Solver Square Comparison: Considers all models.

Results created on 02/25/11 16:06:54 using the PAVER Server/Performance tools available at http://www.gamsworld.eu/performance/paver

Compares all solver return outcomes (for example optimal, locally optimal, infeasible, unbounded, fail) of one solver with all return outcomes of another solver. Interrupt denotes resource or iteration limit has been reached.

Solver ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex is represented on the left (rows) and solver BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx on top (columns).

See the solver return definitions for return codes. Models having trace data only in one trace file are listed in the "no data" column of the other.

Input File Number Filename
Tracefile 1: MINLPconvex.ALPHAECP.alphaecp-minlpconvex.pav
Tracefile 2: MINLPconvex.BONMIN.bonmin-oa-cpx.pav
Solvers used : ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex
BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx
Modeltype(s)   MINLP

BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx:
optimal
BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx:
locally optimal
BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx:
feasible
BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx:
infeasible
BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx:
unbounded
BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx:
fail
BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx:
no data
total ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex
ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex:
optimal
35 - - - - 2 - 37
ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex:
locally optimal
- - - - - - - -
ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex:
feasible
5 - 1 - - 3 - 9
ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex:
infeasible
- - - - - - - -
ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex:
unbounded
- - - - - - - -
ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex:
fail
1 - - - - - - 1
ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex:
no data
- - - - - - - -
total BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx 41 - 1 - - 5 - 47

Solver return definitions:

Outcome Model Status Solver Status
optimal 1 or 15 1
locally optimal 2 any
feasible 8 or 16 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5
infeasible 4 or 5 or 10 or 19 1
unbounded 3 or 18 1
fail all other all other

Solver Resource Times


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: optimal -- BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: optimal    

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Ratio (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex/BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
BatchS101006M 86.9510 6.2860 13.832 769440.00000000 769440.00000000
BatchS121208M 414.9960 4.1370 100.313 1241130.00000000 1241130.00000000
BatchS151208M 358.0080 14.1860 25.237 1543470.00000000 1543470.00000000
BatchS201210M 137.4990 28.1430 4.886 2295350.00000000 2295350.00000000
clay0303h 5.4760 2.1710 2.522 26669.10000000 26669.10000000
clay0304h 18.8560 11.8240 1.595 40262.40000000 40262.40000000
clay0305h 53.9050 16.2650 3.314 8092.50000000 8092.50000000
clay0305m 17.3060 14.3640 1.205 8092.50000000 8092.50000000
FLay04H 96.0070 23.6240 4.064 54.40590000 54.40590000
fo7_2 41.5380 24.0690 1.726 17.74930000 17.74930000
fo7 206.4110 49.2510 4.191 20.72980000 20.72980000
fo8 1480.9900 155.6810 9.513 22.38190000 22.38190000
m6 1.5500 0.3150 4.921 82.25690000 82.25690000
m7 4.3460 1.1780 3.689 106.75700000 106.75700000
o7_2 569.6560 3363.0500 0.169 116.94600000 116.94600000
RSyn0805H 0.8410 0.2040 4.123 1296.12000000 1296.12000000
RSyn0805M02M 10.0430 23.0470 0.436 2238.40000000 2238.40000000
RSyn0805M03M 12.7890 31.3840 0.408 3068.93000000 3068.93000000
RSyn0805M04M 17.8910 11.6180 1.540 7174.22000000 7174.22000000
RSyn0810M02M 13.2200 12.3630 1.069 1741.39000000 1741.39000000
RSyn0810M03M 13.8260 22.1170 0.625 2722.45000000 2722.45000000
RSyn0820M 2.1400 0.5800 3.690 1150.30000000 1150.30000000
RSyn0830M04H 21.8760 5.0920 4.296 2529.07000000 2529.07000000
RSyn0830M 3.0010 0.7740 3.877 510.07200000 510.07200000
RSyn0840M 2.2910 0.8750 2.618 325.55500000 325.55500000
SLay06H 318.8590 1.7240 184.953 32757.00000000 32757.00000000
SLay07H 3416.9100 5.1670 661.295 64748.80000000 64748.80000000
Syn15M04M 3.6060 0.4080 8.838 4937.48000000 4937.48000000
Syn20M03M 3.5180 0.3990 8.817 2646.95000000 2646.95000000
Syn20M04M 4.5620 0.5250 8.690 3532.74000000 3532.74000000
Syn30M02M 3.7390 0.5740 6.514 399.68300000 399.68300000
Syn40M03H 10.5050 1.8010 5.833 395.14900000 395.14900000
Syn40M 2.3590 0.2850 8.277 67.71330000 67.71330000
sssd-10-4-3 2.9870 1.0390 2.875 152710.00000000 152710.00000000
sssd-15-6-3 104.9700 215.4670 0.487 440748.00000000 440711.00000000

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: optimal -- BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: fail    

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Ratio (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex/BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Status (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
clay0304m 10.3940 2.2020 --- 40262.40000000 mstat( 7)sstat( 1)
FLay05M 3305.1000 3604.2800 --- 64.49810000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: feasible -- BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: optimal    

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Ratio (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex/BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
FLay06M 3615.6500 5.5250 654.416 66.93280000 66.93280000
SLay08H 3621.8700 16.3770 221.156 84960.20000000 84960.20000000
SLay09H 3663.8900 83.2580 44.006 107806.00000000 107806.00000000
SLay09M 3666.3900 24.8570 147.499 107806.00000000 107806.00000000
SLay10M 3657.1700 1420.6400 2.574 129810.00000000 129580.00000000

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: feasible -- BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: feasible    

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Ratio (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex/BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
uflquad-30-100 3634.2800 3602.7000 1.009 415.04000000 2952.74000000

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: feasible -- BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: fail    

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Ratio (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex/BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Status (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
FLay05H 3615.7000 3602.1000 --- 64.49810000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
uflquad-20-150 3651.8800 3604.2700 --- 630.18200000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)
uflquad-40-80 3666.3400 3604.0900 --- 386.67200000 mstat(14)sstat( 3)

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: fail -- BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: optimal    

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Ratio (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex/BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Status (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
sssd-12-5-3 7.4980 15.1870 --- mstat( 7)sstat( 1) 261143.00000000

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: optimal:

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex)
BatchS101006M 86.9510 769440.00000000
BatchS121208M 414.9960 1241130.00000000
BatchS151208M 358.0080 1543470.00000000
BatchS201210M 137.4990 2295350.00000000
clay0303h 5.4760 26669.10000000
clay0304h 18.8560 40262.40000000
clay0304m 10.3940 40262.40000000
clay0305h 53.9050 8092.50000000
clay0305m 17.3060 8092.50000000
FLay04H 96.0070 54.40590000
FLay05M 3305.1000 64.49810000
fo7_2 41.5380 17.74930000
fo7 206.4110 20.72980000
fo8 1480.9900 22.38190000
m6 1.5500 82.25690000
m7 4.3460 106.75700000
o7_2 569.6560 116.94600000
RSyn0805H 0.8410 1296.12000000
RSyn0805M02M 10.0430 2238.40000000
RSyn0805M03M 12.7890 3068.93000000
RSyn0805M04M 17.8910 7174.22000000
RSyn0810M02M 13.2200 1741.39000000
RSyn0810M03M 13.8260 2722.45000000
RSyn0820M 2.1400 1150.30000000
RSyn0830M04H 21.8760 2529.07000000
RSyn0830M 3.0010 510.07200000
RSyn0840M 2.2910 325.55500000
SLay06H 318.8590 32757.00000000
SLay07H 3416.9100 64748.80000000
Syn15M04M 3.6060 4937.48000000
Syn20M03M 3.5180 2646.95000000
Syn20M04M 4.5620 3532.74000000
Syn30M02M 3.7390 399.68300000
Syn40M03H 10.5050 395.14900000
Syn40M 2.3590 67.71330000
sssd-10-4-3 2.9870 152710.00000000
sssd-15-6-3 104.9700 440748.00000000

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: feasible:

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex)
FLay05H 3615.7000 64.49810000
FLay06M 3615.6500 66.93280000
SLay08H 3621.8700 84960.20000000
SLay09H 3663.8900 107806.00000000
SLay09M 3666.3900 107806.00000000
SLay10M 3657.1700 129810.00000000
uflquad-20-150 3651.8800 630.18200000
uflquad-30-100 3634.2800 415.04000000
uflquad-40-80 3666.3400 386.67200000

Back to top


ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: fail:

Back to top

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Status (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex)
sssd-12-5-3 -- mstat( 7) sstat( 1)

Back to top


BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: optimal:

Back to top

Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
BatchS101006M 6.2860 769440.00000000
BatchS121208M 4.1370 1241130.00000000
BatchS151208M 14.1860 1543470.00000000
BatchS201210M 28.1430 2295350.00000000
clay0303h 2.1710 26669.10000000
clay0304h 11.8240 40262.40000000
clay0305h 16.2650 8092.50000000
clay0305m 14.3640 8092.50000000
FLay04H 23.6240 54.40590000
FLay06M 5.5250 66.93280000
fo7_2 24.0690 17.74930000
fo7 49.2510 20.72980000
fo8 155.6810 22.38190000
m6 0.3150 82.25690000
m7 1.1780 106.75700000
o7_2 3363.0500 116.94600000
RSyn0805H 0.2040 1296.12000000
RSyn0805M02M 23.0470 2238.40000000
RSyn0805M03M 31.3840 3068.93000000
RSyn0805M04M 11.6180 7174.22000000
RSyn0810M02M 12.3630 1741.39000000
RSyn0810M03M 22.1170 2722.45000000
RSyn0820M 0.5800 1150.30000000
RSyn0830M04H 5.0920 2529.07000000
RSyn0830M 0.7740 510.07200000
RSyn0840M 0.8750 325.55500000
SLay06H 1.7240 32757.00000000
SLay07H 5.1670 64748.80000000
SLay08H 16.3770 84960.20000000
SLay09H 83.2580 107806.00000000
SLay09M 24.8570 107806.00000000
SLay10M 1420.6400 129580.00000000
Syn15M04M 0.4080 4937.48000000
Syn20M03M 0.3990 2646.95000000
Syn20M04M 0.5250 3532.74000000
Syn30M02M 0.5740 399.68300000
Syn40M03H 1.8010 395.14900000
Syn40M 0.2850 67.71330000
sssd-10-4-3 1.0390 152710.00000000
sssd-12-5-3 15.1870 261143.00000000
sssd-15-6-3 215.4670 440711.00000000

Back to top

BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: feasible:

Back to top

Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
uflquad-30-100 3602.7000 2952.74000000

Back to top

BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: fail:

Back to top

Modelname Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Status (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
clay0304m -- mstat( 7)sstat( 1)
FLay05H -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
FLay05M -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
uflquad-20-150 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)
uflquad-40-80 -- mstat(14)sstat( 3)

Back to top

ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex: all -- BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx: all

Back to top

A "(max)" behind a model names indicates that this model is a maximization model.

Rows with red background in the model name mark inconsistencies, caused by negative gaps or objective values of one solver that are better than the objestive estimate of the other solver.

A model is counted as solved if the gap reported by the solver is at most 0.00015. The gap is in this case displayed with a green background.

A shifted geometric mean of the solver time is computed, where unsolved instances and instances above the timelimit are counted with the timelimit (3666.39 seconds). The shift is 10s.

Modelname Time (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Time (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Ratio (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex/ BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Obj (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Obj (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) ObjEst (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) ObjEst (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx) Gap (ALPHAECP_alphaecp-minlpconvex) Gap (BONMIN_bonmin-oa-cpx)
BatchS101006M 86.9510 6.2860 13.832 769440.00000000 769440.00000000 769440.00000000 769440.00000000 0.0000 0.0000
BatchS121208M 414.9960 4.1370 100.313 1241130.00000000 1241130.00000000 1241130.00000000 1241130.00000000 0.0000 0.0000
BatchS151208M 358.0080 14.1860 25.237 1543470.00000000 1543470.00000000 1543470.00000000 1543470.00000000 0.0000 0.0000
BatchS201210M 137.4990 28.1430 4.886 2295350.00000000 2295350.00000000 2295350.00000000 2295350.00000000 0.0000 0.0000
clay0303h 5.4760 2.1710 2.522 26669.10000000 26669.10000000 26669.10000000 26669.10000000 0.0000 0.0000
clay0304h 18.8560 11.8240 1.595 40262.40000000 40262.40000000 40262.40000000 40262.40000000 0.0000 0.0000
clay0304m 10.3940 2.2020 --- 40262.40000000 mstat( 7) sstat(1) 40262.40000000 --- 0.0000 ---
clay0305h 53.9050 16.2650 3.314 8092.50000000 8092.50000000 8092.50000000 8092.50000000 0.0000 0.0000
clay0305m 17.3060 14.3640 1.205 8092.50000000 8092.50000000 8092.50000000 8092.50000000 0.0000 0.0000
FLay04H 96.0070 23.6240 4.064 54.40590000 54.40590000 54.40590000 54.40590000 0.0000 0.0000
FLay05H 3615.7000 3602.1000 --- 64.49810000 mstat(14) sstat(3) -1.0000000000000E+20 --- 1.0000 ---
FLay05M 3305.1000 3604.2800 --- 64.49810000 mstat(14) sstat(3) 64.49810000 --- 0.0000 ---
FLay06M 3615.6500 5.5250 654.416 66.93280000 66.93280000 -1.0000000000000E+20 66.93280000 1.0000 0.0000
fo7_2 41.5380 24.0690 1.726 17.74930000 17.74930000 17.74930000 17.74930000 0.0000 0.0000
fo7 206.4110 49.2510 4.191 20.72980000 20.72980000 20.72980000 20.72980000 0.0000 0.0000
fo8 1480.9900 155.6810 9.513 22.38190000 22.38190000 22.38190000 22.38190000 0.0000 0.0000
m6 1.5500 0.3150 4.921 82.25690000 82.25690000 82.25690000 82.25690000 0.0000 0.0000
m7 4.3460 1.1780 3.689 106.75700000 106.75700000 106.75700000 106.75700000 0.0000 0.0000
o7_2 569.6560 3363.0500 0.169 116.94600000 116.94600000 116.94600000 116.94600000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0805H (max) 0.8410 0.2040 4.123 1296.12000000 1296.12000000 1296.12000000 1296.12000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0805M02M (max) 10.0430 23.0470 0.436 2238.40000000 2238.40000000 2238.40000000 2238.40000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0805M03M (max) 12.7890 31.3840 0.408 3068.93000000 3068.93000000 3068.93000000 3068.93000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0805M04M (max) 17.8910 11.6180 1.540 7174.22000000 7174.22000000 7174.22000000 7174.22000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0810M02M (max) 13.2200 12.3630 1.069 1741.39000000 1741.39000000 1741.39000000 1741.39000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0810M03M (max) 13.8260 22.1170 0.625 2722.45000000 2722.45000000 2722.45000000 2722.45000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0820M (max) 2.1400 0.5800 3.690 1150.30000000 1150.30000000 1150.30000000 1150.30000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0830M04H (max) 21.8760 5.0920 4.296 2529.07000000 2529.07000000 2529.07000000 2529.07000000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0830M (max) 3.0010 0.7740 3.877 510.07200000 510.07200000 510.07200000 510.07200000 0.0000 0.0000
RSyn0840M (max) 2.2910 0.8750 2.618 325.55500000 325.55500000 325.55500000 325.55500000 0.0000 0.0000
SLay06H 318.8590 1.7240 184.953 32757.00000000 32757.00000000 32757.00000000 32757.00000000 0.0000 0.0000
SLay07H 3416.9100 5.1670 661.295 64748.80000000 64748.80000000 64748.80000000 64748.80000000 0.0000 0.0000
SLay08H 3621.8700 16.3770 221.156 84960.20000000 84960.20000000 84960.20000000 84960.20000000 0.0000 0.0000
SLay09H 3663.8900 83.2580 44.006 107806.00000000 107806.00000000 -1.0000000000000E+20 107806.00000000 1.0000 0.0000
SLay09M 3666.3900 24.8570 147.499 107806.00000000 107806.00000000 -1.0000000000000E+20 107806.00000000 1.0000 0.0000
SLay10M 3657.1700 1420.6400 2.574 129810.00000000 129580.00000000 -1.0000000000000E+20 129580.00000000 1.0000 0.0000
Syn15M04M (max) 3.6060 0.4080 8.838 4937.48000000 4937.48000000 4937.48000000 4937.48000000 0.0000 0.0000
Syn20M03M (max) 3.5180 0.3990 8.817 2646.95000000 2646.95000000 2646.95000000 2646.95000000 0.0000 0.0000
Syn20M04M (max) 4.5620 0.5250 8.690 3532.74000000 3532.74000000 3532.74000000 3532.74000000 0.0000 0.0000
Syn30M02M (max) 3.7390 0.5740 6.514 399.68300000 399.68300000 399.68300000 399.68300000 0.0000 0.0000
Syn40M03H (max) 10.5050 1.8010 5.833 395.14900000 395.14900000 395.14900000 395.14900000 0.0000 0.0000
Syn40M (max) 2.3590 0.2850 8.277 67.71330000 67.71330000 67.71330000 67.71330000 0.0000 0.0000
sssd-10-4-3 2.9870 1.0390 2.875 152710.00000000 152710.00000000 152710.00000000 152710.00000000 0.0000 0.0000
sssd-12-5-3 7.4980 15.1870 --- mstat( 7) sstat(1) 261143.00000000 --- 261143.00000000 --- 0.0000
sssd-15-6-3 104.9700 215.4670 0.487 440748.00000000 440711.00000000 440748.00000000 440711.00000000 0.0000 0.0000
uflquad-20-150 3651.8800 3604.2700 --- 630.18200000 mstat(14) sstat(3) -1.0000000000000E+20 --- 1.0000 ---
uflquad-30-100 3634.2800 3602.7000 1.009 415.04000000 2952.74000000 -1.0000000000000E+20 135.65600000 1.0000 20.7664
uflquad-40-80 3666.3400 3604.0900 --- 386.67200000 mstat(14) sstat(3) -1.0000000000000E+20 --- 1.0000 ---
Shifted Geometric Mean
(Solved)
116.63 39.61              
% Unsolved 19.15% 12.77%         

Back to top