd-15-6-3 231.9490 15779.7000 0.015 4.40711000E+05 5.13871000E+05

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb much faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) BatchS101006M 18.3460 81.6070 0.225 7.69440000E+05 7.69440000E+05 BatchS121208M 37.3690 99.3970 0.376 1.24113000E+06 1.24113000E+06 BatchS201210M 144.9750 517.8210 0.280 2.29535000E+06 2.29535000E+06 clay0304h 208.0350 510.2070 0.408 4.02624000E+04 4.02624000E+04 RSyn0820M02H 22.9370 58.5700 0.392 1.09209000E+03 1.09209000E+03 RSyn0820M03H 75.2470 514.5710 0.146 2.02881000E+03 2.02881000E+03 RSyn0820M04H 91.3950 427.0530 0.214 2.45077000E+03 2.45077000E+03 RSyn0820M 3363.6400 7190.5900 0.468 1.15030000E+03 1.15030000E+03 RSyn0840M04H 240.4630 740.9130 0.325 2.56450000E+03 2.56450000E+03 SLay05H 4.4500 22.2240 0.200 2.26647000E+04 2.26647000E+04 SLay06H 54.5440 387.8510 0.141 3.27570000E+04 3.27570000E+04 SLay07H 67.9740 7383.1600 0.009 6.47488000E+04 6.47488000E+04 SLay09M 69.8780 330.1600 0.212 1.07806000E+05 1.07806000E+05 SLay10M 144.9750 538.4240 0.269 1.29580000E+05 1.29580000E+05 Syn40M 973.0320 10415.2000 0.093 6.77133000E+01 6.77133000E+01 sssd-8-4-3 9.6910 931.0760 0.010 1.97181000E+05 1.97181000E+05 uflquad-20-50 225.1360 1623.3800 0.139 3.75919000E+02 3.75919000E+02 fo7_2 2031.2700 7403.9100 0.274 1.77493000E+01 1.77493000E+01 m6 46.2730 1321.2900 0.035 8.22569000E+01 8.22569000E+01 m7_ar25_1 166.4970 4391.6700 0.038 1.43585000E+02 1.43585000E+02 m7 507.3050 7448.1800 0.068 1.06757000E+02 1.06757000E+02 netmod_kar1 15.0230 204.3500 0.074 -4.19790000E-01 -4.19790000E-01 netmod_kar2 15.0430 202.6730 0.074 -4.19790000E-01 -4.19790000E-01

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb faster - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-bb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) RSyn0810M02M 7375.6600 8679.9900 0.850 1.71269000E+03 1.59216000E+03 RSyn0840M02M 7321.5600 8159.1100 0.897 6.36571000E+02 1.91126000E+02 RSyn0840M 7448.0700 11688.7000 0.637 3.18555000E+02 2.47397000E+02 Syn40M02M 7384.0100 8804.5400 0.839 3.60415000E+02 3.44487000E+02 sssd-16-8-3 7649.9500 13118.5000 0.583 6.16043000E+05 7.09652000E+05 sssd-18-8-3 7643.5000 12851.3000 0.595 5.24139000E+05 6.37320000E+05 sssd-20-9-3 7616.2900 11853.3000 0.643 4.78924000E+05 5.10261000E+05 sssd-22-8-3 7614.5400 12055.5000 0.632 5.96139000E+05 7.30203000E+05 fo7_ar5_1 4544.9200 7340.0900 0.619 1.77493000E+01 1.90120000E+01 tls4 7676.4700 15208.6000 0.505 8.30000000E+00 1.37000000E+01

### Solver BONMIN_bonmin-bb faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) BatchS151208M 110.9250 123.5030 0.898 1.54347000E+06 1.54347000E+06 clay0204m 9.1500 10.9330 0.837 6.54500000E+03 6.54500000E+03 clay0304m 61.5350 94.4630 0.651 4.02624000E+04 4.02624000E+04 RSyn0810M02H 18.2470 20.7120 0.881 1.74139000E+03 1.74139000E+03 RSyn0810M03H 53.8100 106.6050 0.505 2.72245000E+03 2.72245000E+03 RSyn0810M 450.3500 788.8410 0.571 1.72145000E+03 1.72145000E+03 RSyn0840M03H 66.9090 113.8710 0.588 2.74265000E+03 2.74265000E+03 Syn20M02M 458.7050 819.5300 0.560 1.75213000E+03 1.75213000E+03 Syn40M04H 53.4430 60.9210 0.877 9.01752000E+02 9.01752000E+02 uflquad-15-60 12.4560 15.8290 0.787 1.06319000E+03 1.06319000E+03 uflquad-15-80 22.6090 37.1940 0.608 1.21799000E+03 1.21799000E+03 uflquad-25-40 23.3470 27.5040 0.849 8.28165000E+02 8.28165000E+02

### Solvers perform the same - Obj of BONMIN_bonmin-bb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) RSyn0810M03M 7323.3200 7569.2100 0.968 2.71225000E+03 2.36877000E+03 RSyn0810M04M 7294.0800 7495.6000 0.973 6.51167000E+03 5.43333000E+03 RSyn0820M02M 7354.5600 7627.2200 0.964 9.73262000E+02 6.69537000E+02 RSyn0820M03M 7306.8100 7451.4200 0.981 1.95237000E+03 1.43977000E+03 RSyn0820M04M 7273.8100 7396.6400 0.983 2.34774000E+03 1.56383000E+03 RSyn0840M03M 7282.9700 7609.5000 0.957 2.64392000E+03 2.24135000E+03 Syn40M03M 7331.7900 7548.5800 0.971 3.31144000E+02 2.94290000E+02 nd-13 7237.1500 7251.3700 0.998 6.49835000E+01 6.59079000E+01 nd-15 7227.0400 7230.4100 1.000 8.33353000E+01 8.69265000E+01 nd-16 7227.7000 7227.5800 1.000 9.90439000E+01 1.02098000E+02 fo7_ar2_1 7489.7600 7545.5400 0.993 2.48398000E+01 3.48713000E+01 fo7_ar25_1 7485.8900 7414.1500 1.010 2.55891000E+01 2.56784000E+01 fo7_ar4_1 7491.1600 7368.0300 1.017 2.07298000E+01 2.94755000E+01 fo7 7510.0700 7431.2200 1.011 2.07298000E+01 2.84523000E+01 fo8_ar3_1 7454.6600 7329.2200 1.017 3.96525000E+01 4.07912000E+01 fo8_ar4_1 7459.2200 7294.2400 1.023 2.84665000E+01 3.34653000E+01 fo8_ar5_1 7462.5000 7299.6800 1.022 2.44226000E+01 4.56578000E+01 fo8 7478.3600 7381.7800 1.013 2.68626000E+01 4.10696000E+01 fo9 7445.8100 7344.6400 1.014 3.04643000E+01 4.99615000E+01 netmod_dol1 7250.5400 7214.8800 1.005 -5.60008000E-01 -5.51398000E-01 no7_ar2_1 7503.1200 7471.5700 1.004 1.25589000E+02 1.51860000E+02 no7_ar25_1 7492.9500 7380.7300 1.015 1.15100000E+02 1.48786000E+02 no7_ar3_1 7500.7900 7374.7100 1.017 1.17224000E+02 1.34427000E+02 no7_ar4_1 7496.5500 7367.5900 1.018 1.00419000E+02 1.20701000E+02 no7_ar5_1 7486.4200 7343.6400 1.019 9.06227000E+01 1.18382000E+02 o7_2 7514.5300 7409.9700 1.014 1.16946000E+02 1.22353000E+02 o7_ar2_1 7480.0300 7458.1000 1.003 1.53249000E+02 1.77946000E+02 o7_ar25_1 7497.6300 7424.6000 1.010 1.51014000E+02 1.80922000E+02 o7_ar3_1 7488.1600 7369.9300 1.016 1.46096000E+02 1.63977000E+02 o7_ar4_1 7482.3300 7346.2800 1.019 1.36731000E+02 1.83000000E+02 o7_ar5_1 7488.1200 7350.2000 1.019 1.18767000E+02 1.29239000E+02 o7 7521.1600 7424.4200 1.013 1.31653000E+02 1.65396000E+02 o8_ar4_1 7450.2100 7302.2300 1.020 2.98512000E+02 3.04809000E+02

### Solvers perform the same - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) clay0305h 1662.5000 1521.9900 1.092 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 FLay06H 7394.3800 7451.7700 0.992 6.69328000E+01 6.69328000E+01 RSyn0810H 3.0840 2.9460 1.047 1.72145000E+03 1.72145000E+03 RSyn0810M04H 30.9780 30.6420 1.011 6.58194000E+03 6.58194000E+03 Syn10M04M 56.4720 58.3070 0.969 4.55706000E+03 4.55706000E+03 Syn40M02H 3.5190 3.8970 0.903 3.88773000E+02 3.88773000E+02 Syn40M03H 17.1110 16.2270 1.054 3.95149000E+02 3.95149000E+02 uflquad-20-40 17.2550 19.0030 0.908 8.60961000E+02 8.60961000E+02 m7_ar3_1 7483.3400 7479.4900 1.001 1.43585000E+02 1.43585000E+02 m7_ar5_1 7487.6700 7336.1600 1.021 1.06460000E+02 1.06460000E+02

### Solvers perform the same - Obj of SBB_sbb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) RSyn0840M04M 7267.4400 7575.0000 0.959 2.29365000E+03 2.30143000E+03 Syn40M04M 7295.7900 7557.2600 0.965 8.08852000E+02 8.31896000E+02 fo7_ar3_1 7504.2700 7413.0500 1.012 2.41955000E+01 2.31210000E+01 fo8_ar2_1 7456.9100 7498.4800 0.994 4.86817000E+01 4.84199000E+01 m7_ar4_1 7488.2500 7134.8100 1.050 1.48620000E+02 1.06757000E+02

### Solver SBB_sbb faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) clay0203h 6.8740 3.9370 1.746 4.15733000E+04 4.15733000E+04 clay0204h 52.7820 43.6850 1.208 6.54500000E+03 6.54500000E+03 clay0305m 250.6350 186.2620 1.346 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 FLay03M 0.8650 0.6440 1.343 4.89898000E+01 4.89898000E+01 FLay04H 38.9700 25.2120 1.546 5.44059000E+01 5.44059000E+01 FLay04M 12.8400 10.0850 1.273 5.44059000E+01 5.44059000E+01 FLay05M 617.4280 504.3070 1.224 6.44981000E+01 6.44981000E+01 RSyn0820H 5.5110 4.6940 1.174 1.15030000E+03 1.15030000E+03 RSyn0840H 3.7300 2.1890 1.704 3.25555000E+02 3.25555000E+02 RSyn0840M02H 23.3200 18.9290 1.232 7.34984000E+02 7.34984000E+02 SLay05M 2.5770 2.3020 1.119 2.26647000E+04 2.26647000E+04 Syn10M02H 0.3180 0.2850 1.116 2.31030000E+03 2.31030000E+03 Syn10M02M 4.5530 3.3410 1.363 2.31030000E+03 2.31030000E+03 Syn10M03H 0.7190 0.4480 1.605 3.35468000E+03 3.35468000E+03 Syn10M03M 19.6690 13.2780 1.481 3.35468000E+03 3.35468000E+03 Syn10M04H 1.0620 0.5910 1.797 4.55706000E+03 4.55706000E+03 Syn20M 4.8100 3.3160 1.451 9.24263000E+02 9.24263000E+02 Syn40H 1.5330 0.8680 1.766 6.77134000E+01 6.77134000E+01 uflquad-25-25 10.5160 5.7650 1.824 6.73697000E+02 6.73697000E+02 m7_ar2_1 2569.7700 2283.0700 1.126 1.90235000E+02 1.90235000E+02 tls2 5.9730 4.2320 1.411 5.30000000E+00 5.30000000E+00

### Solver SBB_sbb much faster - Obj same for both solvers:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) clay0203m 4.2890 1.8450 2.325 4.15733000E+04 4.15733000E+04 clay0205h 1775.5400 688.0400 2.581 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 clay0205m 708.5470 231.4940 3.061 8.09250000E+03 8.09250000E+03 clay0303h 18.6050 6.9610 2.673 2.66691000E+04 2.66691000E+04 FLay03H 2.2550 1.0190 2.213 4.89898000E+01 4.89898000E+01 SLay06M 27.4070 1.1210 24.449 3.27570000E+04 3.27570000E+04 SLay07M 66.4610 13.6680 4.863 6.47488000E+04 6.47488000E+04 SLay08M 67.5310 4.8160 14.022 8.49602000E+04 8.49602000E+04 Syn10H 0.3520 0.1120 3.143 1.26735000E+03 1.26735000E+03 Syn10M 0.6270 0.2170 2.889 1.26735000E+03 1.26735000E+03 Syn20H 0.4150 0.2040 2.034 9.24263000E+02 9.24263000E+02 Syn20M02H 2.2460 0.9990 2.248 1.75213000E+03 1.75213000E+03 Syn20M03H 4.2170 1.1720 3.598 2.64695000E+03 2.64695000E+03 Syn20M04H 7.6110 1.7440 4.364 3.53274000E+03 3.53274000E+03 uflquad-25-30 12.5240 4.6730 2.680 6.69840000E+02 6.69840000E+02 nd-10 1189.2800 472.2360 2.518 5.24611000E+01 5.24611000E+01 m3 1.3530 0.4660 2.903 3.78000000E+01 3.78000000E+01

### Solver SBB_sbb much faster - Obj of SBB_sbb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) nd-12 7239.3100 2721.8200 2.660 5.83036000E+01 5.66696000E+01

### Solver SBB_sbb infinitely faster - Obj of SBB_sbb better:

 Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Time (SBB_sbb) Ratio (BONMIN_bonmin-bb / SBB_sbb) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-bb) Obj (SBB_sbb) Syn20M03M fail 7954.4200 -- 2.62995000E+03 2.64695000E+03 Syn20M04M fail 7781.6900 -- 1.39395000E+03 3.50074000E+03 fo8_ar25_1 fail 7372.1000 -- 1.00000000E+20 4.16304000E+01 fo9_ar5_1 fail 7263.1100 -- 1.00000000E+20 4.16603000E+01 tls5 fail 10552.2000 -- 1.00000000E+20 1.56000000E+01 tls6 fail 9148.5200 -- 1.00000000E+20 2.14000000E+01