ALPHAECP(alphaecp-minlpconvex2) | BONMIN(bonmin-bb) | BONMIN(bonmin-ecp) | BONMIN(bonmin-hyb) | BONMIN(bonmin-oa) | BONMIN(bonmin-oa-cpx) | BONMIN(bonmin-qg) | DICOPT(dicopt-minlpconvex) | KNITRO(knitro) | SBB(sbb) | MYSCIP(assumeconvex) | MYSCIP(minlp) | --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- Name |F| Nodes | Time |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ |F| Nodes | Time | NodQ | TimQ | bounds check --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- * BatchS101006M 1 46.3 436 18.3 436.00 0.40 490 18.9 490.00 0.41 513 25.9 513.00 0.56 1 443.6 1.00 9.58 1 5.8 1.00 0.13 308 8.3 308.00 0.18 1 7.7 1.00 0.17 3067 143.3 Large 3.10 5566 81.6 Large 1.76 25885 21.7 Large 0.47 25885 22.0 Large 0.48 ok BatchS121208M 1 887.7 570 37.4 570.00 0.04 272 40.0 272.00 0.05 435 46.5 435.00 0.05 1 655.5 1.00 0.74 1 5.6 1.00 0.01 498 38.6 498.00 0.04 1 7.2 1.00 0.01 4283 5227.5 Large 5.89 4948 99.4 Large 0.11 22211 31.0 Large 0.03 22211 31.8 Large 0.04 inconsistent * BatchS151208M 1 1088.1 1790 110.9 Large 0.10 466 77.1 466.00 0.07 432 60.0 432.00 0.06 1 4421.2 1.00 4.06 1 9.5 1.00 0.01 714 64.7 714.00 0.06 1 13.1 1.00 0.01 # 3721 > 7200.3 Large 6.62 5255 123.5 Large 0.11 268341 225.7 Large 0.21 268341 228.8 Large 0.21 ok * BatchS201210M 1 127.1 1560 145.0 Large 1.14 692 159.9 692.00 1.26 532 79.8 532.00 0.63 # 1 > 7325.7 1.00 57.64 1 18.9 1.00 0.15 502 86.6 502.00 0.68 1 12.8 1.00 0.10 # 2499 > 7200.3 Large 56.65 17569 517.8 Large 4.07 10112 54.3 Large 0.43 10112 52.6 Large 0.41 ok clay0203h 1 3.0 203 6.9 203.00 2.30 372 2.6 372.00 0.87 344 4.2 344.00 1.40 1 3.2 1.00 1.07 1 1.2 1.00 0.40 354 2.3 354.00 0.77 1 3.3 1.00 1.10 131 1.9 131.00 0.63 390 3.9 390.00 1.30 88 0.8 88.00 0.27 267 2.1 267.00 0.70 inconsistent * clay0203m 1 2.0 251 4.3 251.00 2.15 224 0.9 224.00 0.45 214 2.7 214.00 1.35 1 2.2 1.00 1.10 1 0.8 1.00 0.40 188 0.8 188.00 0.40 1 3.4 1.00 1.70 205 1.3 205.00 0.65 297 1.8 297.00 0.90 44 0.5 44.00 0.25 44 0.5 44.00 0.25 ok * clay0204h 1 11.3 1622 52.8 Large 4.67 193 5.2 193.00 0.46 292 11.4 292.00 1.01 1 7.7 1.00 0.68 1 1.1 1.00 0.10 165 2.0 165.00 0.18 1 0.5 1.00 0.04 1507 9.8 Large 0.87 3687 43.7 Large 3.87 1253 2.6 Large 0.23 1365 6.2 Large 0.55 ok * clay0204m 1 6.1 1208 9.2 Large 1.51 226 1.3 226.00 0.21 209 4.4 209.00 0.72 1 3.3 1.00 0.54 1 0.8 1.00 0.13 258 1.6 258.00 0.26 1 0.5 1.00 0.08 2629 10.4 Large 1.70 2649 10.9 Large 1.79 613 1.2 613.00 0.20 613 1.2 613.00 0.20 ok clay0205h 1 38.4 23926 1775.5 Large 46.24 1139 110.2 Large 2.87 1059 110.9 Large 2.89 1 1044.7 1.00 27.21 1 13.7 1.00 0.36 1201 26.2 Large 0.68 1 38.3 1.00 1.00 19681 268.1 Large 6.98 61328 688.0 Large 17.92 11339 15.4 Large 0.40 2118 ! 7.7 Large 0.20 fail * clay0205m 1 22.7 21352 708.5 Large 31.21 870 7.5 870.00 0.33 810 16.7 810.00 0.74 1 122.5 1.00 5.40 1 6.9 1.00 0.30 1156 6.9 Large 0.30 1 102.2 1.00 4.50 18785 114.6 Large 5.05 49844 231.5 Large 10.20 7623 4.8 Large 0.21 7623 4.3 Large 0.19 ok clay0303h 1 4.0 335 18.6 335.00 4.65 959 7.6 959.00 1.90 1036 9.7 Large 2.43 1 6.0 1.00 1.50 1 1.7 1.00 0.43 894 5.4 894.00 1.35 1 57.3 1.00 14.33 291 5.8 291.00 1.45 620 7.0 620.00 1.75 160 0.9 160.00 0.23 1209 6.0 Large 1.50 inconsistent clay0303m 1 3.0 349 5.6 349.00 1.87 614 2.4 614.00 0.80 508 3.9 508.00 1.30 1 5.6 1.00 1.87 1 1.3 1.00 0.43 468 2.5 468.00 0.83 1 35.6 1.00 11.87 337 2.2 337.00 0.73 266 ! 1.7 266.00 0.57 148 0.5 148.00 0.17 148 0.5 148.00 0.17 fail clay0304h 1 16.6 2684 208.0 Large 12.53 38740 361.6 Large 21.78 35512 493.2 Large 29.71 1 263.1 1.00 15.85 1 7.6 1.00 0.46 42141 246.1 Large 14.83 1 > 7236.7 1.00 435.95 1883 37.2 Large 2.24 30544 510.2 Large 30.73 1439 2.9 Large 0.17 # 143 ! 1.8 143.00 0.11 fail * clay0304m 1 7.3 2867 61.5 Large 8.42 14847 48.5 Large 6.64 14694 56.5 Large 7.74 1 304.5 1.00 41.71 1 3.0 1.00 0.41 15102 50.0 Large 6.85 1 > 7231.5 1.00 990.62 2289 21.7 Large 2.97 17061 94.5 Large 12.95 1033 1.7 Large 0.23 1033 1.2 Large 0.16 ok * clay0305h 1 43.2 15414 1662.5 Large 38.48 1792 111.4 Large 2.58 1756 171.7 Large 3.97 1 3838.4 1.00 88.85 1 19.0 1.00 0.44 1692 45.9 Large 1.06 1 243.6 1.00 5.64 12642 200.5 Large 4.64 103099 1522.0 Large 35.23 10525 17.7 Large 0.41 17125 82.5 Large 1.91 ok * clay0305m 1 24.5 16867 250.6 Large 10.23 1344 9.3 Large 0.38 1272 11.7 Large 0.48 1 258.5 1.00 10.55 1 10.2 1.00 0.42 1577 10.3 Large 0.42 1 1218.0 1.00 49.71 16501 90.1 Large 3.68 34359 186.3 Large 7.60 13202 7.3 Large 0.30 13202 8.8 Large 0.36 ok * FLay03H 1 8.6 106 2.3 106.00 0.27 70 1.0 70.00 0.12 52 2.0 52.00 0.23 1 2.0 1.00 0.23 1 0.9 1.00 0.10 72 0.5 72.00 0.06 1 1.8 1.00 0.21 109 0.5 109.00 0.06 106 1.0 106.00 0.12 113 0.9 113.00 0.10 113 1.0 113.00 0.12 ok * FLay03M 1 3.3 102 0.9 102.00 0.27 60 0.5 60.00 0.15 58 1.1 58.00 0.33 1 0.7 1.00 0.21 1 0.5 1.00 0.15 66 0.5 66.00 0.15 1 0.7 1.00 0.21 111 0.5 111.00 0.15 106 0.6 106.00 0.18 107 0.5 107.00 0.15 107 0.5 107.00 0.15 ok * FLay04H 1 147.3 2536 39.0 Large 0.26 860 8.0 860.00 0.05 852 18.5 852.00 0.13 1 188.2 1.00 1.28 1 24.5 1.00 0.17 988 6.1 988.00 0.04 1 291.1 1.00 1.98 2655 12.1 Large 0.08 2721 25.2 Large 0.17 2329 4.5 Large 0.03 2329 4.5 Large 0.03 ok * FLay04M 1 118.6 2644 12.8 Large 0.11 842 2.3 842.00 0.02 822 12.1 822.00 0.10 1 21.4 1.00 0.18 1 6.2 1.00 0.05 908 2.0 908.00 0.02 1 78.1 1.00 0.66 2875 4.3 Large 0.04 2472 10.1 Large 0.09 2342 2.2 Large 0.02 2342 2.3 Large 0.02 ok FLay05H 1 > 7202.2 89570 3506.5 Large 0.49 24104 300.3 Large 0.04 24338 315.7 Large 0.04 # 1 > 7414.4 1.00 1.03 1 5798.9 1.00 0.81 23338 331.3 Large 0.05 1 > 7204.7 1.00 1.00 98087 647.4 Large 0.09 154166 ! 2611.9 Large 0.36 111898 232.3 Large 0.03 111898 233.3 Large 0.03 fail * FLay05M 1 > 7202.2 85140 617.4 Large 0.09 21918 69.7 Large 0.01 22092 75.8 Large 0.01 # 1 > 7392.0 1.00 1.03 1 3181.8 1.00 0.44 23856 71.8 Large 0.01 1 > 7205.9 1.00 1.00 93507 169.6 Large 0.02 102527 504.3 Large 0.07 87409 58.3 Large 0.01 87409 59.8 Large 0.01 ok * FLay06H 1 > 7202.2 134329 > 7394.4 Large 1.03 254690 > 7281.1 Large 1.01 249295 > 7283.6 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7445.0 1.00 1.03 # 1 > 7228.6 1.00 1.00 209436 > 7363.5 Large 1.02 1 > 7201.8 1.00 1.00 287384 > 7200.7 Large 1.00 284811 > 7451.8 Large 1.03 2950626 > 7325.4 Large 1.02 2936065 > 7325.1 Large 1.02 ok FLay06M 1 > 7202.4 1214016 > 7661.8 Large 1.06 604219 > 7284.6 Large 1.01 599736 > 7285.7 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7509.8 1.00 1.04 # 1 > 7262.0 1.00 1.01 682717 > 7285.2 Large 1.01 1 > 7203.4 1.00 1.00 496930 > 7200.5 Large 1.00 1314928 !11788.9 Large 1.64 4208366 2587.4 Large 0.36 4208366 2588.4 Large 0.36 fail * RSyn0810H 1 0.7 34 3.1 34.00 4.43 6 0.5 6.00 0.71 12 1.1 12.00 1.57 1 0.5 1.00 0.71 1 0.5 1.00 0.71 39 0.8 39.00 1.14 1 0.5 1.00 0.71 111 3.3 111.00 4.71 304 2.9 304.00 4.14 1 0.5 1.00 0.71 89 1.4 89.00 2.00 ok * RSyn0810M02H 1 6.4 44 18.2 44.00 2.84 20 1.9 20.00 0.30 56 4.1 56.00 0.64 1 3.2 1.00 0.50 1 1.0 1.00 0.16 82 2.7 82.00 0.42 1 1.4 1.00 0.22 183 1227.9 183.00 191.86 498 20.7 498.00 3.23 1 1.4 1.00 0.22 24463 84.1 Large 13.14 ok * RSyn0810M02M 1 29.6 85489 > 7375.7 Large 249.18 7661 192.1 Large 6.49 2716 83.9 Large 2.83 1 1576.4 1.00 53.26 1 5.9 1.00 0.20 348919 > 7291.0 Large 246.32 1 4.3 1.00 0.15 20067 > 7200.2 Large 243.25 574917 > 8680.0 Large 293.24 35535 38.8 Large 1.31 35535 38.3 Large 1.29 ok RSyn0810M03H 1 11.5 150 53.8 150.00 4.68 44 5.9 44.00 0.51 142 10.8 142.00 0.94 1 16.2 1.00 1.41 1 1.7 1.00 0.15 200 9.1 200.00 0.79 1 2.4 1.00 0.21 117 ! 5769.2 117.00 501.67 1295 106.6 Large 9.27 1 2.1 1.00 0.18 2014505 > 7332.5 Large 637.61 fail * RSyn0810M03M 1 35.6 55115 > 7323.3 Large 205.71 9411 516.2 Large 14.50 16211 1045.4 Large 29.37 1 > 7502.7 1.00 210.75 1 12.5 1.00 0.35 223851 > 7452.0 Large 209.33 1 6.3 1.00 0.18 2884 > 7200.2 Large 202.25 272252 > 7569.2 Large 212.62 115825 95.2 Large 2.67 115825 96.1 Large 2.70 ok RSyn0810M04H 1 16.9 8 31.0 8.00 1.83 34 5.6 34.00 0.33 52 7.7 52.00 0.46 1 5.9 1.00 0.35 1 1.6 1.00 0.09 68 4.6 68.00 0.27 1 ! 3.6 1.00 0.21 1 ! 7.4 1.00 0.44 256 30.6 256.00 1.81 1 2.0 1.00 0.12 1280551 1795.2 Large 106.22 fail RSyn0810M04M 1 32.5 34686 > 7294.1 Large 224.43 7144 628.9 Large 19.35 16237 1295.9 Large 39.87 1 > 7287.3 1.00 224.22 1 8.0 1.00 0.25 150922 > 7439.8 Large 228.92 1 ! 7.6 1.00 0.23 7023 > 7200.1 Large 221.54 192860 > 7495.6 Large 230.63 849581 491.3 Large 15.12 849581 491.8 Large 15.13 fail * RSyn0810M 1 1.1 25945 450.4 Large 409.45 172 1.3 172.00 1.18 147 1.5 147.00 1.36 1 5.5 1.00 5.00 1 0.6 1.00 0.55 1939 8.7 Large 7.91 1 0.5 1.00 0.45 42691 493.9 Large 449.00 165574 788.8 Large 717.09 1333 1.7 Large 1.55 1333 1.7 Large 1.55 ok RSyn0820H 1 1.3 73 5.5 73.00 4.23 30 1.2 30.00 0.92 63 2.5 63.00 1.92 1 2.8 1.00 2.15 1 0.7 1.00 0.54 81 1.2 81.00 0.92 1 0.5 1.00 0.38 125 15.7 125.00 12.08 347 4.7 347.00 3.62 1 0.5 1.00 0.38 44883 51.8 Large 39.85 inconsistent RSyn0820M02H 1 4.4 40 22.9 40.00 5.20 1 ! 0.8 1.00 0.18 56 4.1 56.00 0.93 1 4.8 1.00 1.09 1 1.5 1.00 0.34 92 3.4 92.00 0.77 1 1.7 1.00 0.39 111 ! 930.6 111.00 211.50 886 58.6 886.00 13.32 1 1.5 1.00 0.34 1445031 3003.9 Large 682.70 fail * RSyn0820M02M 1 28.0 72061 > 7354.6 Large 262.66 107047 2545.0 Large 90.89 16048 544.9 Large 19.46 1 > 7628.3 1.00 272.44 1 6.6 1.00 0.24 291906 > 7311.1 Large 261.11 1 7.8 1.00 0.28 49258 > 7200.2 Large 257.15 298212 > 7627.2 Large 272.40 158566 189.2 Large 6.76 158566 188.9 Large 6.75 ok RSyn0820M03H 1 7.7 194 75.2 194.00 9.77 1 ! 1.2 1.00 0.16 126 12.3 126.00 1.60 1 40.6 1.00 5.27 1 1.4 1.00 0.18 272 16.6 272.00 2.16 1 ! 3.4 1.00 0.44 1 ! 18.1 1.00 2.35 3987 514.6 Large 66.83 1 3.6 1.00 0.47 809177 > 7289.1 Large 946.64 fail * RSyn0820M03M 1 23.1 42651 > 7306.8 Large 316.31 111646 > 7543.7 Large 326.57 118547 > 7324.1 Large 317.06 1 > 7489.7 1.00 324.23 1 18.7 1.00 0.81 192670 > 7409.6 Large 320.76 1 28.7 1.00 1.24 492 > 7200.1 492.00 311.69 183473 > 7451.4 Large 322.57 2396477 4043.6 Large 175.05 2396477 4048.0 Large 175.24 ok RSyn0820M04H 1 11.6 89 91.4 89.00 7.88 1 ! 2.2 1.00 0.19 108 12.4 108.00 1.07 1 23.8 1.00 2.05 1 2.8 1.00 0.24 158 10.8 158.00 0.93 1 5.4 1.00 0.47 95 > 7200.2 95.00 620.71 2115 427.1 Large 36.82 1 2.8 1.00 0.24 596459 > 7287.6 Large 628.24 fail * RSyn0820M04M 1 26.0 34893 > 7273.8 Large 279.76 67480 > 7357.6 Large 282.98 95765 > 7561.5 Large 290.83 1 > 7390.2 1.00 284.24 1 53.8 1.00 2.07 137899 > 7567.4 Large 291.05 1 215.3 1.00 8.28 160 > 7200.2 160.00 276.93 120626 > 7396.6 Large 284.48 10360724 > 7431.9 Large 285.84 10346133 > 7435.3 Large 285.97 ok * RSyn0820M 1 2.3 154585 3363.6 Large Large 297 3.1 297.00 1.35 999 8.0 999.00 3.48 1 26.1 1.00 11.35 1 0.7 1.00 0.30 20435 107.1 Large 46.57 1 0.5 1.00 0.22 150145 2660.9 Large Large 965722 7190.6 Large Large 124911 31.6 Large 13.74 124911 32.0 Large 13.91 ok RSyn0840H 1 2.4 14 3.7 14.00 1.54 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.21 8 1.4 8.00 0.58 1 0.9 1.00 0.37 1 0.6 1.00 0.25 22 1.0 22.00 0.42 1 0.5 1.00 0.21 27 2.2 27.00 0.92 102 2.2 102.00 0.92 1 0.8 1.00 0.33 46597 132.2 Large 55.08 fail RSyn0840M02H 1 13.9 36 23.3 36.00 1.68 16 1.9 16.00 0.14 12 3.4 12.00 0.24 1 2.6 1.00 0.19 1 1.5 1.00 0.11 36 2.4 36.00 0.17 1 ! 1.8 1.00 0.13 1 ! 2.3 1.00 0.17 279 18.9 279.00 1.36 1 1.3 1.00 0.09 1117752 > 7315.3 Large 526.28 fail RSyn0840M02M 1 29.1 52034 > 7321.6 Large 251.60 160658 > 7649.8 Large 262.88 179476 > 7264.9 Large 249.65 1 4692.2 1.00 161.24 1 3.4 1.00 0.12 228689 > 7334.4 Large 252.04 1 ! 3.0 1.00 0.10 31248 > 7200.2 Large 247.43 443016 > 8159.1 Large 280.38 2232081 984.7 Large 33.84 2232081 985.6 Large 33.87 fail RSyn0840M03H 1 30.4 109 66.9 109.00 2.20 49 6.8 49.00 0.22 118 ! 11.3 118.00 0.37 1 16.8 1.00 0.55 1 1.8 1.00 0.06 128 11.2 128.00 0.37 1 ! 3.9 1.00 0.13 1 ! 77.6 1.00 2.55 623 113.9 623.00 3.75 1 3.0 1.00 0.10 555757 > 7262.1 Large 238.88 fail * RSyn0840M03M 1 50.2 31087 > 7283.0 Large 145.08 112513 > 7602.9 Large 151.45 107680 > 7250.9 Large 144.44 1 > 7529.1 1.00 149.98 1 7.1 1.00 0.14 160255 > 7352.1 Large 146.46 1 3.4 1.00 0.07 18530 > 7200.2 Large 143.43 215768 > 7609.5 Large 151.58 11666122 > 7459.9 Large 148.60 11665653 > 7459.2 Large 148.59 ok RSyn0840M04H 1 77.2 423 240.5 423.00 3.12 120 17.8 120.00 0.23 113 21.5 113.00 0.28 1 20.5 1.00 0.27 1 2.3 1.00 0.03 206 20.6 206.00 0.27 1 6.8 1.00 0.09 22 > 7200.2 22.00 93.27 3023 740.9 Large 9.60 1 ! 3.6 1.00 0.05 452952 > 7260.5 Large 94.05 fail RSyn0840M04M 1 543.8 14707 > 7267.4 Large 13.36 67718 > 7513.6 Large 13.82 69547 > 7526.7 Large 13.84 1 > 7386.2 1.00 13.58 1 25.3 1.00 0.05 105022 > 7418.4 Large 13.64 1 ! 17.4 1.00 0.03 11418 > 7200.2 Large 13.24 169679 > 7575.0 Large 13.93 3339478 > 7314.8 Large 13.45 3327558 > 7314.8 Large 13.45 fail RSyn0840M 1 2.6 212174 > 7448.1 Large Large 146 2.9 146.00 1.12 514 16.8 514.00 6.46 1 71.2 1.00 27.38 1 0.9 1.00 0.35 772260 > 7355.3 Large Large 1 0.5 1.00 0.19 247291 ! 7200.4 Large Large 989573 >11688.7 Large Large 760 1.7 760.00 0.65 760 2.1 760.00 0.81 fail * SLay05H 1 118.8 35 4.5 35.00 0.04 152 2.5 152.00 0.02 201 8.4 201.00 0.07 1 17.3 1.00 0.15 1 0.9 1.00 0.01 98 0.9 98.00 0.01 1 3.0 1.00 0.03 555 3.5 555.00 0.03 2786 22.2 Large 0.19 1041 4.2 Large 0.04 1041 4.7 Large 0.04 ok * SLay05M 1 77.8 47 2.6 47.00 0.03 62 0.5 62.00 0.01 72 1.2 72.00 0.02 1 2.3 1.00 0.03 1 0.5 1.00 0.01 116 0.5 116.00 0.01 1 0.7 1.00 0.01 521 1.5 521.00 0.02 502 2.3 502.00 0.03 31 0.8 31.00 0.01 31 1.0 31.00 0.01 ok * SLay06H 1 244.1 96 54.5 96.00 0.22 401 11.5 401.00 0.05 462 25.8 462.00 0.11 1 1072.0 1.00 4.39 1 3.4 1.00 0.01 310 3.1 310.00 0.01 1 13.6 1.00 0.06 1185 10.0 Large 0.04 36979 387.9 Large 1.59 1148 6.0 Large 0.02 1148 6.0 Large 0.02 ok * SLay06M 1 157.3 100 27.4 100.00 0.17 166 0.9 166.00 0.01 188 3.0 188.00 0.02 1 5.9 1.00 0.04 1 0.7 1.00 0.00 248 1.0 248.00 0.01 1 1.6 1.00 0.01 955 3.7 955.00 0.02 168 1.1 168.00 0.01 793 3.4 793.00 0.02 793 3.5 793.00 0.02 ok SLay07H 1 746.2 233 68.0 233.00 0.09 1101 60.7 Large 0.08 1801 89.8 Large 0.12 # 1 > 7358.1 1.00 9.86 1 10.1 1.00 0.01 655 8.7 655.00 0.01 1 11.9 1.00 0.02 2282 27.9 Large 0.04 512202 > 7383.2 Large 9.89 15268 111.9 Large 0.15 15268 112.4 Large 0.15 inconsistent * SLay07M 1 431.6 235 66.5 235.00 0.15 314 1.7 314.00 0.00 702 5.1 702.00 0.01 1 75.3 1.00 0.17 1 1.2 1.00 0.00 610 2.9 610.00 0.01 1 67.7 1.00 0.16 2151 11.7 Large 0.03 2658 13.7 Large 0.03 674 5.1 674.00 0.01 674 4.9 674.00 0.01 ok * SLay08H 1 1579.8 270 69.3 270.00 0.04 2801 174.8 Large 0.11 3401 231.4 Large 0.15 # 1 > 7392.2 1.00 4.68 1 35.0 1.00 0.02 1501 35.5 Large 0.02 1 3235.4 1.00 2.05 2690 43.2 Large 0.03 366221 > 7413.2 Large 4.69 2678 30.9 Large 0.02 2678 31.2 Large 0.02 ok * SLay08M 1 821.5 265 67.5 265.00 0.08 761 5.7 761.00 0.01 602 14.1 602.00 0.02 1 4354.5 1.00 5.30 1 4.0 1.00 0.00 1488 8.2 Large 0.01 1 62.3 1.00 0.08 3687 26.8 Large 0.03 803 4.8 803.00 0.01 1884 21.8 Large 0.03 1884 21.9 Large 0.03 ok * SLay09H 1 > 7202.2 416 79.3 416.00 0.01 55877 > 7248.7 Large 1.01 35301 3633.1 Large 0.50 # 1 > 7457.7 1.00 1.04 1 164.5 1.00 0.02 39701 1821.4 Large 0.25 1 > 7218.2 1.00 1.00 4749 112.6 Large 0.02 249035 > 7412.8 Large 1.03 70840 986.2 Large 0.14 70840 987.7 Large 0.14 ok * SLay09M 1 2096.7 393 69.9 393.00 0.03 2246 28.1 Large 0.01 3251 42.8 Large 0.02 # 1 > 7497.9 1.00 3.58 1 23.3 1.00 0.01 4232 44.3 Large 0.02 1 287.2 1.00 0.14 7253 55.3 Large 0.03 48186 330.2 Large 0.16 9146 74.2 Large 0.04 9146 74.6 Large 0.04 ok * SLay10H 1 > 7202.1 7314 336.6 Large 0.05 43723 > 7251.0 Large 1.01 48349 > 7222.4 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7430.0 1.00 1.03 # 1 > 7226.3 1.00 1.00 143376 > 7706.1 Large 1.07 1 > 7209.4 1.00 1.00 25804 741.3 Large 0.10 178550 > 7356.2 Large 1.02 114230 1748.7 Large 0.24 114230 1748.1 Large 0.24 ok SLay10M 1 > 7202.3 6692 145.0 Large 0.02 21094 396.9 Large 0.06 26014 484.0 Large 0.07 # 1 > 7590.3 1.00 1.05 1 1865.2 1.00 0.26 32629 852.1 Large 0.12 1 > 7231.9 1.00 1.00 26823 309.8 Large 0.04 57932 538.4 Large 0.07 14739 152.2 Large 0.02 14739 152.1 Large 0.02 inconsistent * Syn10H 1 0.5 2 0.5 2.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 1 0.6 1.00 1.20 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 2 0.5 2.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 3 0.5 3.00 1.00 2 0.5 2.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 25 1.0 25.00 2.00 ok Syn10M02H 1 1.0 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 1 0.9 1.00 0.90 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 4 0.5 4.00 0.50 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 7 0.5 7.00 0.50 7 0.5 7.00 0.50 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 1881 1.9 Large 1.90 inconsistent Syn10M02M 1 0.8 246 4.6 246.00 5.75 20 0.5 20.00 0.62 12 0.6 12.00 0.75 1 0.5 1.00 0.62 1 0.5 1.00 0.62 144 0.8 144.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 0.62 1325 7.2 Large 9.00 551 3.3 551.00 4.12 81 1.0 81.00 1.25 81 0.9 81.00 1.12 inconsistent * Syn10M03H 1 1.2 1 0.7 1.00 0.58 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 1 1.0 1.00 0.83 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 4 0.5 4.00 0.42 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 7 0.5 7.00 0.42 9 0.5 9.00 0.42 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 24201 9.3 Large 7.75 ok Syn10M03M 1 1.1 878 19.7 878.00 17.91 24 1.0 24.00 0.91 16 0.6 16.00 0.55 1 1.2 1.00 1.09 1 0.5 1.00 0.45 366 2.9 366.00 2.64 1 0.5 1.00 0.45 2779 49.7 Large 45.18 1828 13.3 Large 12.09 2431 1.8 Large 1.64 2431 1.6 Large 1.45 inconsistent * Syn10M04H 1 2.1 1 1.1 1.00 0.52 1 0.5 1.00 0.24 1 1.1 1.00 0.52 1 0.5 1.00 0.24 1 0.5 1.00 0.24 6 0.5 6.00 0.24 1 0.5 1.00 0.24 7 0.7 7.00 0.33 11 0.6 11.00 0.29 1 0.5 1.00 0.24 37291 18.4 Large 8.76 ok * Syn10M04M 1 1.9 1932 56.5 Large 29.74 26 1.0 26.00 0.53 20 1.1 20.00 0.58 1 1.1 1.00 0.58 1 0.5 1.00 0.26 830 7.0 830.00 3.68 1 0.5 1.00 0.26 8661 524.7 Large 276.16 5847 58.3 Large 30.68 5801 2.7 Large 1.42 5801 2.6 Large 1.37 ok Syn10M 1 0.5 30 0.6 30.00 1.20 1 ! 0.5 1.00 1.00 1 ! 0.5 1.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 22 0.5 22.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 63 0.5 63.00 1.00 32 0.5 32.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 fail * Syn20H 1 0.9 1 0.5 1.00 0.56 4 0.5 4.00 0.56 1 0.9 1.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 0.56 1 0.5 1.00 0.56 2 0.5 2.00 0.56 1 0.5 1.00 0.56 5 0.5 5.00 0.56 4 0.5 4.00 0.56 1 0.5 1.00 0.56 689 1.7 689.00 1.89 ok Syn20M02H 1 1.2 6 2.2 6.00 1.83 1 0.6 1.00 0.50 1 1.2 1.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 10 0.6 10.00 0.50 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.42 13 1.2 13.00 1.00 14 1.0 14.00 0.83 1 0.5 1.00 0.42 73851 68.2 Large 56.83 fail * Syn20M02M 1 1.0 16924 458.7 Large 458.70 70 1.3 70.00 1.30 62 1.3 62.00 1.30 1 1.8 1.00 1.80 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 5716 51.2 Large 51.20 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 131215 3179.7 Large Large 81252 819.5 Large 819.50 3050 2.1 Large 2.10 3050 2.1 Large 2.10 ok Syn20M03H 1 2.2 12 4.2 12.00 1.91 1 0.6 1.00 0.27 1 2.1 1.00 0.95 1 0.5 1.00 0.23 1 0.5 1.00 0.23 18 1.1 18.00 0.50 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.23 21 1.7 21.00 0.77 18 1.2 18.00 0.55 1 0.5 1.00 0.23 1467951 986.1 Large 448.23 fail Syn20M03M 1 1.5 96821 ! 4347.0 Large Large 60 2.1 60.00 1.40 86 2.9 86.00 1.93 1 11.1 1.00 7.40 1 0.5 1.00 0.33 52184 633.1 Large 422.07 1 0.5 1.00 0.33 29759 > 7200.2 Large Large 739324 > 7954.4 Large Large 20368 8.4 Large 5.60 20368 8.0 Large 5.33 fail Syn20M04H 1 3.1 16 7.6 16.00 2.45 1 0.8 1.00 0.26 1 3.0 1.00 0.97 1 0.7 1.00 0.23 1 0.6 1.00 0.19 22 1.6 22.00 0.52 1 ! 0.6 1.00 0.19 25 2.9 25.00 0.94 20 1.7 20.00 0.55 1 0.9 1.00 0.29 1705031 3311.8 Large Large fail Syn20M04M 1 2.5 2 ! 12.9 2.00 5.16 222 8.1 222.00 3.24 320 9.1 320.00 3.64 1 8.9 1.00 3.56 1 0.5 1.00 0.20 255592 4371.9 Large Large 1 0.5 1.00 0.20 45360 > 7200.2 Large Large 429123 > 7781.7 Large Large 33606 17.6 Large 7.04 33606 18.0 Large 7.20 fail Syn20M 1 1.1 596 4.8 596.00 4.36 22 0.5 22.00 0.45 16 0.5 16.00 0.45 1 0.5 1.00 0.45 1 0.5 1.00 0.45 348 1.0 348.00 0.91 1 0.5 1.00 0.45 763 2.4 763.00 2.18 684 3.3 684.00 3.00 883 1.2 883.00 1.09 883 1.1 883.00 1.00 inconsistent Syn40H 1 2.3 10 1.5 10.00 0.65 10 0.7 10.00 0.30 18 1.2 18.00 0.52 1 0.9 1.00 0.39 1 0.7 1.00 0.30 24 0.7 24.00 0.30 1 0.6 1.00 0.26 13 0.6 13.00 0.26 11 0.9 11.00 0.39 1 0.5 1.00 0.22 48675 144.3 Large 62.74 inconsistent Syn40M02H 1 4.9 10 3.5 10.00 0.71 14 1.4 14.00 0.29 14 1.6 14.00 0.33 1 1.4 1.00 0.29 1 0.7 1.00 0.14 16 0.9 16.00 0.18 1 0.9 1.00 0.18 23 2.3 23.00 0.47 32 3.9 32.00 0.80 1 1.0 1.00 0.20 1968814 > 7350.7 Large Large inconsistent * Syn40M02M 1 4.4 157430 > 7384.0 Large Large 314 8.2 314.00 1.86 342 9.8 342.00 2.23 1 256.0 1.00 58.18 1 0.6 1.00 0.14 404489 > 7309.8 Large Large 1 0.5 1.00 0.11 192801 > 7200.4 Large Large 614164 > 8804.5 Large Large 243610 94.3 Large 21.43 243610 93.1 Large 21.16 ok Syn40M03H 1 10.9 42 17.1 42.00 1.57 95 5.8 95.00 0.53 113 15.5 113.00 1.42 1 5.6 1.00 0.51 1 1.3 1.00 0.12 110 5.1 110.00 0.47 1 1.4 1.00 0.13 79 65.4 79.00 6.00 123 16.2 123.00 1.49 626 2.4 626.00 0.22 753295 > 7276.8 Large 667.60 inconsistent Syn40M03M 1 10.4 75312 > 7331.8 Large 704.98 1612 76.4 Large 7.35 74807 3068.1 Large 295.01 1 > 7316.0 1.00 703.46 1 1.1 1.00 0.11 278582 > 7315.2 Large 703.38 1 ! 0.8 1.00 0.08 87793 > 7200.3 Large 692.34 249243 > 7548.6 Large 725.83 3992375 1733.0 Large 166.63 3992375 1733.1 Large 166.64 fail Syn40M04H 1 21.2 110 53.4 110.00 2.52 62 5.7 62.00 0.27 70 15.3 70.00 0.72 1 17.0 1.00 0.80 1 1.9 1.00 0.09 94 6.6 94.00 0.31 1 ! 1.6 1.00 0.08 215 ! 269.8 215.00 12.73 262 60.9 262.00 2.87 1 2.6 1.00 0.12 748895 > 7277.5 Large 343.28 fail Syn40M04M 1 20.9 48642 > 7295.8 Large 349.08 65450 4042.4 Large 193.42 94271 5722.5 Large 273.80 1 > 7366.8 1.00 352.48 1 1.3 1.00 0.06 184735 > 7310.8 Large 349.80 1 ! 1.2 1.00 0.06 36540 > 7200.2 Large 344.51 222084 > 7557.3 Large 361.59 10517686 > 7477.8 Large 357.79 10541800 > 7472.6 Large 357.54 fail Syn40M 1 2.2 57114 973.0 Large 442.27 66 0.8 66.00 0.36 102 1.3 102.00 0.59 1 1.7 1.00 0.77 1 0.5 1.00 0.23 39042 108.7 Large 49.41 1 0.5 1.00 0.23 175874 2292.0 Large Large 1253823 >10415.2 Large Large 7071 3.4 Large 1.55 7071 3.2 Large 1.45 inconsistent * sssd-8-4-3 1 3.2 1393 9.7 Large 3.03 1011 1.4 Large 0.44 557 1.3 557.00 0.41 1 24.5 1.00 7.66 1 1.3 1.00 0.41 1096 1.3 Large 0.41 1 1.6 1.00 0.50 2015 9.3 Large 2.91 242772 931.1 Large 290.97 937 1.2 937.00 0.38 313770 114.0 Large 35.62 ok * sssd-10-4-3 1 6.8 1778 12.6 Large 1.85 4443 4.9 Large 0.72 750 1.7 750.00 0.25 1 295.5 1.00 43.46 1 1.7 1.00 0.25 1208 1.6 Large 0.24 1 2.2 1.00 0.32 2763 4.3 Large 0.63 1948718 >12944.6 Large Large 1902 2.7 Large 0.40 2519070 821.5 Large 120.81 ok sssd-12-5-3 1 24.2 6779 52.5 Large 2.17 18579 25.0 Large 1.03 33039 42.0 Large 1.74 # 1 > 7644.1 1.00 315.87 1 10.4 1.00 0.43 5030 5.7 Large 0.24 1 ! 12.6 1.00 0.52 39320 > 7200.2 Large 297.53 1568842 >19374.5 Large 800.60 2984 4.0 Large 0.17 19894793 > 8017.2 Large 331.29 fail sssd-15-6-3 1 118.8 25478 231.9 Large 1.95 52598 93.9 Large 0.79 31897 61.3 Large 0.52 # 1 > 7652.3 1.00 64.41 1 41.0 1.00 0.35 27637 47.5 Large 0.40 1 ! 133.8 1.00 1.13 32428 > 7200.3 Large 60.61 1271090 >15779.7 Large 132.83 21398 11.3 Large 0.10 21144042 > 7976.2 Large 67.14 fail * sssd-16-8-3 1 3710.8 765198 > 7650.0 Large 2.06 407901 966.9 Large 0.26 326001 762.0 Large 0.21 # 1 > 7560.8 1.00 2.04 1 338.5 1.00 0.09 96792 231.4 Large 0.06 1 1150.8 1.00 0.31 30162 > 7200.3 Large 1.94 1077219 >13118.5 Large 3.54 1162150 444.4 Large 0.12 14011524 > 7883.6 Large 2.12 ok sssd-18-8-3 1 5649.0 721081 > 7643.5 Large 1.35 635601 2007.9 Large 0.36 289301 841.7 Large 0.15 # 1 > 7563.5 1.00 1.34 1 1244.5 1.00 0.22 158692 392.2 Large 0.07 1 ! 1941.7 1.00 0.34 51827 > 7200.3 Large 1.27 1045218 >12851.3 Large 2.27 1539776 542.2 Large 0.10 21312832 > 7993.3 Large 1.41 fail * sssd-20-9-3 1 > 7202.5 652849 > 7616.3 Large 1.06 2449487 > 7343.1 Large 1.02 2408346 > 7256.2 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7579.1 1.00 1.05 # 1 > 7279.7 1.00 1.01 2598301 > 7326.0 Large 1.02 1 > 7200.4 1.00 1.00 28266 > 7200.2 Large 1.00 954285 >11853.3 Large 1.65 21755741 > 7714.7 Large 1.07 12674523 > 7730.7 Large 1.07 ok * sssd-22-8-3 1 > 7202.7 648239 > 7614.5 Large 1.06 1922280 > 7313.1 Large 1.02 1947845 > 7409.6 Large 1.03 # 1 > 7595.2 1.00 1.05 # 1 > 7307.2 1.00 1.01 1126401 3360.5 Large 0.47 1 5898.3 1.00 0.82 58302 > 7200.3 Large 1.00 965724 >12055.5 Large 1.67 20342521 6893.0 Large 0.96 24617230 > 7982.2 Large 1.11 ok * uflquad-15-60 1 > 7202.2 604 12.5 604.00 0.00 932 55.6 932.00 0.01 858 55.2 858.00 0.01 # 1 > 7313.5 1.00 1.02 1 1331.2 1.00 0.18 876 45.7 876.00 0.01 1 1507.0 1.00 0.21 621 9.7 621.00 0.00 604 15.8 604.00 0.00 863 1530.3 863.00 0.21 863 1532.6 863.00 0.21 ok * uflquad-15-80 1 > 7202.2 853 22.6 853.00 0.00 1412 135.8 Large 0.02 1308 124.8 Large 0.02 # 1 > 7304.0 1.00 1.01 1 6322.0 1.00 0.88 1322 117.3 Large 0.02 1 5141.1 1.00 0.71 867 17.9 867.00 0.00 880 37.2 880.00 0.01 227 > 7220.7 227.00 1.00 227 > 7220.8 227.00 1.00 ok * uflquad-20-40 1 > 7202.2 946 17.3 946.00 0.00 1510 63.0 Large 0.01 1338 58.3 Large 0.01 # 1 > 7323.5 1.00 1.02 1 1139.1 1.00 0.16 1410 52.3 Large 0.01 1 1880.2 1.00 0.26 1351 19.1 Large 0.00 1023 19.0 Large 0.00 1247 284.3 Large 0.04 1247 283.5 Large 0.04 ok * uflquad-20-50 1 > 7202.1 10404 225.1 Large 0.03 47556 > 7264.0 Large 1.01 53078 > 7234.9 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7309.2 1.00 1.01 # 1 > 7220.7 1.00 1.00 56981 > 7245.7 Large 1.01 1 > 7209.8 1.00 1.00 13917 244.5 Large 0.03 21880 1623.4 Large 0.23 375 > 7220.7 375.00 1.00 375 > 7220.7 375.00 1.00 ok * uflquad-25-25 1 > 7202.2 602 10.5 602.00 0.00 614 19.6 614.00 0.00 630 28.8 630.00 0.00 1 3815.8 1.00 0.53 1 187.7 1.00 0.03 618 17.3 618.00 0.00 1 187.5 1.00 0.03 617 8.9 617.00 0.00 474 5.8 474.00 0.00 383 14.4 383.00 0.00 383 14.8 383.00 0.00 ok * uflquad-25-30 1 > 7202.2 538 12.5 538.00 0.00 660 25.4 660.00 0.00 544 26.9 544.00 0.00 1 3352.4 1.00 0.47 1 177.7 1.00 0.02 558 18.7 558.00 0.00 1 163.9 1.00 0.02 523 10.0 523.00 0.00 306 4.7 306.00 0.00 313 19.0 313.00 0.00 313 19.1 313.00 0.00 ok * uflquad-25-40 1 > 7202.2 1032 23.3 Large 0.00 2384 129.9 Large 0.02 1932 107.7 Large 0.01 # 1 > 7311.2 1.00 1.02 1 2968.6 1.00 0.41 2162 105.8 Large 0.01 1 4831.3 1.00 0.67 2017 40.0 Large 0.01 1202 27.5 Large 0.00 1751 292.6 Large 0.04 1751 291.0 Large 0.04 ok nd-10 1 5943.3 9955 1189.3 Large 0.20 2014 33.7 Large 0.01 1904 42.6 Large 0.01 1 448.2 1.00 0.08 1 34.5 1.00 0.01 2080 28.3 Large 0.00 # 1 ! 99.2 1.00 0.02 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 20459 472.2 Large 0.08 5369 45.5 Large 0.01 # 1689480 > 7270.4 Large 1.22 fail nd-12 1 684.7 14359 > 7239.3 Large 10.57 3433 170.7 Large 0.25 3735 183.5 Large 0.27 1 660.7 1.00 0.96 1 12.5 1.00 0.02 5538 179.5 Large 0.26 # 1 ! 98.7 1.00 0.14 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 49379 2721.8 Large 3.98 4034 72.8 Large 0.11 1514851 > 7274.4 Large 10.62 fail nd-13 1 > 7202.3 14812 > 7237.2 Large 1.00 114165 > 7222.1 Large 1.00 110172 > 7222.0 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7242.2 1.00 1.01 1 969.4 1.00 0.13 160457 > 7223.4 Large 1.00 # 1 ! 1506.4 1.00 0.21 5020 > 7200.2 Large 1.00 121327 > 7251.4 Large 1.01 160382 ! 3286.0 Large 0.46 # 2249344 > 7310.2 Large 1.01 fail nd-15 1 ! 7202.3 5815 > 7227.0 Large 1.00 62777 > 7222.7 Large 1.00 58115 > 7221.2 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7317.9 1.00 1.02 1 ! 1715.9 1.00 0.24 85367 > 7222.2 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7200.3 1.00 1.00 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 73713 > 7230.4 Large 1.00 1813729 > 7255.6 Large 1.01 # 1248878 > 7275.6 Large 1.01 fail nd-16 1 > 7202.3 5762 > 7227.7 Large 1.00 97552 > 7222.2 Large 1.00 80092 > 7221.5 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7310.7 1.00 1.02 1 1511.5 1.00 0.21 123777 > 7222.5 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7200.4 1.00 1.00 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 71446 > 7227.6 Large 1.00 1312357 ! 7247.0 Large 1.01 # 1111898 > 7279.5 Large 1.01 fail fo7_2 1 16.3 120252 2031.3 Large 124.62 52106 669.6 Large 41.08 20672 99.3 Large 6.09 1 2450.5 1.00 150.34 1 12.2 1.00 0.75 52204 136.1 Large 8.35 1 ! 1670.3 1.00 102.47 # 53641 > 7200.1 Large 441.72 296763 > 7403.9 Large 454.23 103722 63.5 Large 3.90 103722 63.8 Large 3.91 fail fo7_ar2_1 1 71.7 325873 > 7489.8 Large 104.46 27707 289.7 Large 4.04 34088 401.3 Large 5.60 1 7014.4 1.00 97.83 1 9.7 1.00 0.14 27206 119.2 Large 1.66 # 1 ! 67.9 1.00 0.95 # 22535 > 7200.2 Large 100.42 440234 > 7545.5 Large 105.24 52427 32.3 Large 0.45 52427 32.4 Large 0.45 fail fo7_ar25_1 1 68.7 339800 > 7485.9 Large 108.97 9997 98.5 Large 1.43 16999 220.1 Large 3.20 # 1 > 7344.8 1.00 106.91 1 12.2 1.00 0.18 22586 112.6 Large 1.64 # 1 ! 4.5 1.00 0.07 # 21304 > 7200.2 Large 104.81 313501 > 7414.2 Large 107.92 38491 22.1 Large 0.32 38491 22.3 Large 0.32 fail * fo7_ar3_1 1 143.0 219608 > 7504.3 Large 52.48 23650 253.6 Large 1.77 18757 192.8 Large 1.35 # 1 > 7349.0 1.00 51.39 1 15.4 1.00 0.11 31705 161.9 Large 1.13 1 6582.8 1.00 46.03 # 23655 > 7200.2 Large 50.35 307946 > 7413.1 Large 51.84 44005 26.1 Large 0.18 44005 26.2 Large 0.18 ok * fo7_ar4_1 1 129.6 338010 > 7491.2 Large 57.80 21778 255.6 Large 1.97 19263 259.7 Large 2.00 # 1 > 7356.0 1.00 56.76 1 11.6 1.00 0.09 17009 83.8 Large 0.65 1 491.4 1.00 3.79 # 21401 > 7200.2 Large 55.56 260524 > 7368.0 Large 56.85 70207 44.5 Large 0.34 70207 44.5 Large 0.34 ok fo7_ar5_1 1 26.7 206982 4544.9 Large 170.22 3897 52.9 Large 1.98 2682 55.2 Large 2.07 1 3347.9 1.00 125.39 1 4.2 1.00 0.16 4443 21.5 Large 0.81 # 1 ! 3.2 1.00 0.12 # 22893 > 7200.1 Large 269.67 246282 > 7340.1 Large 274.91 18655 13.2 Large 0.49 18655 13.2 Large 0.49 fail fo7 1 158.3 496521 > 7510.1 Large 47.44 100962 585.5 Large 3.70 149071 1100.1 Large 6.95 # 1 > 7533.0 1.00 47.59 1 37.1 1.00 0.23 176402 458.8 Large 2.90 1 ! 190.5 1.00 1.20 # 49904 > 7200.1 Large 45.48 306817 > 7431.2 Large 46.94 206981 128.7 Large 0.81 206981 126.3 Large 0.80 fail fo8_ar2_1 1 416.7 274963 > 7456.9 Large 17.90 160601 2852.8 Large 6.85 113525 2301.9 Large 5.52 # 1 > 7337.6 1.00 17.61 1 52.5 1.00 0.13 377238 2570.6 Large 6.17 # 1 ! 25.3 1.00 0.06 # 14500 > 7200.1 Large 17.28 377577 > 7498.5 Large 17.99 437421 225.8 Large 0.54 437421 225.9 Large 0.54 fail fo8_ar25_1 1 432.3 # 187861 > 7466.7 Large 17.27 84801 1939.6 Large 4.49 129329 3448.7 Large 7.98 # 1 > 7368.6 1.00 17.05 1 87.1 1.00 0.20 252312 1848.9 Large 4.28 # 1 ! 34.9 1.00 0.08 # 18449 > 7200.1 Large 16.66 268957 > 7372.1 Large 17.05 305443 168.2 Large 0.39 305443 166.5 Large 0.39 fail fo8_ar3_1 1 175.8 282767 > 7454.7 Large 42.40 26441 741.8 Large 4.22 47416 1526.5 Large 8.68 # 1 > 7385.6 1.00 42.01 1 12.1 1.00 0.07 46480 377.7 Large 2.15 # 1 ! 11.2 1.00 0.06 # 18401 > 7200.1 Large 40.96 209391 > 7329.2 Large 41.69 162233 107.9 Large 0.61 162233 106.7 Large 0.61 fail * fo8_ar4_1 1 130.3 295761 > 7459.2 Large 57.25 24947 745.5 Large 5.72 23573 802.1 Large 6.16 # 1 > 7376.8 1.00 56.61 1 7.0 1.00 0.05 34982 306.5 Large 2.35 1 > 7203.7 1.00 55.29 # 16512 > 7200.1 Large 55.26 174894 > 7294.2 Large 55.98 166442 128.3 Large 0.98 166442 129.2 Large 0.99 ok * fo8_ar5_1 1 469.2 291395 > 7462.5 Large 15.90 32632 901.8 Large 1.92 25936 748.5 Large 1.60 # 1 > 7363.1 1.00 15.69 1 22.0 1.00 0.05 49232 433.7 Large 0.92 1 > 7202.5 1.00 15.35 # 18304 > 7200.1 Large 15.35 177322 > 7299.7 Large 15.56 129180 90.2 Large 0.19 129180 90.4 Large 0.19 ok fo8 1 532.2 418713 > 7478.4 Large 14.05 340135 3786.5 Large 7.11 154773 3903.7 Large 7.34 # 1 > 7461.7 1.00 14.02 1 130.3 1.00 0.24 1121335 4112.3 Large 7.73 1 ! 6025.6 1.00 11.32 # 41265 > 7200.2 Large 13.53 262119 > 7381.8 Large 13.87 605569 377.7 Large 0.71 605569 378.1 Large 0.71 fail fo9_ar2_1 1 1938.4 # 234317 > 7427.4 Large 3.83 192513 > 7285.5 Large 3.76 165291 > 7262.2 Large 3.75 # 1 > 7319.4 1.00 3.78 1 277.9 1.00 0.14 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 1 > 7200.2 1.00 3.71 # 12150 > 7200.1 Large 3.71 # 328060 > 7424.4 Large 3.83 2704643 1361.6 Large 0.70 2704643 1364.3 Large 0.70 fail fo9_ar25_1 1 > 7202.2 # 248362 > 7422.6 Large 1.03 169769 > 7281.9 Large 1.01 151951 > 7280.0 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7320.9 1.00 1.02 1 1307.2 1.00 0.18 595364 > 7320.4 Large 1.02 # 1 ! 19.9 1.00 0.00 # 13512 > 7200.2 Large 1.00 # 265432 > 7375.1 Large 1.02 12466007 > 7458.6 Large 1.04 12450093 > 7465.5 Large 1.04 fail fo9_ar3_1 1 1033.5 # 240441 > 7423.6 Large 7.18 128000 5716.6 Large 5.53 82797 4415.4 Large 4.27 # 1 > 7355.2 1.00 7.12 1 41.5 1.00 0.04 202178 2350.4 Large 2.27 # 1 ! 349.5 1.00 0.34 # 15697 > 7200.2 Large 6.97 # 170957 > 7292.3 Large 7.06 120271 80.7 Large 0.08 120271 80.3 Large 0.08 fail fo9_ar4_1 1 1274.7 # 238136 > 7424.5 Large 5.82 98913 4651.0 Large 3.65 55277 2857.3 Large 2.24 # 1 > 7367.7 1.00 5.78 1 31.8 1.00 0.02 218601 2925.3 Large 2.29 1 ! 119.7 1.00 0.09 # 919965 > 7200.3 Large 5.65 # 136375 > 7268.5 Large 5.70 1040088 700.2 Large 0.55 1040088 697.1 Large 0.55 fail fo9_ar5_1 1 2653.3 # 235696 > 7424.9 Large 2.80 52234 2552.4 Large 0.96 120038 5114.3 Large 1.93 # 1 > 7367.0 1.00 2.78 1 104.1 1.00 0.04 143563 2093.3 Large 0.79 # 1 ! 508.1 1.00 0.19 # 14891 > 7200.2 Large 2.71 121525 > 7263.1 Large 2.74 1116605 913.2 Large 0.34 1116605 914.9 Large 0.34 fail fo9 1 3049.9 379398 > 7445.8 Large 2.44 374317 > 7297.4 Large 2.39 292530 > 7273.4 Large 2.38 # 1 > 7389.2 1.00 2.42 1 475.6 1.00 0.16 1167896 > 7336.3 Large 2.41 # 1 ! 9.1 1.00 0.00 # 49824 > 7200.1 Large 2.36 226175 > 7344.6 Large 2.41 1075990 877.6 Large 0.29 1075990 877.4 Large 0.29 fail * m3 1 0.5 69 1.4 69.00 2.80 39 0.5 39.00 1.00 26 0.5 26.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 37 0.5 37.00 1.00 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 51 0.5 51.00 1.00 52 0.5 52.00 1.00 17 0.5 17.00 1.00 17 1.6 17.00 3.20 ok * m6 1 1.5 3035 46.3 Large 30.87 2149 7.3 Large 4.87 2086 17.4 Large 11.60 1 19.8 1.00 13.20 1 0.5 1.00 0.33 7344 12.3 Large 8.20 1 0.6 1.00 0.40 11493 504.4 Large 336.27 112710 1321.3 Large 880.87 890 1.5 890.00 1.00 890 1.5 890.00 1.00 ok * m7_ar2_1 1 6.8 96342 2569.8 Large 377.91 6322 163.7 Large 24.07 7747 79.2 Large 11.65 1 150.5 1.00 22.13 1 2.4 1.00 0.35 9459 38.6 Large 5.68 1 10.4 1.00 1.53 # 17542 > 7200.2 Large Large 170938 2283.1 Large 335.75 7410 4.8 Large 0.71 7410 4.1 Large 0.60 ok * m7_ar25_1 1 1.1 6560 166.5 Large 151.36 1134 11.2 Large 10.18 902 20.5 902.00 18.64 1 51.6 1.00 46.91 1 0.7 1.00 0.64 1158 6.9 Large 6.27 1 0.8 1.00 0.73 11833 4701.3 Large Large 237925 4391.7 Large Large 1804 1.8 Large 1.64 1804 1.7 Large 1.55 ok * m7_ar3_1 1 10.9 306482 > 7483.3 Large 686.54 9775 92.0 Large 8.44 7106 84.1 Large 7.72 1 726.3 1.00 66.63 1 2.3 1.00 0.21 11594 54.6 Large 5.01 1 1878.8 1.00 172.37 # 25389 > 7200.2 Large 660.57 480861 > 7479.5 Large 686.19 11644 6.5 Large 0.60 11644 6.5 Large 0.60 ok * m7_ar4_1 1 1.0 317712 > 7488.3 Large Large 3311 34.6 Large 34.60 1699 134.7 Large 134.70 1 864.5 1.00 864.50 1 0.5 1.00 0.50 6768 30.8 Large 30.80 1 0.7 1.00 0.70 # 16337 > 7200.1 Large Large 395921 7134.8 Large Large 630 1.2 630.00 1.20 630 1.3 630.00 1.30 ok m7_ar5_1 1 3.7 325454 > 7487.7 Large Large 6902 68.3 Large 18.46 10284 173.0 Large 46.76 1 1070.7 1.00 289.38 1 1.5 1.00 0.41 8425 34.2 Large 9.24 # 1 ! 28.6 1.00 7.73 # 21062 > 7200.1 Large Large 314634 > 7336.2 Large Large 17956 9.5 Large 2.57 17956 9.4 Large 2.54 fail * m7 1 2.8 27020 507.3 Large 181.18 24030 184.2 Large 65.79 6244 57.0 Large 20.36 1 140.0 1.00 50.00 1 0.9 1.00 0.32 50360 113.5 Large 40.54 1 0.5 1.00 0.18 # 52912 > 7200.2 Large Large 521609 > 7448.2 Large Large 16013 9.2 Large 3.29 16013 9.0 Large 3.21 ok * netmod_dol1 1 > 7202.2 46504 > 7250.5 Large 1.01 7647 > 7273.5 Large 1.01 7938 > 7225.2 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7246.7 1.00 1.01 # 1 > 7220.2 1.00 1.00 7657 > 7275.1 Large 1.01 1 > 7201.7 1.00 1.00 # 62946 > 7200.3 Large 1.00 13213 > 7214.9 Large 1.00 66114 5276.9 Large 0.73 66114 5289.3 Large 0.73 ok netmod_dol2 1 408.5 3274 1936.8 Large 4.74 398 228.6 398.00 0.56 568 337.4 568.00 0.83 # 1 > 7226.9 1.00 17.69 1 235.5 1.00 0.58 1677 1022.6 Large 2.50 1 ! 526.1 1.00 1.29 1055 244.4 Large 0.60 1 ! 5.4 1.00 0.01 119 38.4 119.00 0.09 119 38.4 119.00 0.09 fail * netmod_kar1 1 82.0 473 15.0 473.00 0.18 1148 42.6 Large 0.52 870 29.9 870.00 0.36 # 1 > 7342.0 1.00 89.54 1 80.3 1.00 0.98 808 19.0 808.00 0.23 1 635.0 1.00 7.74 8639 128.1 Large 1.56 6893 204.3 Large 2.49 298 3.8 298.00 0.05 298 4.0 298.00 0.05 ok * netmod_kar2 1 82.6 473 15.0 473.00 0.18 1148 42.8 Large 0.52 870 29.9 870.00 0.36 # 1 > 7340.5 1.00 88.87 1 80.2 1.00 0.97 808 18.9 808.00 0.23 1 634.4 1.00 7.68 8639 128.0 Large 1.55 6893 202.7 Large 2.45 298 3.8 298.00 0.05 298 3.7 298.00 0.04 ok no7_ar2_1 1 131.1 174296 > 7503.1 Large 57.23 37661 242.3 Large 1.85 32204 204.2 Large 1.56 # 1 > 7416.5 1.00 56.57 1 7.3 1.00 0.06 80918 304.9 Large 2.33 1 ! 13.4 1.00 0.10 # 15595 > 7200.2 Large 54.92 346309 > 7471.6 Large 56.99 27721 19.7 Large 0.15 27721 19.7 Large 0.15 fail no7_ar25_1 1 221.2 330284 > 7492.9 Large 33.87 96056 602.9 Large 2.73 91307 613.5 Large 2.77 # 1 > 7478.8 1.00 33.81 1 23.1 1.00 0.10 185142 647.5 Large 2.93 # 1 > 7200.8 1.00 32.55 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 242349 > 7380.7 Large 33.37 72438 53.3 Large 0.24 72438 52.1 Large 0.24 fail * no7_ar3_1 1 361.9 172383 > 7500.8 Large 20.73 217317 1243.4 Large 3.44 166806 1017.8 Large 2.81 # 1 > 7347.0 1.00 20.30 1 77.2 1.00 0.21 360009 1219.9 Large 3.37 # 1 > 7201.3 1.00 19.90 # 17945 > 7200.2 Large 19.90 250276 > 7374.7 Large 20.38 280947 171.6 Large 0.47 280947 169.6 Large 0.47 ok * no7_ar4_1 1 308.8 335365 > 7496.5 Large 24.28 132539 823.2 Large 2.67 135112 879.9 Large 2.85 # 1 > 7509.3 1.00 24.32 1 74.3 1.00 0.24 224036 840.6 Large 2.72 # 1 > 7205.1 1.00 23.33 # 14178 > 7200.3 Large 23.32 224944 > 7367.6 Large 23.86 138953 101.1 Large 0.33 138953 101.1 Large 0.33 ok no7_ar5_1 1 197.3 327410 > 7486.4 Large 37.94 72405 477.5 Large 2.42 57956 373.8 Large 1.89 # 1 > 7520.3 1.00 38.12 1 70.2 1.00 0.36 120442 465.6 Large 2.36 # 1 ! 73.4 1.00 0.37 # 15560 > 7200.2 Large 36.49 214287 > 7343.6 Large 37.22 92609 63.5 Large 0.32 92609 63.8 Large 0.32 fail * o7_2 1 1225.8 454210 > 7514.5 Large 6.13 417664 1422.9 Large 1.16 560715 1688.2 Large 1.38 # 1 > 7491.2 1.00 6.11 1 518.9 1.00 0.42 829808 1918.9 Large 1.57 # 1 > 7200.9 1.00 5.87 # 20065 > 7200.2 Large 5.87 280797 > 7410.0 Large 6.05 1879586 1272.5 Large 1.04 1879586 1270.4 Large 1.04 ok * o7_ar2_1 1 164.5 329664 > 7480.0 Large 45.47 110888 663.4 Large 4.03 101987 596.8 Large 3.63 # 1 > 7377.7 1.00 44.85 1 52.6 1.00 0.32 192688 659.0 Large 4.01 1 4092.0 1.00 24.88 # 17058 > 7200.2 Large 43.77 307163 > 7458.1 Large 45.34 129891 78.4 Large 0.48 129891 79.4 Large 0.48 ok o7_ar25_1 1 876.7 341508 > 7497.6 Large 8.55 228914 1119.6 Large 1.28 254729 1431.4 Large 1.63 # 1 > 7508.8 1.00 8.56 1 239.0 1.00 0.27 429378 1394.3 Large 1.59 # 1 > 7201.2 1.00 8.21 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 270104 > 7424.6 Large 8.47 669325 465.2 Large 0.53 669325 466.6 Large 0.53 fail * o7_ar3_1 1 689.2 330281 > 7488.2 Large 10.87 380142 1992.6 Large 2.89 347561 1752.8 Large 2.54 # 1 > 7447.6 1.00 10.81 1 477.7 1.00 0.69 714091 2288.7 Large 3.32 # 1 > 7200.8 1.00 10.45 # 19185 > 7200.2 Large 10.45 230750 > 7369.9 Large 10.69 1053808 712.5 Large 1.03 1053808 715.5 Large 1.04 ok * o7_ar4_1 1 4416.5 342709 > 7482.3 Large 1.69 531102 2899.7 Large 0.66 466882 2517.3 Large 0.57 # 1 > 7487.0 1.00 1.70 1 1632.1 1.00 0.37 802687 2707.9 Large 0.61 # 1 > 7200.9 1.00 1.63 # 9859 > 7200.2 Large 1.63 209048 > 7346.3 Large 1.66 1705683 1244.1 Large 0.28 1705683 1244.0 Large 0.28 ok * o7_ar5_1 1 645.0 340519 > 7488.1 Large 11.61 184577 1073.8 Large 1.66 180845 1246.5 Large 1.93 # 1 > 7509.7 1.00 11.64 1 333.8 1.00 0.52 296779 1098.2 Large 1.70 1 > 7200.7 1.00 11.16 # 13449 > 7200.2 Large 11.16 221800 > 7350.2 Large 11.40 620025 419.9 Large 0.65 620025 418.3 Large 0.65 ok * o7 1 > 7202.2 438438 > 7521.2 Large 1.04 1223437 4180.1 Large 0.58 1461992 4029.9 Large 0.56 # 1 > 7602.1 1.00 1.06 1 2462.8 1.00 0.34 2094716 4770.6 Large 0.66 # 1 > 7200.8 1.00 1.00 # 49022 > 7200.1 Large 1.00 280735 > 7424.4 Large 1.03 2498329 1575.1 Large 0.22 2498329 1580.6 Large 0.22 ok * o8_ar4_1 1 > 7202.5 299299 > 7450.2 Large 1.03 476210 > 7332.3 Large 1.02 544854 > 7344.6 Large 1.02 # 1 > 7422.9 1.00 1.03 1 5426.4 1.00 0.75 934192 > 7361.0 Large 1.02 # 1 > 7200.4 1.00 1.00 # 9678 > 7200.1 Large 1.00 178896 > 7302.2 Large 1.01 9342240 > 7423.9 Large 1.03 9351849 > 7421.8 Large 1.03 ok * o9_ar4_1 1 > 7202.7 # 235965 > 7422.1 Large 1.03 291307 > 7282.0 Large 1.01 249619 > 7274.0 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7408.1 1.00 1.03 # 1 > 7245.8 1.00 1.01 639040 > 7299.0 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7200.3 1.00 1.00 # 9215 > 7200.1 Large 1.00 # 174299 > 7297.7 Large 1.01 9085490 > 7412.4 Large 1.03 9094498 > 7411.2 Large 1.03 ok * tls12 # 1 > 7202.3 # 161520 > 7370.2 Large 1.02 # 205817 > 7262.9 Large 1.01 # 263639 > 7263.3 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7447.3 1.00 1.03 # 1 > 7221.1 1.00 1.00 # 412165 > 7334.7 Large 1.02 # 1 > 7200.3 1.00 1.00 # 137924 > 7200.5 Large 1.00 # 257587 > 7667.1 Large 1.06 # 111957 > 7368.5 Large 1.02 # 619987 > 7392.0 Large 1.03 ok tls2 1 0.5 622 6.0 622.00 12.00 130 0.5 130.00 1.00 144 11.3 144.00 22.60 1 0.9 1.00 1.80 1 0.5 1.00 1.00 256 0.5 256.00 1.00 1 ! 0.9 1.00 1.80 1042 1.5 Large 3.00 1496 4.2 Large 8.40 11 0.5 11.00 1.00 5 0.5 5.00 1.00 fail tls4 1 224.5 670556 > 7676.5 Large 34.19 248542 1082.4 Large 4.82 254614 1252.2 Large 5.58 # 1 > 7444.0 1.00 33.16 1 236.7 1.00 1.05 1575374 3786.2 Large 16.87 # 1 > 7200.7 1.00 32.07 # 1 ! 0.5 1.00 0.00 1653760 >15208.6 Large 67.74 5387 9.3 Large 0.04 59960 59.0 Large 0.26 fail * tls5 1 > 7202.3 # 552317 > 7597.7 Large 1.05 555401 > 7285.5 Large 1.01 523174 > 7237.0 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7519.4 1.00 1.04 # 1 > 7225.8 1.00 1.00 426390 > 7255.0 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7200.5 1.00 1.00 # 435585 > 7200.4 Large 1.00 998944 >10552.2 Large 1.47 2765317 > 7410.5 Large 1.03 4475614 > 7519.9 Large 1.04 ok tls6 1 > 7202.3 # 441654 > 7535.5 Large 1.05 # 614194 > 7284.2 Large 1.01 452936 > 7234.7 Large 1.00 # 1 > 7442.2 1.00 1.03 # 1 > 7224.0 1.00 1.00 # 533674 > 7258.5 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7200.2 1.00 1.00 339173 > 7200.6 Large 1.00 835557 > 9148.5 Large 1.27 1405555 > 7415.0 Large 1.03 2802946 > 7459.0 Large 1.04 inconsistent tls7 1 > 7202.3 # 363777 > 7489.1 Large 1.04 # 412745 > 7268.1 Large 1.01 # 293752 > 7255.9 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7302.0 1.00 1.01 # 1 > 7224.9 1.00 1.00 # 834221 > 7283.3 Large 1.01 # 1 > 7200.2 1.00 1.00 307724 > 7200.4 Large 1.00 # 659592 > 8474.6 Large 1.18 987193 > 7315.0 Large 1.02 1708575 > 7409.9 Large 1.03 inconsistent --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- total (81) 81 156836 9002140 236022 10549058 125098 10614423 118459 81 316175 81 92557 14280959 141051 81 192305 2307493 260514 16714679 309385 102091570 102433 115265223 112249 geom. mean 1 107.2 5801 239.8 5801.92 2.24 3245 64.3 3245.35 0.60 2975 78.3 2975.60 0.73 1 452.4 1.00 4.22 1 22.0 1.00 0.20 5759 69.6 5759.54 0.65 1 83.6 1.00 0.78 4480 261.0 4480.11 2.43 21470 383.3 21470.73 3.58 8602 39.1 8602.12 0.37 18694 57.1 18694.06 0.53 shifted geom. 1 184.5 8331 349.7 8331.94 1.89 4855 130.7 4855.21 0.71 4474 133.9 4474.09 0.73 1 720.3 1.00 3.90 1 61.0 1.00 0.33 7743 137.5 7743.48 0.74 1 207.6 1.00 1.12 5535 421.7 5535.01 2.29 26441 591.1 26441.93 3.20 13496 85.4 13496.32 0.46 21508 105.1 21508.78 0.57 --------------------+-+---------+--------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+-+---------+--------+------+------+------------- all proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score ALPHAECP(alphaecp-minlpconvex2) 155 81 1 22 127 8 0 0 0 0 154 1 1 1.00 1.00 107.2 184.5 1.00 1.00 1.00 BONMIN(bonmin-bb) 155 81 2 32 90 12 29 42 3 19 144 5801 8331 5801.92 8331.94 239.8 349.7 2.24 1.89 0.72 BONMIN(bonmin-ecp) 155 81 5 16 125 13 39 29 4 3 152 3245 4855 3245.35 4855.21 64.3 130.7 0.60 0.71 1.30 BONMIN(bonmin-hyb) 155 81 2 15 129 8 37 30 4 4 153 2975 4474 2975.60 4474.09 78.3 133.9 0.73 0.73 1.18 BONMIN(bonmin-oa) 155 81 0 43 82 11 17 44 0 38 91 1 1 1.00 1.00 452.4 720.3 4.22 3.90 0.43 BONMIN(bonmin-oa-cpx) 155 81 1 11 142 45 67 1 0 8 143 1 1 1.00 1.00 22.0 61.0 0.20 0.33 3.38 BONMIN(bonmin-qg) 155 81 1 18 124 20 41 26 4 5 151 5759 7743 5759.54 7743.48 69.6 137.5 0.65 0.74 1.34 DICOPT(dicopt-minlpconvex) 155 81 38 24 84 23 43 24 1 16 123 1 1 1.00 1.00 83.6 207.6 0.78 1.12 1.32 KNITRO(knitro) 155 81 15 36 72 14 28 42 1 32 107 4480 5535 4480.11 5535.01 261.0 421.7 2.43 2.29 0.72 SBB(sbb) 155 81 4 38 78 10 23 45 1 28 148 21470 26441 21470.73 26441.93 383.3 591.1 3.58 3.20 0.57 MYSCIP(assumeconvex) 155 81 3 12 136 25 53 14 4 1 154 8602 13496 8602.12 13496.32 39.1 85.4 0.37 0.46 2.17 MYSCIP(minlp) 155 81 2 16 119 17 43 25 2 3 149 18694 21508 18694.06 21508.78 57.1 105.1 0.53 0.57 1.58 optimal auto settings 0 7 147 73 5 154 1 1 1.00 1.00 10.7 31.5 0.10 0.17 diff proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score BONMIN(bonmin-bb) 80 41 2 0 78 2 19 21 0 0 80 562 1047 562.30 1047.26 28.8 49.3 1.92 1.55 0.90 BONMIN(bonmin-ecp) 120 59 5 0 115 8 31 26 0 0 120 1241 2097 1241.58 2097.47 19.7 46.5 0.67 0.83 1.22 BONMIN(bonmin-hyb) 120 59 2 0 118 3 28 27 0 0 120 1105 1872 1105.40 1872.81 26.1 49.0 0.89 0.88 1.05 BONMIN(bonmin-oa) 80 40 0 0 80 6 15 22 0 0 80 1 1 1.00 1.00 26.6 60.2 2.83 3.04 0.54 BONMIN(bonmin-oa-cpx) 128 62 1 0 127 39 57 1 0 0 128 1 1 1.00 1.00 5.0 12.9 0.17 0.24 3.95 BONMIN(bonmin-qg) 113 55 1 0 112 14 31 19 0 0 112 1797 2700 1797.73 2700.43 15.2 34.7 0.50 0.59 1.47 DICOPT(dicopt-minlpconvex) 113 53 36 0 77 18 36 15 0 0 100 1 1 1.00 1.00 9.8 32.2 0.51 0.87 1.83 KNITRO(knitro) 74 37 14 0 60 6 18 17 0 0 68 1324 1993 1324.44 1993.43 19.8 44.3 1.47 1.52 1.11 SBB(sbb) 71 39 2 0 69 4 15 22 0 0 71 3554 5289 3554.03 5289.95 42.9 89.3 3.23 3.10 0.72 MYSCIP(assumeconvex) 123 60 1 0 122 17 42 12 0 0 123 3512 6269 3512.06 6269.82 10.4 23.9 0.35 0.44 2.28 MYSCIP(minlp) 108 59 2 0 106 9 33 22 0 0 107 8585 10137 8585.93 10137.19 15.5 29.9 0.57 0.59 1.51 equal proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score timeout proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score BONMIN(bonmin-bb) 75 40 0 32 12 10 10 21 3 19 64 63462 65040 63462.62 65040.52 2102.4 2271.7 2.62 2.44 0.58 BONMIN(bonmin-ecp) 35 22 0 16 10 5 8 3 4 3 32 42692 43764 42692.03 43765.00 1530.2 1617.6 0.45 0.45 1.55 BONMIN(bonmin-hyb) 35 22 0 15 11 5 9 3 4 4 33 42355 43526 42355.03 43526.84 1487.2 1564.3 0.43 0.44 1.60 BONMIN(bonmin-oa) 75 41 0 43 2 5 2 22 0 38 11 1 1 1.00 1.00 7168.0 7168.1 6.23 5.96 0.34 BONMIN(bonmin-oa-cpx) 27 19 0 11 15 6 10 0 0 8 15 1 1 1.00 1.00 2822.0 2843.1 0.39 0.39 2.04 BONMIN(bonmin-qg) 42 26 0 18 12 6 10 7 4 5 39 67617 69192 67617.39 69192.58 1728.4 1827.5 1.12 1.07 1.10 DICOPT(dicopt-minlpconvex) 42 28 2 24 7 5 7 9 1 16 23 1 1 1.00 1.00 4816.1 4833.4 1.74 1.69 0.70 KNITRO(knitro) 81 44 1 36 12 8 10 25 1 32 39 12483 12857 12483.75 12857.32 2281.4 2459.5 3.73 3.33 0.50 SBB(sbb) 84 42 2 38 9 6 8 23 1 28 77 114071 116534 114071.64 116534.57 2931.5 3189.3 3.93 3.71 0.46 MYSCIP(assumeconvex) 32 21 2 12 14 8 11 2 4 1 31 111213 118548 111213.73 118548.46 1728.9 1822.5 0.40 0.41 1.91 MYSCIP(minlp) 47 22 0 16 13 8 10 3 2 3 42 150637 160130 150637.72 160130.60 1871.4 1966.9 0.43 0.45 1.77 all optimal proc eval fail time solv wins bett wors bobj wobj feas gnodes shnodes gnodesQ shnodesQ gtime shtime gtimeQ shtimeQ score ALPHAECP(alphaecp-minlpconvex2) 40 31 0 0 50 2 0 0 0 0 40 1 1 1.00 1.00 9.1 20.5 1.00 1.00 1.00 BONMIN(bonmin-bb) 40 31 0 0 50 2 14 16 0 0 40 375 829 375.26 829.01 20.4 39.4 2.23 1.92 0.79 BONMIN(bonmin-ecp) 40 31 0 0 47 8 23 6 0 0 40 118 240 118.56 240.46 2.1 4.1 0.23 0.20 2.54 BONMIN(bonmin-hyb) 40 31 0 0 47 2 19 8 0 0 40 121 252 121.81 252.73 4.3 7.3 0.47 0.36 1.71 BONMIN(bonmin-oa) 40 31 0 0 47 6 15 13 0 0 40 1 1 1.00 1.00 11.3 29.2 1.24 1.42 0.86 BONMIN(bonmin-oa-cpx) 40 31 0 0 47 21 29 0 0 0 40 1 1 1.00 1.00 1.3 2.4 0.14 0.12 4.09 BONMIN(bonmin-qg) 40 31 0 0 47 12 21 6 0 0 40 257 450 257.02 450.40 2.7 5.5 0.29 0.27 2.09 DICOPT(dicopt-minlpconvex) 40 31 0 0 42 12 24 5 0 0 40 1 1 1.00 1.00 3.1 11.3 0.33 0.55 2.43 KNITRO(knitro) 40 31 0 0 42 6 15 14 0 0 40 1041 1690 1041.77 1690.44 17.4 44.0 1.90 2.14 1.03 SBB(sbb) 40 31 0 0 41 4 13 16 0 0 40 2115 3465 2115.94 3465.92 23.5 57.0 2.57 2.78 0.81 MYSCIP(assumeconvex) 40 31 0 0 41 13 23 5 0 0 40 310 851 310.06 851.35 2.1 3.7 0.23 0.18 2.89 MYSCIP(minlp) 40 31 0 0 40 4 16 14 0 0 40 1625 2105 1625.17 2105.23 4.4 7.8 0.48 0.38 1.50 total time over all settings: 4186430.2 sec = 1162.9 hours = 48.5 days = 6.9 weeks = 1.6 months