Solver Square Comparison

Solver Square Comparison: Considers all models.

Results created on 03/08/11 11:29:01 using the PAVER Server/Performance tools available at http://www.gamsworld.eu/performance/paver

Compares all solver return outcomes (for example optimal, locally optimal, infeasible, unbounded, fail) of one solver with all return outcomes of another solver. Interrupt denotes resource or iteration limit has been reached.

Solver CPLEX is represented on the left (rows) and solver CLP on top (columns).

See the solver return definitions for return codes. Models having trace data only in one trace file are listed in the "no data" column of the other.

Input File Number	Filename
Tracefile 1:	CPLEX-0.trc
Tracefile 2:	CLP-0.trc
Solvers used :	CPLEX
	CLP
Modeltype(s)	`LP`

	CLP: optimal	CLP: locally optimal	CLP: feasible	CLP: infeasible	CLP: unbounded	CLP: fail	CLP: no data	total CPLEX
CPLEX: optimal	`108`	-	-	`1`	-	`1`	-	`110`
CPLEX: locally optimal	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
CPLEX: feasible	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
CPLEX: infeasible	-	-	-	`2`	-	`1`	-	`3`
CPLEX: unbounded	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
CPLEX: fail	-	-	-	`1`	-	`2`	-	`3`
CPLEX: no data	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
total CLP	`108`	`-`	`-`	`4`	`-`	`4`	`-`	`116`

Solver return definitions:

Outcome	Model Status	Solver Status
optimal	1 or 15	1
locally optimal	2	any
feasible	7 or 16 or 17	1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5
infeasible	4 or 5 or 19	1
unbounded	3 or 18	1
fail	all other	all other

Solver Resource Times

Models for each solver pair outcome. Listed are the solver resource times TIME(.) in seconds, as well as the ratio RATIO(./.) of resource times for the two solvers if both solved optimally.
Also listed are the objective values OBJ(.) using both solvers. The better solution found is listed in boldface. A solution is considered better, if the relative objective function difference is greater than 1.00E-05. If both solutions are less than 1e-1, we use the absolute difference.
Solver resource time ratios for a particular model are listed only if one solver has resource greater than 5.00E-02.

CPLEX: optimal -- CLP: optimal

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/CLP)	Obj (CPLEX)	Obj (CLP)
`aa01`	`1.1700`	`1.1470`	`1.020`	`55535.43638822`	`55535.43638822`
`aa03`	`0.5900`	`0.6690`	`0.882`	`49616.36363636`	`49616.36362903`
`air02`	`0.0300`	`0.0340`	`---`	`7640.00000000`	`7640.00000000`
`air06`	`0.5900`	`0.6680`	`0.883`	`49616.36363636`	`49616.36362903`
`baxter`	`0.6300`	`0.6130`	`1.028`	`56007255.67225310`	`56007255.67225310`
`car4`	`0.2800`	`0.7500`	`0.373`	`35.46037017`	`35.46037017`
`cari`	`0.0400`	`0.0620`	`0.645`	`581.89305779`	`581.89305779`
`co5`	`1.2000`	`1.6870`	`0.711`	`714469.55375105`	`714469.55375105`
`co9`	`5.3000`	`7.7550`	`0.683`	`946920.43028456`	`946920.43028456`
`cq5`	`0.7700`	`1.2210`	`0.631`	`400133.80747262`	`400133.80747262`
`cq9`	`3.2600`	`5.0650`	`0.644`	`505541.70980727`	`505541.70980727`
`crew1`	`0.1500`	`0.1320`	`1.136`	`20.55555556`	`20.55555556`
`ex3sta1`	`13.9700`	`21.8350`	`0.640`	`-63.07540325`	`-63.07540325`
`fit2d`	`0.2200`	`0.1170`	`1.880`	`-68464.29329383`	`-68464.29329383`
`fit2p`	`1.6700`	`2.7640`	`0.604`	`68464.29329383`	`68464.29329383`
`fome11`	`0.0900`	`0.0480`	`1.875`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`fome12`	`0.2000`	`0.1230`	`1.626`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`gen1`	`0.0900`	`0.3300`	`0.273`	`0.00000006`	`0.00000123`
`gen2`	`7.2200`	`3.9340`	`1.835`	`3.29279078`	`3.29279078`
`gen4`	`0.5900`	`7.3530`	`0.080`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000286`
`jendrec1`	`0.7600`	`2.2980`	`0.331`	`7028.46051135`	`7028.46051135`
`ken-11`	`0.1900`	`0.2960`	`0.642`	`-6972382262.51997100`	`-6972382262.51999000`
`ken-13`	`0.6000`	`0.8200`	`0.732`	`-1.0257394789482E+10`	`-1.0257394789483E+10`
`l30`	`8.8500`	`9.9660`	`0.888`	`0.95266134`	`0.95266141`
`lp22`	`12.9300`	`17.6930`	`0.731`	`458.94459411`	`458.94459411`
`lpl3`	`0.7000`	`0.5120`	`1.367`	`27318.00000000`	`27317.99999289`
`maros-r7`	`1.0300`	`1.5720`	`0.655`	`1497185.16647964`	`1497185.16647964`
`mod2`	`2.4300`	`4.7060`	`0.516`	`27737371.36444530`	`27737371.36444000`
`model10`	`6.2200`	`14.9160`	`0.417`	`-154599.62130064`	`-154599.62130019`
`model11`	`0.3000`	`1.0870`	`0.276`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`model5`	`1.2500`	`1.8830`	`0.664`	`-858440.72907343`	`-858440.72907343`
`model7`	`1.7700`	`1.9650`	`0.901`	`49380.08549287`	`49380.08549287`
`model9`	`0.6000`	`0.9150`	`0.656`	`-141123.09361299`	`-141123.09361336`
`nemspmm1`	`1.7900`	`2.3000`	`0.778`	`-327415.83567076`	`-327415.83567076`
`nemspmm2`	`1.8200`	`2.0740`	`0.878`	`-291794.83608908`	`-291794.83608908`
`nemswrld`	`22.2000`	`36.8160`	`0.603`	`260.30896600`	`260.30896600`
`nsir1`	`0.0700`	`0.0960`	`0.729`	`-28909033.00000000`	`-28909033.00000000`
`nsir2`	`0.1800`	`0.2780`	`0.647`	`-27175593.50000000`	`-27175593.50000010`
`nug15`	`1003.0500`	`1273.1720`	`0.788`	`1040.99404096`	`1040.99404095`
`osa-07`	`0.1300`	`0.1250`	`1.040`	`535722.51729935`	`535722.51729935`
`p010`	`0.4000`	`0.6250`	`0.640`	`1115047.91511081`	`1115047.91511082`
`p05`	`0.1600`	`0.1950`	`0.821`	`556000.27662588`	`556000.27662590`
`pcb3000`	`0.4100`	`0.5280`	`0.777`	`137416.41961282`	`137416.41961282`
`pds-06`	`0.2000`	`0.2340`	`0.855`	`27761037600.00000000`	`27761037600.00000000`
`pds-10`	`0.4500`	`0.5850`	`0.769`	`26727094976.00000000`	`26727094976.00000000`
`pilot87`	`6.7600`	`6.0440`	`1.118`	`301.71035696`	`301.71034744`
`qap15`	`1086.8500`	`1671.1610`	`0.650`	`1040.99404096`	`1040.99404096`
`r05`	`0.1800`	`0.2070`	`0.870`	`557831.85904066`	`557831.85904066`
`rat1`	`0.2000`	`0.2540`	`0.787`	`1999531.66287928`	`1999531.66287928`
`rat5`	`0.6800`	`0.7780`	`0.874`	`3083707.01043842`	`3083707.01043842`
`rosen10`	`0.2300`	`0.0760`	`3.026`	`-174215.45613870`	`-174215.45613870`
`scfxm1-2b-64`	`1.4800`	`2.5470`	`0.581`	`2877.56386371`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-64`	`0.5100`	`0.7860`	`0.649`	`2877.56386371`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-96`	`0.9200`	`1.5350`	`0.599`	`2891.70611371`	`2891.70611371`
`scrs8-2r-512`	`0.0900`	`0.0700`	`1.286`	`1074.09934157`	`1074.09934157`
`scsd8-2b-64`	`0.1700`	`0.2430`	`0.700`	`15.99866803`	`15.99866803`
`scsd8-2c-64`	`0.1800`	`0.2390`	`0.753`	`14.99923200`	`14.99923200`
`scsd8-2r-108`	`0.0600`	`0.0530`	`1.132`	`23.69999434`	`23.69999434`
`scsd8-2r-216`	`0.1500`	`0.1780`	`0.843`	`23.39998395`	`23.39998388`
`sctap1-2b-64`	`0.1900`	`0.2890`	`0.657`	`484.56000000`	`484.56000000`
`slptsk`	`0.5600`	`1.2010`	`0.466`	`29.89536602`	`29.89536602`
`south31`	`13.9900`	`16.9350`	`0.826`	`1818940197.10106000`	`1818940197.10106000`
`stocfor3`	`0.6600`	`0.7150`	`0.923`	`-39976.78394365`	`-39976.78394365`
`testbig`	`0.1500`	`0.3800`	`0.395`	`-60.42296073`	`-60.42296073`
`ulevimin`	`9.2400`	`24.5030`	`0.377`	`-5191101861.43197000`	`-5191101861.43197000`
`wood1p`	`0.0200`	`0.0500`	`0.400`	`1.44290241`	`1.44290241`
`world`	`2.1500`	`4.0640`	`0.529`	`40364873.11411920`	`40364873.11417420`
`bas1lp`	`4.4000`	`0.8850`	`4.972`	`363.00000000`	`363.00000000`
`cre-b`	`1.4200`	`2.2780`	`0.623`	`23129639.88683240`	`23129639.88683230`
`cre-d`	`0.6400`	`1.4730`	`0.434`	`24454969.76454920`	`24454969.76454920`
`fome13`	`0.4400`	`0.3010`	`1.462`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`fome20`	`2.6400`	`2.6300`	`1.004`	`23821658640.00000000`	`23821658640.00000000`
`fome21`	`5.3000`	`7.4650`	`0.710`	`47346318912.00000000`	`47346318912.00000000`
`ken-18`	`4.0900`	`7.1440`	`0.573`	`-5.2217025287397E+10`	`-5.2217025287397E+10`
`kl02`	`0.1900`	`0.3450`	`0.551`	`215.25000000`	`215.25000000`
`nemsemm2`	`0.3000`	`0.4710`	`0.637`	`581079.57090468`	`581079.57090469`
`nsct1`	`0.3200`	`0.4770`	`0.671`	`-38922436.00000000`	`-38922436.00000000`
`nsct2`	`0.6300`	`1.1340`	`0.556`	`-37175082.00000000`	`-37175082.00000040`
`osa-14`	`0.2800`	`0.4550`	`0.615`	`1106462.84473626`	`1106462.84473625`
`osa-30`	`0.6900`	`0.8570`	`0.805`	`2142139.87320976`	`2142139.87320979`
`pds-20`	`2.6100`	`2.6380`	`0.989`	`23821658640.00000000`	`23821658640.00000000`
`pds-30`	`6.3100`	`6.9160`	`0.912`	`21385445736.00000000`	`21385445736.00000000`
`pds-40`	`8.7100`	`14.8210`	`0.588`	`18855198824.00000000`	`18855198824.00000000`
`pds-50`	`15.2300`	`23.3840`	`0.651`	`16603525724.00000000`	`16603525724.00000000`
`pds-60`	`17.2900`	`37.5860`	`0.460`	`14265904407.00000000`	`14265904407.00000000`
`rail507`	`4.1600`	`5.7860`	`0.719`	`172.14556668`	`172.14556668`
`rail516`	`1.4100`	`1.5940`	`0.885`	`182.00000000`	`182.00000000`
`rail582`	`1.9400`	`5.3580`	`0.362`	`209.71223296`	`209.71223296`
`rat7a`	`5.1700`	`4.2570`	`1.214`	`2074371.41572829`	`2074371.41572828`
`rlfddd`	`0.2100`	`0.1610`	`1.304`	`-13.00000000`	`-13.00000000`
`rlfdual`	`3.7400`	`22.0990`	`0.169`	`-1.00000000`	`-1.00000000`
`route`	`0.1900`	`0.1590`	`1.195`	`5941.65027667`	`5941.65027667`
`scsd8-2r-432`	`0.3500`	`0.6120`	`0.572`	`25.79996959`	`25.79996945`
`t0331-4l`	`9.6000`	`8.7820`	`1.093`	`29730.03335194`	`29730.03335194`
`us04`	`0.2400`	`0.1160`	`2.069`	`17731.66666667`	`17731.66666667`
`watson_1`	`10.5200`	`77.2170`	`0.136`	`-1609.28079574`	`-1609.28069437`
`dbic1`	`39.1600`	`193.5450`	`0.202`	`-9768973.00000000`	`-9768973.00000001`
`dbir1`	`0.5800`	`0.7660`	`0.757`	`-8106707.00000000`	`-8106707.00000000`
`dbir2`	`0.9500`	`2.1360`	`0.445`	`-6116916.50000000`	`-6116916.50000043`
`nemsemm1`	`0.7300`	`1.0380`	`0.703`	`512959.60078798`	`512959.60078798`
`nw14`	`0.6600`	`2.1830`	`0.302`	`61844.00000000`	`61844.00000000`
`osa-60`	`1.9500`	`3.0580`	`0.638`	`4044072.50315743`	`4044072.50315747`
`pds-100`	`41.8700`	`98.7860`	`0.424`	`10928229968.00000000`	`10928229968.00000000`
`pds-70`	`26.1600`	`52.7540`	`0.496`	`12241162812.00000000`	`12241162812.00000000`
`pds-80`	`38.3000`	`73.6320`	`0.520`	`11469077462.00000000`	`11469077462.00000000`
`pds-90`	`39.0900`	`90.1270`	`0.434`	`11087561635.00000000`	`11087561635.00000000`
`rail2586`	`882.0100`	`1547.3460`	`0.570`	`935.92182057`	`935.92182057`
`self`	`17.7300`	`3.7690`	`4.704`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`

CPLEX: optimal -- CLP: infeasible

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/CLP)	Obj (CPLEX)	Status (CLP)
`rlfprim`	`0.5200`	`2.9410`	---	`1.00000000`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`

CPLEX: optimal -- CLP: fail

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/CLP)	Obj (CPLEX)	Status (CLP)
`rail4284`	`1875.6000`	`3600.4760`	---	`1054.05449127`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`

CPLEX: infeasible -- CLP: infeasible

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/CLP)	Status (CPLEX)	Status (CLP)
`bgindy`	`0.0700`	`0.2320`	---	`mstat( 4)sstat( 1)`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`
`gosh`	`0.8800`	`50.7570`	---	`mstat( 4)sstat( 1)`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`

CPLEX: infeasible -- CLP: fail

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/CLP)	Status (CPLEX)	Status (CLP)
`lpl1`	`51.0800`	`3600.1990`	---	`mstat( 4)sstat( 1)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`

CPLEX: fail -- CLP: infeasible

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/CLP)	Status (CPLEX)	Status (CLP)
`sgpf5y6`	`3600.5800`	`161.3350`	---	`mstat( 6)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`

CPLEX: fail -- CLP: fail

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/CLP)	Status (CPLEX)	Status (CLP)
`nug20`	`3599.0000`	`3600.0120`	---	`mstat( 6)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`nug30`	`3654.5100`	`3601.2970`	---	`mstat( 6)sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`

CPLEX: optimal:

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Obj (CPLEX)
`aa01`	`1.1700`	`55535.43638822`
`aa03`	`0.5900`	`49616.36363636`
`air02`	`0.0300`	`7640.00000000`
`air06`	`0.5900`	`49616.36363636`
`baxter`	`0.6300`	`56007255.67225310`
`car4`	`0.2800`	`35.46037017`
`cari`	`0.0400`	`581.89305779`
`co5`	`1.2000`	`714469.55375105`
`co9`	`5.3000`	`946920.43028456`
`cq5`	`0.7700`	`400133.80747262`
`cq9`	`3.2600`	`505541.70980727`
`crew1`	`0.1500`	`20.55555556`
`ex3sta1`	`13.9700`	`-63.07540325`
`fit2d`	`0.2200`	`-68464.29329383`
`fit2p`	`1.6700`	`68464.29329383`
`fome11`	`0.0900`	`0.00000000`
`fome12`	`0.2000`	`0.00000000`
`gen1`	`0.0900`	`0.00000006`
`gen2`	`7.2200`	`3.29279078`
`gen4`	`0.5900`	`0.00000000`
`jendrec1`	`0.7600`	`7028.46051135`
`ken-11`	`0.1900`	`-6972382262.51997100`
`ken-13`	`0.6000`	`-1.0257394789482E+10`
`l30`	`8.8500`	`0.95266134`
`lp22`	`12.9300`	`458.94459411`
`lpl3`	`0.7000`	`27318.00000000`
`maros-r7`	`1.0300`	`1497185.16647964`
`mod2`	`2.4300`	`27737371.36444530`
`model10`	`6.2200`	`-154599.62130064`
`model11`	`0.3000`	`0.00000000`
`model5`	`1.2500`	`-858440.72907343`
`model7`	`1.7700`	`49380.08549287`
`model9`	`0.6000`	`-141123.09361299`
`nemspmm1`	`1.7900`	`-327415.83567076`
`nemspmm2`	`1.8200`	`-291794.83608908`
`nemswrld`	`22.2000`	`260.30896600`
`nsir1`	`0.0700`	`-28909033.00000000`
`nsir2`	`0.1800`	`-27175593.50000000`
`nug15`	`1003.0500`	`1040.99404096`
`osa-07`	`0.1300`	`535722.51729935`
`p010`	`0.4000`	`1115047.91511081`
`p05`	`0.1600`	`556000.27662588`
`pcb3000`	`0.4100`	`137416.41961282`
`pds-06`	`0.2000`	`27761037600.00000000`
`pds-10`	`0.4500`	`26727094976.00000000`
`pilot87`	`6.7600`	`301.71035696`
`qap15`	`1086.8500`	`1040.99404096`
`r05`	`0.1800`	`557831.85904066`
`rat1`	`0.2000`	`1999531.66287928`
`rat5`	`0.6800`	`3083707.01043842`
`rosen10`	`0.2300`	`-174215.45613870`
`scfxm1-2b-64`	`1.4800`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-64`	`0.5100`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-96`	`0.9200`	`2891.70611371`
`scrs8-2r-512`	`0.0900`	`1074.09934157`
`scsd8-2b-64`	`0.1700`	`15.99866803`
`scsd8-2c-64`	`0.1800`	`14.99923200`
`scsd8-2r-108`	`0.0600`	`23.69999434`
`scsd8-2r-216`	`0.1500`	`23.39998395`
`sctap1-2b-64`	`0.1900`	`484.56000000`
`slptsk`	`0.5600`	`29.89536602`
`south31`	`13.9900`	`1818940197.10106000`
`stocfor3`	`0.6600`	`-39976.78394365`
`testbig`	`0.1500`	`-60.42296073`
`ulevimin`	`9.2400`	`-5191101861.43197000`
`wood1p`	`0.0200`	`1.44290241`
`world`	`2.1500`	`40364873.11411920`
`bas1lp`	`4.4000`	`363.00000000`
`cre-b`	`1.4200`	`23129639.88683240`
`cre-d`	`0.6400`	`24454969.76454920`
`fome13`	`0.4400`	`0.00000000`
`fome20`	`2.6400`	`23821658640.00000000`
`fome21`	`5.3000`	`47346318912.00000000`
`ken-18`	`4.0900`	`-5.2217025287397E+10`
`kl02`	`0.1900`	`215.25000000`
`nemsemm2`	`0.3000`	`581079.57090468`
`nsct1`	`0.3200`	`-38922436.00000000`
`nsct2`	`0.6300`	`-37175082.00000000`
`osa-14`	`0.2800`	`1106462.84473626`
`osa-30`	`0.6900`	`2142139.87320976`
`pds-20`	`2.6100`	`23821658640.00000000`
`pds-30`	`6.3100`	`21385445736.00000000`
`pds-40`	`8.7100`	`18855198824.00000000`
`pds-50`	`15.2300`	`16603525724.00000000`
`pds-60`	`17.2900`	`14265904407.00000000`
`rail507`	`4.1600`	`172.14556668`
`rail516`	`1.4100`	`182.00000000`
`rail582`	`1.9400`	`209.71223296`
`rat7a`	`5.1700`	`2074371.41572829`
`rlfddd`	`0.2100`	`-13.00000000`
`rlfdual`	`3.7400`	`-1.00000000`
`rlfprim`	`0.5200`	`1.00000000`
`route`	`0.1900`	`5941.65027667`
`scsd8-2r-432`	`0.3500`	`25.79996959`
`t0331-4l`	`9.6000`	`29730.03335194`
`us04`	`0.2400`	`17731.66666667`
`watson_1`	`10.5200`	`-1609.28079574`
`dbic1`	`39.1600`	`-9768973.00000000`
`dbir1`	`0.5800`	`-8106707.00000000`
`dbir2`	`0.9500`	`-6116916.50000000`
`nemsemm1`	`0.7300`	`512959.60078798`
`nw14`	`0.6600`	`61844.00000000`
`osa-60`	`1.9500`	`4044072.50315743`
`pds-100`	`41.8700`	`10928229968.00000000`
`pds-70`	`26.1600`	`12241162812.00000000`
`pds-80`	`38.3000`	`11469077462.00000000`
`pds-90`	`39.0900`	`11087561635.00000000`
`rail2586`	`882.0100`	`935.92182057`
`rail4284`	`1875.6000`	`1054.05449127`
`self`	`17.7300`	`0.00000000`

CPLEX: infeasible:

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Status (CPLEX)
`bgindy`	`--`	`mstat( 4) sstat( 1)`
`gosh`	`--`	`mstat( 4) sstat( 1)`
`lpl1`	`--`	`mstat( 4) sstat( 1)`

CPLEX: fail:

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Status (CPLEX)
`nug20`	`--`	`mstat( 6) sstat( 3)`
`sgpf5y6`	`--`	`mstat( 6) sstat( 3)`
`nug30`	`--`	`mstat( 6) sstat( 3)`

CLP: optimal:

Modelname	Time (CLP)	Obj (CLP)
`aa01`	`1.1470`	`55535.43638822`
`aa03`	`0.6690`	`49616.36362903`
`air02`	`0.0340`	`7640.00000000`
`air06`	`0.6680`	`49616.36362903`
`baxter`	`0.6130`	`56007255.67225310`
`car4`	`0.7500`	`35.46037017`
`cari`	`0.0620`	`581.89305779`
`co5`	`1.6870`	`714469.55375105`
`co9`	`7.7550`	`946920.43028456`
`cq5`	`1.2210`	`400133.80747262`
`cq9`	`5.0650`	`505541.70980727`
`crew1`	`0.1320`	`20.55555556`
`ex3sta1`	`21.8350`	`-63.07540325`
`fit2d`	`0.1170`	`-68464.29329383`
`fit2p`	`2.7640`	`68464.29329383`
`fome11`	`0.0480`	`0.00000000`
`fome12`	`0.1230`	`0.00000000`
`gen1`	`0.3300`	`0.00000123`
`gen2`	`3.9340`	`3.29279078`
`gen4`	`7.3530`	`0.00000286`
`jendrec1`	`2.2980`	`7028.46051135`
`ken-11`	`0.2960`	`-6972382262.51999000`
`ken-13`	`0.8200`	`-1.0257394789483E+10`
`l30`	`9.9660`	`0.95266141`
`lp22`	`17.6930`	`458.94459411`
`lpl3`	`0.5120`	`27317.99999289`
`maros-r7`	`1.5720`	`1497185.16647964`
`mod2`	`4.7060`	`27737371.36444000`
`model10`	`14.9160`	`-154599.62130019`
`model11`	`1.0870`	`0.00000000`
`model5`	`1.8830`	`-858440.72907343`
`model7`	`1.9650`	`49380.08549287`
`model9`	`0.9150`	`-141123.09361336`
`nemspmm1`	`2.3000`	`-327415.83567076`
`nemspmm2`	`2.0740`	`-291794.83608908`
`nemswrld`	`36.8160`	`260.30896600`
`nsir1`	`0.0960`	`-28909033.00000000`
`nsir2`	`0.2780`	`-27175593.50000010`
`nug15`	`1273.1720`	`1040.99404095`
`osa-07`	`0.1250`	`535722.51729935`
`p010`	`0.6250`	`1115047.91511082`
`p05`	`0.1950`	`556000.27662590`
`pcb3000`	`0.5280`	`137416.41961282`
`pds-06`	`0.2340`	`27761037600.00000000`
`pds-10`	`0.5850`	`26727094976.00000000`
`pilot87`	`6.0440`	`301.71034744`
`qap15`	`1671.1610`	`1040.99404096`
`r05`	`0.2070`	`557831.85904066`
`rat1`	`0.2540`	`1999531.66287928`
`rat5`	`0.7780`	`3083707.01043842`
`rosen10`	`0.0760`	`-174215.45613870`
`scfxm1-2b-64`	`2.5470`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-64`	`0.7860`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-96`	`1.5350`	`2891.70611371`
`scrs8-2r-512`	`0.0700`	`1074.09934157`
`scsd8-2b-64`	`0.2430`	`15.99866803`
`scsd8-2c-64`	`0.2390`	`14.99923200`
`scsd8-2r-108`	`0.0530`	`23.69999434`
`scsd8-2r-216`	`0.1780`	`23.39998388`
`sctap1-2b-64`	`0.2890`	`484.56000000`
`slptsk`	`1.2010`	`29.89536602`
`south31`	`16.9350`	`1818940197.10106000`
`stocfor3`	`0.7150`	`-39976.78394365`
`testbig`	`0.3800`	`-60.42296073`
`ulevimin`	`24.5030`	`-5191101861.43197000`
`wood1p`	`0.0500`	`1.44290241`
`world`	`4.0640`	`40364873.11417420`
`bas1lp`	`0.8850`	`363.00000000`
`cre-b`	`2.2780`	`23129639.88683230`
`cre-d`	`1.4730`	`24454969.76454920`
`fome13`	`0.3010`	`0.00000000`
`fome20`	`2.6300`	`23821658640.00000000`
`fome21`	`7.4650`	`47346318912.00000000`
`ken-18`	`7.1440`	`-5.2217025287397E+10`
`kl02`	`0.3450`	`215.25000000`
`nemsemm2`	`0.4710`	`581079.57090469`
`nsct1`	`0.4770`	`-38922436.00000000`
`nsct2`	`1.1340`	`-37175082.00000040`
`osa-14`	`0.4550`	`1106462.84473625`
`osa-30`	`0.8570`	`2142139.87320979`
`pds-20`	`2.6380`	`23821658640.00000000`
`pds-30`	`6.9160`	`21385445736.00000000`
`pds-40`	`14.8210`	`18855198824.00000000`
`pds-50`	`23.3840`	`16603525724.00000000`
`pds-60`	`37.5860`	`14265904407.00000000`
`rail507`	`5.7860`	`172.14556668`
`rail516`	`1.5940`	`182.00000000`
`rail582`	`5.3580`	`209.71223296`
`rat7a`	`4.2570`	`2074371.41572828`
`rlfddd`	`0.1610`	`-13.00000000`
`rlfdual`	`22.0990`	`-1.00000000`
`route`	`0.1590`	`5941.65027667`
`scsd8-2r-432`	`0.6120`	`25.79996945`
`t0331-4l`	`8.7820`	`29730.03335194`
`us04`	`0.1160`	`17731.66666667`
`watson_1`	`77.2170`	`-1609.28069437`
`dbic1`	`193.5450`	`-9768973.00000001`
`dbir1`	`0.7660`	`-8106707.00000000`
`dbir2`	`2.1360`	`-6116916.50000043`
`nemsemm1`	`1.0380`	`512959.60078798`
`nw14`	`2.1830`	`61844.00000000`
`osa-60`	`3.0580`	`4044072.50315747`
`pds-100`	`98.7860`	`10928229968.00000000`
`pds-70`	`52.7540`	`12241162812.00000000`
`pds-80`	`73.6320`	`11469077462.00000000`
`pds-90`	`90.1270`	`11087561635.00000000`
`rail2586`	`1547.3460`	`935.92182057`
`self`	`3.7690`	`0.00000000`

CLP: infeasible:

Modelname	Time (CLP)	Status (CLP)
`bgindy`	`--`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`
`gosh`	`--`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`
`rlfprim`	`--`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`
`sgpf5y6`	`--`	`mstat(19)sstat( 1)`

CLP: fail:

Modelname	Time (CLP)	Status (CLP)
`lpl1`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`nug20`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`nug30`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`
`rail4284`	`--`	`mstat(14)sstat( 3)`

CPLEX: all -- CLP: all

A "(max)" behind a model names indicates that this model is a maximization model.

Modelname	Time (CPLEX)	Time (CLP)	Ratio (CPLEX/ CLP)	Obj (CPLEX)	Obj (CLP)
`aa01`	`1.1700`	`1.1470`	`1.020`	`55535.43638822`	`55535.43638822`
`aa03`	`0.5900`	`0.6690`	`0.882`	`49616.36363636`	`49616.36362903`
`air02`	`0.0300`	`0.0340`	`---`	`7640.00000000`	`7640.00000000`
`air06`	`0.5900`	`0.6680`	`0.883`	`49616.36363636`	`49616.36362903`
`baxter`	`0.6300`	`0.6130`	`1.028`	`56007255.67225310`	`56007255.67225310`
`bgindy`	`0.0700`	`0.2320`	---	`mstat( 4) sstat(1)`	`mstat(19) sstat(1)`
`car4`	`0.2800`	`0.7500`	`0.373`	`35.46037017`	`35.46037017`
`cari`	`0.0400`	`0.0620`	`0.645`	`581.89305779`	`581.89305779`
`co5`	`1.2000`	`1.6870`	`0.711`	`714469.55375105`	`714469.55375105`
`co9`	`5.3000`	`7.7550`	`0.683`	`946920.43028456`	`946920.43028456`
`cq5`	`0.7700`	`1.2210`	`0.631`	`400133.80747262`	`400133.80747262`
`cq9`	`3.2600`	`5.0650`	`0.644`	`505541.70980727`	`505541.70980727`
`crew1`	`0.1500`	`0.1320`	`1.136`	`20.55555556`	`20.55555556`
`ex3sta1`	`13.9700`	`21.8350`	`0.640`	`-63.07540325`	`-63.07540325`
`fit2d`	`0.2200`	`0.1170`	`1.880`	`-68464.29329383`	`-68464.29329383`
`fit2p`	`1.6700`	`2.7640`	`0.604`	`68464.29329383`	`68464.29329383`
`fome11`	`0.0900`	`0.0480`	`1.875`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`fome12`	`0.2000`	`0.1230`	`1.626`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`gen1`	`0.0900`	`0.3300`	`0.273`	`0.00000006`	`0.00000123`
`gen2`	`7.2200`	`3.9340`	`1.835`	`3.29279078`	`3.29279078`
`gen4`	`0.5900`	`7.3530`	`0.080`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000286`
`gosh`	`0.8800`	`50.7570`	---	`mstat( 4) sstat(1)`	`mstat(19) sstat(1)`
`jendrec1`	`0.7600`	`2.2980`	`0.331`	`7028.46051135`	`7028.46051135`
`ken-11`	`0.1900`	`0.2960`	`0.642`	`-6972382262.51997100`	`-6972382262.51999000`
`ken-13`	`0.6000`	`0.8200`	`0.732`	`-1.0257394789482E+10`	`-1.0257394789483E+10`
`l30`	`8.8500`	`9.9660`	`0.888`	`0.95266134`	`0.95266141`
`lp22`	`12.9300`	`17.6930`	`0.731`	`458.94459411`	`458.94459411`
`lpl3`	`0.7000`	`0.5120`	`1.367`	`27318.00000000`	`27317.99999289`
`maros-r7`	`1.0300`	`1.5720`	`0.655`	`1497185.16647964`	`1497185.16647964`
`mod2`	`2.4300`	`4.7060`	`0.516`	`27737371.36444530`	`27737371.36444000`
`model10`	`6.2200`	`14.9160`	`0.417`	`-154599.62130064`	`-154599.62130019`
`model11`	`0.3000`	`1.0870`	`0.276`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`model5`	`1.2500`	`1.8830`	`0.664`	`-858440.72907343`	`-858440.72907343`
`model7`	`1.7700`	`1.9650`	`0.901`	`49380.08549287`	`49380.08549287`
`model9`	`0.6000`	`0.9150`	`0.656`	`-141123.09361299`	`-141123.09361336`
`nemspmm1`	`1.7900`	`2.3000`	`0.778`	`-327415.83567076`	`-327415.83567076`
`nemspmm2`	`1.8200`	`2.0740`	`0.878`	`-291794.83608908`	`-291794.83608908`
`nemswrld`	`22.2000`	`36.8160`	`0.603`	`260.30896600`	`260.30896600`
`nsir1`	`0.0700`	`0.0960`	`0.729`	`-28909033.00000000`	`-28909033.00000000`
`nsir2`	`0.1800`	`0.2780`	`0.647`	`-27175593.50000000`	`-27175593.50000010`
`nug15`	`1003.0500`	`1273.1720`	`0.788`	`1040.99404096`	`1040.99404095`
`osa-07`	`0.1300`	`0.1250`	`1.040`	`535722.51729935`	`535722.51729935`
`p010`	`0.4000`	`0.6250`	`0.640`	`1115047.91511081`	`1115047.91511082`
`p05`	`0.1600`	`0.1950`	`0.821`	`556000.27662588`	`556000.27662590`
`pcb3000`	`0.4100`	`0.5280`	`0.777`	`137416.41961282`	`137416.41961282`
`pds-06`	`0.2000`	`0.2340`	`0.855`	`27761037600.00000000`	`27761037600.00000000`
`pds-10`	`0.4500`	`0.5850`	`0.769`	`26727094976.00000000`	`26727094976.00000000`
`pilot87`	`6.7600`	`6.0440`	`1.118`	`301.71035696`	`301.71034744`
`qap15`	`1086.8500`	`1671.1610`	`0.650`	`1040.99404096`	`1040.99404096`
`r05`	`0.1800`	`0.2070`	`0.870`	`557831.85904066`	`557831.85904066`
`rat1`	`0.2000`	`0.2540`	`0.787`	`1999531.66287928`	`1999531.66287928`
`rat5`	`0.6800`	`0.7780`	`0.874`	`3083707.01043842`	`3083707.01043842`
`rosen10`	`0.2300`	`0.0760`	`3.026`	`-174215.45613870`	`-174215.45613870`
`scfxm1-2b-64`	`1.4800`	`2.5470`	`0.581`	`2877.56386371`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-64`	`0.5100`	`0.7860`	`0.649`	`2877.56386371`	`2877.56386371`
`scfxm1-2r-96`	`0.9200`	`1.5350`	`0.599`	`2891.70611371`	`2891.70611371`
`scrs8-2r-512`	`0.0900`	`0.0700`	`1.286`	`1074.09934157`	`1074.09934157`
`scsd8-2b-64`	`0.1700`	`0.2430`	`0.700`	`15.99866803`	`15.99866803`
`scsd8-2c-64`	`0.1800`	`0.2390`	`0.753`	`14.99923200`	`14.99923200`
`scsd8-2r-108`	`0.0600`	`0.0530`	`1.132`	`23.69999434`	`23.69999434`
`scsd8-2r-216`	`0.1500`	`0.1780`	`0.843`	`23.39998395`	`23.39998388`
`sctap1-2b-64`	`0.1900`	`0.2890`	`0.657`	`484.56000000`	`484.56000000`
`slptsk`	`0.5600`	`1.2010`	`0.466`	`29.89536602`	`29.89536602`
`south31`	`13.9900`	`16.9350`	`0.826`	`1818940197.10106000`	`1818940197.10106000`
`stocfor3`	`0.6600`	`0.7150`	`0.923`	`-39976.78394365`	`-39976.78394365`
`testbig`	`0.1500`	`0.3800`	`0.395`	`-60.42296073`	`-60.42296073`
`ulevimin`	`9.2400`	`24.5030`	`0.377`	`-5191101861.43197000`	`-5191101861.43197000`
`wood1p`	`0.0200`	`0.0500`	`0.400`	`1.44290241`	`1.44290241`
`world`	`2.1500`	`4.0640`	`0.529`	`40364873.11411920`	`40364873.11417420`
`bas1lp`	`4.4000`	`0.8850`	`4.972`	`363.00000000`	`363.00000000`
`cre-b`	`1.4200`	`2.2780`	`0.623`	`23129639.88683240`	`23129639.88683230`
`cre-d`	`0.6400`	`1.4730`	`0.434`	`24454969.76454920`	`24454969.76454920`
`fome13`	`0.4400`	`0.3010`	`1.462`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`
`fome20`	`2.6400`	`2.6300`	`1.004`	`23821658640.00000000`	`23821658640.00000000`
`fome21`	`5.3000`	`7.4650`	`0.710`	`47346318912.00000000`	`47346318912.00000000`
`ken-18`	`4.0900`	`7.1440`	`0.573`	`-5.2217025287397E+10`	`-5.2217025287397E+10`
`kl02`	`0.1900`	`0.3450`	`0.551`	`215.25000000`	`215.25000000`
`lpl1`	`51.0800`	`3600.1990`	---	`mstat( 4) sstat(1)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`
`nemsemm2`	`0.3000`	`0.4710`	`0.637`	`581079.57090468`	`581079.57090469`
`nsct1`	`0.3200`	`0.4770`	`0.671`	`-38922436.00000000`	`-38922436.00000000`
`nsct2`	`0.6300`	`1.1340`	`0.556`	`-37175082.00000000`	`-37175082.00000040`
`nug20`	`3599.0000`	`3600.0120`	---	`mstat( 6) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`
`osa-14`	`0.2800`	`0.4550`	`0.615`	`1106462.84473626`	`1106462.84473625`
`osa-30`	`0.6900`	`0.8570`	`0.805`	`2142139.87320976`	`2142139.87320979`
`pds-20`	`2.6100`	`2.6380`	`0.989`	`23821658640.00000000`	`23821658640.00000000`
`pds-30`	`6.3100`	`6.9160`	`0.912`	`21385445736.00000000`	`21385445736.00000000`
`pds-40`	`8.7100`	`14.8210`	`0.588`	`18855198824.00000000`	`18855198824.00000000`
`pds-50`	`15.2300`	`23.3840`	`0.651`	`16603525724.00000000`	`16603525724.00000000`
`pds-60`	`17.2900`	`37.5860`	`0.460`	`14265904407.00000000`	`14265904407.00000000`
`rail507`	`4.1600`	`5.7860`	`0.719`	`172.14556668`	`172.14556668`
`rail516`	`1.4100`	`1.5940`	`0.885`	`182.00000000`	`182.00000000`
`rail582`	`1.9400`	`5.3580`	`0.362`	`209.71223296`	`209.71223296`
`rat7a`	`5.1700`	`4.2570`	`1.214`	`2074371.41572829`	`2074371.41572828`
`rlfddd`	`0.2100`	`0.1610`	`1.304`	`-13.00000000`	`-13.00000000`
`rlfdual`	`3.7400`	`22.0990`	`0.169`	`-1.00000000`	`-1.00000000`
`rlfprim`	`0.5200`	`2.9410`	---	`1.00000000`	`mstat(19) sstat(1)`
`route`	`0.1900`	`0.1590`	`1.195`	`5941.65027667`	`5941.65027667`
`scsd8-2r-432`	`0.3500`	`0.6120`	`0.572`	`25.79996959`	`25.79996945`
`sgpf5y6`	`3600.5800`	`161.3350`	---	`mstat( 6) sstat(3)`	`mstat(19) sstat(1)`
`t0331-4l`	`9.6000`	`8.7820`	`1.093`	`29730.03335194`	`29730.03335194`
`us04`	`0.2400`	`0.1160`	`2.069`	`17731.66666667`	`17731.66666667`
`watson_1`	`10.5200`	`77.2170`	`0.136`	`-1609.28079574`	`-1609.28069437`
`dbic1`	`39.1600`	`193.5450`	`0.202`	`-9768973.00000000`	`-9768973.00000001`
`dbir1`	`0.5800`	`0.7660`	`0.757`	`-8106707.00000000`	`-8106707.00000000`
`dbir2`	`0.9500`	`2.1360`	`0.445`	`-6116916.50000000`	`-6116916.50000043`
`nemsemm1`	`0.7300`	`1.0380`	`0.703`	`512959.60078798`	`512959.60078798`
`nug30`	`3654.5100`	`3601.2970`	---	`mstat( 6) sstat(3)`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`
`nw14`	`0.6600`	`2.1830`	`0.302`	`61844.00000000`	`61844.00000000`
`osa-60`	`1.9500`	`3.0580`	`0.638`	`4044072.50315743`	`4044072.50315747`
`pds-100`	`41.8700`	`98.7860`	`0.424`	`10928229968.00000000`	`10928229968.00000000`
`pds-70`	`26.1600`	`52.7540`	`0.496`	`12241162812.00000000`	`12241162812.00000000`
`pds-80`	`38.3000`	`73.6320`	`0.520`	`11469077462.00000000`	`11469077462.00000000`
`pds-90`	`39.0900`	`90.1270`	`0.434`	`11087561635.00000000`	`11087561635.00000000`
`rail2586`	`882.0100`	`1547.3460`	`0.570`	`935.92182057`	`935.92182057`
`rail4284`	`1875.6000`	`3600.4760`	---	`1054.05449127`	`mstat(14) sstat(3)`
`self`	`17.7300`	`3.7690`	`4.704`	`0.00000000`	`0.00000000`