Solver Square Comparison

Solver Square Comparison: Considers all models.

Date / Time: 09/29/08 16:04:27

Solver comparison utility.

Compares all solver return outcomes (for example optimal, locally optimal, infeasible, unbounded, fail) of one solver with all return outcomes of another solver. Interrupt denotes resource or iteration limit has been reached. Solver LINDOGLOBAL is represented on the left (rows) and solver SBB on top (columns). See the solver return definitions for return codes.

Models having trace data only in one trace file are listed in the "no data" column of the other.

Tracefile 1 :	`LINDOGLOBAL-1.trc.canall`
Tracefile 2 :	`SBB-1.trc.canall`
Solvers used :	`LINDOGLOBAL`
	`SBB`
Modeltype(s)	`MINLP`

	SBB: optimal	SBB: feasible	SBB: infeasible	SBB: unbounded	SBB: fail	SBB: no data	total LINDOGLOBAL
LINDOGLOBAL: optimal	-	`56`	`5`	-	-	-	`61`
LINDOGLOBAL: feasible	-	`57`	`2`	-	`3`	-	`62`
LINDOGLOBAL: infeasible	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
LINDOGLOBAL: unbounded	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
LINDOGLOBAL: fail	-	`3`	`1`	-	`4`	-	`8`
LINDOGLOBAL: no data	-	-	-	-	-	-	`-`
total SBB	`-`	`116`	`8`	`-`	`7`	`-`	`131`

Solver return definitions:

Outcome	Model Status	Solver Status
optimal	1 or 15	1
locally optimal	2	any
feasible	8 or 16	1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5
infeasible	4 or 5 or 10 or 19	1
unbounded	3 or 18	1
fail	all other	all other

Solver Resource Times

Models for each solver pair outcome. Listed are the solver resource times TIME(.) in seconds, as well as the ratio RATIO(./.) of resource times for the two solvers if both solved optimally.
Also listed are the objective values OBJ(.) using both solvers. The better solution found is listed in boldface. A solution is considered better, if the relative objective function difference is greater than 1.00E-05. If both solutions are less than 1e-1, we use the absolute difference.
Solver resource time ratios for a particular model are listed only if one solver has resource greater than 5.00E-02.

LINDOGLOBAL: optimal -- SBB: feasible Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)	Obj (SBB)
`alan`	`0.0250`	`0.2080`	`0.120`	`2.92500000`	`2.92500000`
`batch`	`2.2470`	`0.4870`	`4.614`	`285506.50824681`	`285506.50815158`
`batchdes`	`0.1760`	`0.2320`	`0.759`	`167427.65711475`	`167427.65711470`
`ex1222`	`0.0060`	`0.2370`	`0.025`	`1.07654326`	`1.07654308`
`ex1223`	`0.0970`	`0.2150`	`0.451`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223a`	`0.0220`	`0.1630`	`0.135`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223b`	`0.0730`	`0.2150`	`0.340`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`ex1225`	`0.0160`	`0.2000`	`0.080`	`31.00000000`	`31.00000000`
`ex1252`	`29.3540`	`2.4880`	`11.798`	`128893.74106485`	`128893.74101350`
`ex1263`	`43.6500`	`21.5240`	`2.028`	`19.60000002`	`19.60000000`
`ex1263a`	`2.2210`	`6.6890`	`0.332`	`19.60000000`	`20.00000000`
`ex1264`	`17.8680`	`7.8670`	`2.271`	`8.60000001`	`8.60000000`
`ex1265`	`30.7530`	`5.9840`	`5.139`	`10.30000000`	`10.30000000`
`ex1265a`	`1.1460`	`0.3330`	`3.441`	`10.30000000`	`15.10000000`
`ex1266`	`3.9550`	`11.4230`	`0.346`	`16.30000000`	`16.30000000`
`ex1266a`	`4.1190`	`1.1210`	`3.674`	`16.30000000`	`16.30000000`
`ex3pb`	`0.3510`	`0.5400`	`0.650`	`68.00974405`	`68.00974405`
`ex4`	`40.4410`	`3.4150`	`11.842`	`-8.06413616`	`-8.06413616`
`fac2`	`13.1530`	`0.6750`	`19.486`	`331837498.26956600`	`331837498.17676900`
`fac3`	`53.8090`	`0.5570`	`96.605`	`31982309.84800090`	`31982309.84800000`
`gastrans`	`0.8140`	`1.2390`	`0.657`	`89.08584001`	`89.08584000`
`gear`	`0.0390`	`3.3260`	`0.012`	`0.00000067`	`0.00000000`
`gear2`	`0.0430`	`75.2620`	`0.001`	`0.00000062`	`0.00000000`
`gear3`	`0.0530`	`3.3710`	`0.016`	`0.00000003`	`0.00000000`
`gear4`	`153.6720`	`190.3330`	`0.807`	`1.64342847`	`1.64342847`
`m3`	`1.6960`	`1.1120`	`1.525`	`37.79999992`	`37.80000000`
`nvs01`	`0.0510`	`0.3110`	`0.164`	`12.46966882`	`12.46966882`
`nvs03`	`0.0270`	`0.2040`	`0.132`	`16.00000000`	`16.00000000`
`nvs04`	`0.0300`	`0.1740`	`0.172`	`0.72000000`	`0.72000000`
`nvs06`	`0.0250`	`0.1750`	`0.143`	`1.77031250`	`1.77031250`
`nvs07`	`0.0570`	`0.1980`	`0.288`	`4.00000000`	`4.00000000`
`nvs08`	`0.0880`	`0.1800`	`0.489`	`23.44972735`	`23.44972735`
`oaer`	`0.0190`	`0.1750`	`0.109`	`-1.92309851`	`-1.92309854`
`oil2`	`12.6660`	`0.5040`	`25.131`	`-0.73325919`	`-0.73326001`
`ortez`	`14.8570`	`0.4840`	`30.696`	`-9532.02800006`	`-9532.03905335`
`prob02`	`0.0130`	`0.7280`	`0.018`	`112235.00000000`	`112235.00000000`
`prob03`	`0.0150`	`0.1750`	`0.086`	`10.00000000`	`10.00000000`
`procsel`	`0.0160`	`0.3480`	`0.046`	`-1.92309874`	`-1.92309874`
`ravempb`	`67.9760`	`1.4190`	`47.904`	`269590.21948714`	`269590.21931531`
`risk2bpb`	`2.2250`	`0.5240`	`4.246`	`-55.87613939`	`-55.73616850`
`spring`	`0.5600`	`0.3870`	`1.447`	`0.84624868`	`0.84624567`
`st_e14`	`0.1490`	`0.2140`	`0.696`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`st_e32`	`138.8440`	`0.4070`	`341.140`	`-1.43040697`	`-1.43040728`
`st_miqp1`	`0.0310`	`0.2000`	`0.155`	`281.00000000`	`281.00000000`
`st_miqp2`	`0.0440`	`0.2720`	`0.162`	`2.00000000`	`2.00000000`
`st_test5`	`0.0290`	`0.3790`	`0.077`	`-110.00000000`	`-110.00000000`
`st_test6`	`0.0370`	`0.4920`	`0.075`	`471.00000000`	`471.00000000`
`st_test8`	`0.0290`	`0.1410`	`0.206`	`-29605.00000000`	`-29605.00000000`
`synthes1`	`0.0440`	`0.1670`	`0.263`	`6.00975902`	`6.00975891`
`synthes2`	`0.5900`	`0.2650`	`2.226`	`73.03531253`	`73.03531253`
`synthes3`	`4.3810`	`0.4320`	`10.141`	`68.00974052`	`68.00974052`
`tln6`	`156.6810`	`8582.6700`	`0.018`	`15.30000000`	`15.70000000`
`tloss`	`0.4650`	`1.0170`	`0.457`	`16.30000000`	`16.30000000`
`hmittelman`	`2.0350`	`1.0540`	`1.931`	`13.00000000`	`13.00000000`
`st_testgr3`	`11.1490`	`0.3160`	`35.282`	`-20.59000000`	`-20.46880000`
`st_testph4`	`0.0110`	`0.3650`	`0.030`	`-80.50000000`	`-80.50000000`

LINDOGLOBAL: optimal -- SBB: infeasible Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)	Status (SBB)
`st_e13`	`0.0130`	`0.3660`	---	`2.00000000`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e15`	`0.0190`	`0.1190`	---	`7.66718007`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e40`	`5.6410`	`0.1170`	---	`30.41421350`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`tltr`	`4.2540`	`0.2380`	---	`48.06666667`	`mstat(10) sstat( 1)`
`feedtray2`	`0.6080`	`0.1840`	---	`0.00000000`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`

LINDOGLOBAL: feasible -- SBB: feasible Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)	Obj (SBB)
`4stufen`	`3600.3200`	`2.9490`	`1220.861`	`116385.01988820`	`116372.13880337`
`beuster`	`3601.2740`	`71.9220`	`50.072`	`130219.29975388`	`117074.96620329`
`cecil_13`	`132.0890`	`5.4140`	`24.398`	`-115606.73592818`	`-115544.83985511`
`contvar`	`3600.5290`	`10.2790`	`350.280`	`809149.82722944`	`809149.82722947`
`csched1a`	`9.1480`	`0.2930`	`31.222`	`-30430.17681720`	`-30279.74711113`
`csched2a`	`3600.3710`	`4.3700`	`823.884`	`-165382.27900816`	`-163862.78203283`
`du-opt5`	`2047.5980`	`21.3160`	`96.059`	`8.07365758`	`8.07365758`
`du-opt`	`270.9360`	`1.7230`	`157.247`	`3.55634006`	`3.55699635`
`eg_all_s`	`3600.4800`	`13.1550`	`273.697`	`7.65888584`	`7.92018223`
`eg_int_s`	`3600.7340`	`19.3250`	`186.325`	`7.46308038`	`6.45310316`
`elf`	`0.1120`	`0.9030`	`0.124`	`1.67499999`	`0.43466667`
`eniplac`	`3602.4430`	`18.6120`	`193.555`	`-131863.63482866`	`-130344.36990401`
`ex1224`	`0.2620`	`0.2290`	`1.144`	`-0.94347050`	`-0.94347050`
`ex1233`	`60.3570`	`1.3710`	`44.024`	`155010.67127822`	`155010.67128049`
`ex1243`	`20.0350`	`0.3600`	`55.653`	`83402.50642846`	`83402.50641026`
`ex1244`	`266.6930`	`0.4780`	`557.935`	`82042.90524624`	`82042.90521975`
`ex1252a`	`175.6680`	`1.3950`	`125.927`	`128893.74106248`	`128893.74101350`
`ex1264a`	`1.8810`	`12.7950`	`0.147`	`9.30000000`	`8.60000000`
`fac1`	`0.3610`	`0.2300`	`1.570`	`160912612.35017100`	`160912612.35016900`
`fuel`	`0.0540`	`0.1880`	`0.287`	`8566.11896169`	`8566.11896169`
`fo7`	`3600.3070`	`6719.6300`	`0.536`	`29.54373631`	`30.03641833`
`gasnet`	`489.3060`	`0.2340`	`2091.051`	`7004607.80639912`	`7045326.89261437`
`hda`	`3600.7110`	`3.9890`	`902.660`	`-5453.80134259`	`-5762.65148616`
`johnall`	`33.5140`	`1.9880`	`16.858`	`-224.73016162`	`-224.73016162`
`gkocis`	`0.0240`	`0.2480`	`0.097`	`-1.92307545`	`-1.92309874`
`lop97icx`	`191.9090`	`6131.7190`	`0.031`	`4436.39671520`	`4126.26060320`
`m6`	`495.2620`	`2884.9770`	`0.172`	`82.25687760`	`82.25687691`
`m7`	`3600.4280`	`5959.9000`	`0.604`	`106.75687693`	`123.96437781`
`meanvarx`	`0.0820`	`0.2120`	`0.387`	`14.36923211`	`14.49698300`
`minlphix`	`17.0390`	`0.4470`	`38.119`	`316.69269553`	`316.69269544`
`nous1`	`85.3040`	`0.2080`	`410.115`	`1.56707201`	`1.56707200`
`nous2`	`0.5640`	`0.1610`	`3.503`	`0.62596745`	`0.62596741`
`nvs02`	`0.2460`	`0.3430`	`0.717`	`5.98228770`	`5.96418452`
`nvs05`	`40.4780`	`0.1900`	`213.042`	`5.47093411`	`5.47093411`
`nvs10`	`0.0170`	`0.1480`	`0.115`	`-310.80000000`	`-310.80000000`
`o7`	`3600.4330`	`6631.9400`	`0.543`	`151.30711666`	`181.46472807`
`parallel`	`245.4980`	`0.6770`	`362.626`	`924.29559125`	`924.29555066`
`pump`	`131.7010`	`0.1920`	`685.943`	`128893.74106318`	`134263.58532517`
`qap`	`3601.6550`	`5.7090`	`630.873`	`489734.00000476`	`395738.00000000`
`qapw`	`3600.2360`	`1.8410`	`1955.587`	`394964.00000002`	`388870.00000000`
`sep1`	`0.0920`	`0.2340`	`0.393`	`-510.08098427`	`-510.08098435`
`space25a`	`3600.5240`	`10.4610`	`344.185`	`484.32864420`	`484.32864420`
`spectra2`	`38.6420`	`1.6700`	`23.139`	`13.97830588`	`13.97830588`
`st_e29`	`0.2550`	`0.2280`	`1.118`	`-0.94347050`	`-0.94347050`
`st_miqp4`	`0.0060`	`0.1340`	`0.045`	`-4574.00000000`	`-4574.00000000`
`synheat`	`60.3480`	`3.0810`	`19.587`	`154997.33490149`	`154997.33486599`
`tln7`	`3600.4210`	`8762.7440`	`0.411`	`17.00000000`	`23.50000000`
`util`	`3.3870`	`0.2870`	`11.801`	`999.57875034`	`999.89730763`
`water4`	`3600.2010`	`76.9750`	`46.771`	`940.41676849`	`913.15706796`
`waterx`	`3600.0280`	`46.9720`	`76.642`	`950.97655147`	`938.86284906`
`eg_disc_s`	`3601.0130`	`11.1490`	`322.990`	`5.76053962`	`5.76053962`
`eg_disc2_s`	`3600.3370`	`5.2860`	`681.108`	`5.64210058`	`5.93637221`
`enpro48pb`	`42.3590`	`4.6670`	`9.076`	`187277.25947561`	`187277.25942201`
`enpro56pb`	`429.1680`	`33.0950`	`12.968`	`263428.30097264`	`263428.30097265`
`st_testgr1`	`1.4540`	`0.3260`	`4.460`	`-12.81160000`	`-12.72810000`
`nuclearva`	`1081.3210`	`0.3910`	`2765.527`	`-1.00902911`	`-1.00948507`
`stockcycle`	`310.0830`	`591.1400`	`0.525`	`120532.62166667`	`119948.68833333`

LINDOGLOBAL: feasible -- SBB: infeasible Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)	Status (SBB)
`st_e31`	`4.3150`	`0.1350`	---	`-1.99999778`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e36`	`1.8430`	`0.2690`	---	`-246.00000000`	`mstat(10) sstat( 1)`

LINDOGLOBAL: feasible -- SBB: fail Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)	Status (SBB)
`tln12`	`3601.4880`	`8804.7890`	---	`129.60000000`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tls6`	`3600.8170`	`10020.9100`	---	`20.70000003`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tls7`	`3602.9820`	`5234.9090`	---	`22.50000000`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`

LINDOGLOBAL: fail -- SBB: feasible Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Status (LINDOGLOBAL)	Obj (SBB)
`mbtd`	`3600.9110`	`3621.3750`	---	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`	`5.66666000`
`pb351535`	`NA`	`1584.6850`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`4485288.00000000`
`space25`	`NA`	`113.6170`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`484.32864420`

LINDOGLOBAL: fail -- SBB: infeasible Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Status (LINDOGLOBAL)	Status (SBB)
`super3t`	`NA`	`0.6160`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`

LINDOGLOBAL: fail -- SBB: fail Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Status (LINDOGLOBAL)	Status (SBB)
`pb302035`	`NA`	`3932.2400`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`pb302095`	`NA`	`3886.8390`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`pb351595`	`NA`	`3862.9990`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`tls12`	`3607.4790`	`11222.8460`	---	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`

LINDOGLOBAL: optimal: Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)
`alan`	`0.0250`	`2.92500000`
`batch`	`2.2470`	`285506.50824681`
`batchdes`	`0.1760`	`167427.65711475`
`ex1221`	`0.0090`	`7.66718173`
`ex1222`	`0.0060`	`1.07654326`
`ex1223`	`0.0970`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223a`	`0.0220`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223b`	`0.0730`	`4.57958240`
`ex1225`	`0.0160`	`31.00000000`
`ex1226`	`0.0150`	`-17.00000000`
`ex1252`	`29.3540`	`128893.74106485`
`ex1263`	`43.6500`	`19.60000002`
`ex1263a`	`2.2210`	`19.60000000`
`ex1264`	`17.8680`	`8.60000001`
`ex1265`	`30.7530`	`10.30000000`
`ex1265a`	`1.1460`	`10.30000000`
`ex1266`	`3.9550`	`16.30000000`
`ex1266a`	`4.1190`	`16.30000000`
`ex3pb`	`0.3510`	`68.00974405`
`ex4`	`40.4410`	`-8.06413616`
`fac2`	`13.1530`	`331837498.26956600`
`fac3`	`53.8090`	`31982309.84800090`
`feedtray`	`5.1430`	`-13.40599772`
`gastrans`	`0.8140`	`89.08584001`
`gbd`	`0.0090`	`2.20000000`
`gear`	`0.0390`	`0.00000067`
`gear2`	`0.0430`	`0.00000062`
`gear3`	`0.0530`	`0.00000003`
`gear4`	`153.6720`	`1.64342847`
`m3`	`1.6960`	`37.79999992`
`nvs01`	`0.0510`	`12.46966882`
`nvs03`	`0.0270`	`16.00000000`
`nvs04`	`0.0300`	`0.72000000`
`nvs06`	`0.0250`	`1.77031250`
`nvs07`	`0.0570`	`4.00000000`
`nvs08`	`0.0880`	`23.44972735`
`oaer`	`0.0190`	`-1.92309851`
`oil2`	`12.6660`	`-0.73325919`
`ortez`	`14.8570`	`-9532.02800006`
`prob02`	`0.0130`	`112235.00000000`
`prob03`	`0.0150`	`10.00000000`
`procsel`	`0.0160`	`-1.92309874`
`ravempb`	`67.9760`	`269590.21948714`
`risk2bpb`	`2.2250`	`-55.87613939`
`spring`	`0.5600`	`0.84624868`
`st_e13`	`0.0130`	`2.00000000`
`st_e14`	`0.1490`	`4.57958240`
`st_e15`	`0.0190`	`7.66718007`
`st_e27`	`0.0080`	`2.00000000`
`st_e32`	`138.8440`	`-1.43040697`
`st_e38`	`0.0620`	`7197.72714852`
`st_e40`	`5.6410`	`30.41421350`
`st_miqp1`	`0.0310`	`281.00000000`
`st_miqp2`	`0.0440`	`2.00000000`
`st_miqp3`	`0.0080`	`-6.00000000`
`st_miqp5`	`0.0120`	`-333.88888889`
`st_test5`	`0.0290`	`-110.00000000`
`st_test6`	`0.0370`	`471.00000000`
`st_test8`	`0.0290`	`-29605.00000000`
`synthes1`	`0.0440`	`6.00975902`
`synthes2`	`0.5900`	`73.03531253`
`synthes3`	`4.3810`	`68.00974052`
`tln6`	`156.6810`	`15.30000000`
`tloss`	`0.4650`	`16.30000000`
`tltr`	`4.2540`	`48.06666667`
`feedtray2`	`0.6080`	`0.00000000`
`hmittelman`	`2.0350`	`13.00000000`
`st_testgr3`	`11.1490`	`-20.59000000`
`st_testph4`	`0.0110`	`-80.50000000`

LINDOGLOBAL: feasible: Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)
`4stufen`	`3600.3200`	`116385.01988820`
`beuster`	`3601.2740`	`130219.29975388`
`cecil_13`	`132.0890`	`-115606.73592818`
`contvar`	`3600.5290`	`809149.82722944`
`csched1a`	`9.1480`	`-30430.17681720`
`csched2a`	`3600.3710`	`-165382.27900816`
`du-opt5`	`2047.5980`	`8.07365758`
`du-opt`	`270.9360`	`3.55634006`
`eg_all_s`	`3600.4800`	`7.65888584`
`eg_int_s`	`3600.7340`	`7.46308038`
`elf`	`0.1120`	`1.67499999`
`eniplac`	`3602.4430`	`-131863.63482866`
`ex1224`	`0.2620`	`-0.94347050`
`ex1233`	`60.3570`	`155010.67127822`
`ex1243`	`20.0350`	`83402.50642846`
`ex1244`	`266.6930`	`82042.90524624`
`ex1252a`	`175.6680`	`128893.74106248`
`ex1264a`	`1.8810`	`9.30000000`
`fac1`	`0.3610`	`160912612.35017100`
`fuel`	`0.0540`	`8566.11896169`
`fo7`	`3600.3070`	`29.54373631`
`gasnet`	`489.3060`	`7004607.80639912`
`hda`	`3600.7110`	`-5453.80134259`
`johnall`	`33.5140`	`-224.73016162`
`gkocis`	`0.0240`	`-1.92307545`
`lop97icx`	`191.9090`	`4436.39671520`
`m6`	`495.2620`	`82.25687760`
`m7`	`3600.4280`	`106.75687693`
`meanvarx`	`0.0820`	`14.36923211`
`minlphix`	`17.0390`	`316.69269553`
`nous1`	`85.3040`	`1.56707201`
`nous2`	`0.5640`	`0.62596745`
`nvs02`	`0.2460`	`5.98228770`
`nvs05`	`40.4780`	`5.47093411`
`nvs09`	`1.5300`	`-43.13433692`
`nvs10`	`0.0170`	`-310.80000000`
`o7`	`3600.4330`	`151.30711666`
`parallel`	`245.4980`	`924.29559125`
`pump`	`131.7010`	`128893.74106318`
`qap`	`3601.6550`	`489734.00000476`
`qapw`	`3600.2360`	`394964.00000002`
`sep1`	`0.0920`	`-510.08098427`
`space25a`	`3600.5240`	`484.32864420`
`spectra2`	`38.6420`	`13.97830588`
`st_e29`	`0.2550`	`-0.94347050`
`st_e31`	`4.3150`	`-1.99999778`
`st_e35`	`14.2140`	`64868.07683726`
`st_e36`	`1.8430`	`-246.00000000`
`st_miqp4`	`0.0060`	`-4574.00000000`
`synheat`	`60.3480`	`154997.33490149`
`tln12`	`3601.4880`	`129.60000000`
`tln7`	`3600.4210`	`17.00000000`
`tls6`	`3600.8170`	`20.70000003`
`tls7`	`3602.9820`	`22.50000000`
`util`	`3.3870`	`999.57875034`
`water4`	`3600.2010`	`940.41676849`
`waterx`	`3600.0280`	`950.97655147`
`eg_disc_s`	`3601.0130`	`5.76053962`
`eg_disc2_s`	`3600.3370`	`5.64210058`
`enpro48pb`	`42.3590`	`187277.25947561`
`enpro56pb`	`429.1680`	`263428.30097264`
`nuclear14a`	`3606.8250`	`-1.12935386`
`st_testgr1`	`1.4540`	`-12.81160000`
`nuclear24a`	`3608.6320`	`-1.12935386`
`nuclearva`	`1081.3210`	`-1.00902911`
`stockcycle`	`310.0830`	`120532.62166667`

LINDOGLOBAL: fail: Back to top

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Status (LINDOGLOBAL)
`mbtd`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`pb302035`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`
`pb302095`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`
`pb351535`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`
`pb351595`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`
`space25`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`
`super3t`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`
`tls12`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`

SBB: feasible: Back to top

Modelname	Time (SBB)	Obj (SBB)
`4stufen`	`2.9490`	`116372.13880337`
`alan`	`0.2080`	`2.92500000`
`batch`	`0.4870`	`285506.50815158`
`batchdes`	`0.2320`	`167427.65711470`
`beuster`	`71.9220`	`117074.96620329`
`cecil_13`	`5.4140`	`-115544.83985511`
`contvar`	`10.2790`	`809149.82722947`
`csched1a`	`0.2930`	`-30279.74711113`
`csched2a`	`4.3700`	`-163862.78203283`
`du-opt5`	`21.3160`	`8.07365758`
`du-opt`	`1.7230`	`3.55699635`
`eg_all_s`	`13.1550`	`7.92018223`
`eg_int_s`	`19.3250`	`6.45310316`
`elf`	`0.9030`	`0.43466667`
`eniplac`	`18.6120`	`-130344.36990401`
`ex1222`	`0.2370`	`1.07654308`
`ex1223`	`0.2150`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223a`	`0.1630`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223b`	`0.2150`	`4.57958240`
`ex1224`	`0.2290`	`-0.94347050`
`ex1225`	`0.2000`	`31.00000000`
`ex1233`	`1.3710`	`155010.67128049`
`ex1243`	`0.3600`	`83402.50641026`
`ex1244`	`0.4780`	`82042.90521975`
`ex1252`	`2.4880`	`128893.74101350`
`ex1252a`	`1.3950`	`128893.74101350`
`ex1263`	`21.5240`	`19.60000000`
`ex1263a`	`6.6890`	`20.00000000`
`ex1264`	`7.8670`	`8.60000000`
`ex1264a`	`12.7950`	`8.60000000`
`ex1265`	`5.9840`	`10.30000000`
`ex1265a`	`0.3330`	`15.10000000`
`ex1266`	`11.4230`	`16.30000000`
`ex1266a`	`1.1210`	`16.30000000`
`ex3pb`	`0.5400`	`68.00974405`
`ex4`	`3.4150`	`-8.06413616`
`fac1`	`0.2300`	`160912612.35016900`
`fac2`	`0.6750`	`331837498.17676900`
`fac3`	`0.5570`	`31982309.84800000`
`fuel`	`0.1880`	`8566.11896169`
`fo7`	`6719.6300`	`30.03641833`
`gasnet`	`0.2340`	`7045326.89261437`
`gastrans`	`1.2390`	`89.08584000`
`gear`	`3.3260`	`0.00000000`
`gear2`	`75.2620`	`0.00000000`
`gear3`	`3.3710`	`0.00000000`
`gear4`	`190.3330`	`1.64342847`
`hda`	`3.9890`	`-5762.65148616`
`johnall`	`1.9880`	`-224.73016162`
`gkocis`	`0.2480`	`-1.92309874`
`lop97icx`	`6131.7190`	`4126.26060320`
`m3`	`1.1120`	`37.80000000`
`m6`	`2884.9770`	`82.25687691`
`m7`	`5959.9000`	`123.96437781`
`mbtd`	`3621.3750`	`5.66666000`
`meanvarx`	`0.2120`	`14.49698300`
`minlphix`	`0.4470`	`316.69269544`
`nous1`	`0.2080`	`1.56707200`
`nous2`	`0.1610`	`0.62596741`
`nvs01`	`0.3110`	`12.46966882`
`nvs02`	`0.3430`	`5.96418452`
`nvs03`	`0.2040`	`16.00000000`
`nvs04`	`0.1740`	`0.72000000`
`nvs05`	`0.1900`	`5.47093411`
`nvs06`	`0.1750`	`1.77031250`
`nvs07`	`0.1980`	`4.00000000`
`nvs08`	`0.1800`	`23.44972735`
`nvs10`	`0.1480`	`-310.80000000`
`o7`	`6631.9400`	`181.46472807`
`oaer`	`0.1750`	`-1.92309854`
`oil2`	`0.5040`	`-0.73326001`
`ortez`	`0.4840`	`-9532.03905335`
`parallel`	`0.6770`	`924.29555066`
`pb351535`	`1584.6850`	`4485288.00000000`
`prob02`	`0.7280`	`112235.00000000`
`prob03`	`0.1750`	`10.00000000`
`procsel`	`0.3480`	`-1.92309874`
`pump`	`0.1920`	`134263.58532517`
`qap`	`5.7090`	`395738.00000000`
`qapw`	`1.8410`	`388870.00000000`
`ravempb`	`1.4190`	`269590.21931531`
`risk2bpb`	`0.5240`	`-55.73616850`
`sep1`	`0.2340`	`-510.08098435`
`space25`	`113.6170`	`484.32864420`
`space25a`	`10.4610`	`484.32864420`
`spectra2`	`1.6700`	`13.97830588`
`spring`	`0.3870`	`0.84624567`
`st_e14`	`0.2140`	`4.57958240`
`st_e29`	`0.2280`	`-0.94347050`
`st_e32`	`0.4070`	`-1.43040728`
`st_miqp1`	`0.2000`	`281.00000000`
`st_miqp2`	`0.2720`	`2.00000000`
`st_miqp4`	`0.1340`	`-4574.00000000`
`st_test5`	`0.3790`	`-110.00000000`
`st_test6`	`0.4920`	`471.00000000`
`st_test8`	`0.1410`	`-29605.00000000`
`synheat`	`3.0810`	`154997.33486599`
`synthes1`	`0.1670`	`6.00975891`
`synthes2`	`0.2650`	`73.03531253`
`synthes3`	`0.4320`	`68.00974052`
`tln6`	`8582.6700`	`15.70000000`
`tln7`	`8762.7440`	`23.50000000`
`tloss`	`1.0170`	`16.30000000`
`util`	`0.2870`	`999.89730763`
`water4`	`76.9750`	`913.15706796`
`waterx`	`46.9720`	`938.86284906`
`eg_disc_s`	`11.1490`	`5.76053962`
`eg_disc2_s`	`5.2860`	`5.93637221`
`enpro48pb`	`4.6670`	`187277.25942201`
`enpro56pb`	`33.0950`	`263428.30097265`
`hmittelman`	`1.0540`	`13.00000000`
`st_testgr1`	`0.3260`	`-12.72810000`
`st_testgr3`	`0.3160`	`-20.46880000`
`st_testph4`	`0.3650`	`-80.50000000`
`nuclearva`	`0.3910`	`-1.00948507`
`stockcycle`	`591.1400`	`119948.68833333`

SBB: infeasible: Back to top

Modelname	Time (SBB)	Status (SBB)
`st_e13`	`--`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e15`	`--`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e31`	`--`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e36`	`--`	`mstat(10) sstat( 1)`
`st_e40`	`--`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`super3t`	`--`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`tltr`	`--`	`mstat(10) sstat( 1)`
`feedtray2`	`--`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`

SBB: fail: Back to top

Modelname	Time (SBB)	Status (SBB)
`pb302035`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`pb302095`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`pb351595`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`tln12`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tls12`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tls6`	`--`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tls7`	`--`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`

LINDOGLOBAL: all -- SBB: all : Back to top

A "(max)" behind a model names indicates that this model is a maximization model.

A model is counted as solved if a feasible point has been found.

For time and timeratios, a shifted geometric mean is used, where unsolved instances are counted with twice the reslim (3600.00 seconds). The shift is 10s for time and 0.0001 for timeratios.

Modelname	Time (LINDOGLOBAL)	Time (SBB)	Ratio (LINDOGLOBAL/SBB)	Obj (LINDOGLOBAL)	Obj (SBB)
`4stufen`	`3600.3200`	`2.9490`	`1220.861`	`116385.01988820`	`116372.13880337`
`alan`	`0.0250`	`0.2080`	`0.120`	`2.92500000`	`2.92500000`
`batch`	`2.2470`	`0.4870`	`4.614`	`285506.50824681`	`285506.50815158`
`batchdes`	`0.1760`	`0.2320`	`0.759`	`167427.65711475`	`167427.65711470`
`beuster`	`3601.2740`	`71.9220`	`50.072`	`130219.29975388`	`117074.96620329`
`cecil_13`	`132.0890`	`5.4140`	`24.398`	`-115606.73592818`	`-115544.83985511`
`contvar`	`3600.5290`	`10.2790`	`350.280`	`809149.82722944`	`809149.82722947`
`csched1a`	`9.1480`	`0.2930`	`31.222`	`-30430.17681720`	`-30279.74711113`
`csched2a`	`3600.3710`	`4.3700`	`823.884`	`-165382.27900816`	`-163862.78203283`
`du-opt5`	`2047.5980`	`21.3160`	`96.059`	`8.07365758`	`8.07365758`
`du-opt`	`270.9360`	`1.7230`	`157.247`	`3.55634006`	`3.55699635`
`eg_all_s`	`3600.4800`	`13.1550`	`273.697`	`7.65888584`	`7.92018223`
`eg_int_s`	`3600.7340`	`19.3250`	`186.325`	`7.46308038`	`6.45310316`
`elf`	`0.1120`	`0.9030`	`0.124`	`1.67499999`	`0.43466667`
`eniplac`	`3602.4430`	`18.6120`	`193.555`	`-131863.63482866`	`-130344.36990401`
`ex1222`	`0.0060`	`0.2370`	`0.025`	`1.07654326`	`1.07654308`
`ex1223`	`0.0970`	`0.2150`	`0.451`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223a`	`0.0220`	`0.1630`	`0.135`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`ex1223b`	`0.0730`	`0.2150`	`0.340`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`ex1224`	`0.2620`	`0.2290`	`1.144`	`-0.94347050`	`-0.94347050`
`ex1225`	`0.0160`	`0.2000`	`0.080`	`31.00000000`	`31.00000000`
`ex1233`	`60.3570`	`1.3710`	`44.024`	`155010.67127822`	`155010.67128049`
`ex1243`	`20.0350`	`0.3600`	`55.653`	`83402.50642846`	`83402.50641026`
`ex1244`	`266.6930`	`0.4780`	`557.935`	`82042.90524624`	`82042.90521975`
`ex1252`	`29.3540`	`2.4880`	`11.798`	`128893.74106485`	`128893.74101350`
`ex1252a`	`175.6680`	`1.3950`	`125.927`	`128893.74106248`	`128893.74101350`
`ex1263`	`43.6500`	`21.5240`	`2.028`	`19.60000002`	`19.60000000`
`ex1263a`	`2.2210`	`6.6890`	`0.332`	`19.60000000`	`20.00000000`
`ex1264`	`17.8680`	`7.8670`	`2.271`	`8.60000001`	`8.60000000`
`ex1264a`	`1.8810`	`12.7950`	`0.147`	`9.30000000`	`8.60000000`
`ex1265`	`30.7530`	`5.9840`	`5.139`	`10.30000000`	`10.30000000`
`ex1265a`	`1.1460`	`0.3330`	`3.441`	`10.30000000`	`15.10000000`
`ex1266`	`3.9550`	`11.4230`	`0.346`	`16.30000000`	`16.30000000`
`ex1266a`	`4.1190`	`1.1210`	`3.674`	`16.30000000`	`16.30000000`
`ex3pb`	`0.3510`	`0.5400`	`0.650`	`68.00974405`	`68.00974405`
`ex4`	`40.4410`	`3.4150`	`11.842`	`-8.06413616`	`-8.06413616`
`fac1`	`0.3610`	`0.2300`	`1.570`	`160912612.35017100`	`160912612.35016900`
`fac2`	`13.1530`	`0.6750`	`19.486`	`331837498.26956600`	`331837498.17676900`
`fac3`	`53.8090`	`0.5570`	`96.605`	`31982309.84800090`	`31982309.84800000`
`fuel`	`0.0540`	`0.1880`	`0.287`	`8566.11896169`	`8566.11896169`
`fo7`	`3600.3070`	`6719.6300`	`0.536`	`29.54373631`	`30.03641833`
`gasnet`	`489.3060`	`0.2340`	`2091.051`	`7004607.80639912`	`7045326.89261437`
`gastrans`	`0.8140`	`1.2390`	`0.657`	`89.08584001`	`89.08584000`
`gear`	`0.0390`	`3.3260`	`0.012`	`0.00000067`	`0.00000000`
`gear2`	`0.0430`	`75.2620`	`0.001`	`0.00000062`	`0.00000000`
`gear3`	`0.0530`	`3.3710`	`0.016`	`0.00000003`	`0.00000000`
`gear4`	`153.6720`	`190.3330`	`0.807`	`1.64342847`	`1.64342847`
`hda`	`3600.7110`	`3.9890`	`902.660`	`-5453.80134259`	`-5762.65148616`
`johnall`	`33.5140`	`1.9880`	`16.858`	`-224.73016162`	`-224.73016162`
`gkocis`	`0.0240`	`0.2480`	`0.097`	`-1.92307545`	`-1.92309874`
`lop97icx`	`191.9090`	`6131.7190`	`0.031`	`4436.39671520`	`4126.26060320`
`m3`	`1.6960`	`1.1120`	`1.525`	`37.79999992`	`37.80000000`
`m6`	`495.2620`	`2884.9770`	`0.172`	`82.25687760`	`82.25687691`
`m7`	`3600.4280`	`5959.9000`	`0.604`	`106.75687693`	`123.96437781`
`mbtd`	`3600.9110`	`3621.3750`	---	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`	`5.66666000`
`meanvarx`	`0.0820`	`0.2120`	`0.387`	`14.36923211`	`14.49698300`
`minlphix`	`17.0390`	`0.4470`	`38.119`	`316.69269553`	`316.69269544`
`nous1`	`85.3040`	`0.2080`	`410.115`	`1.56707201`	`1.56707200`
`nous2`	`0.5640`	`0.1610`	`3.503`	`0.62596745`	`0.62596741`
`nvs01`	`0.0510`	`0.3110`	`0.164`	`12.46966882`	`12.46966882`
`nvs02`	`0.2460`	`0.3430`	`0.717`	`5.98228770`	`5.96418452`
`nvs03`	`0.0270`	`0.2040`	`0.132`	`16.00000000`	`16.00000000`
`nvs04`	`0.0300`	`0.1740`	`0.172`	`0.72000000`	`0.72000000`
`nvs05`	`40.4780`	`0.1900`	`213.042`	`5.47093411`	`5.47093411`
`nvs06`	`0.0250`	`0.1750`	`0.143`	`1.77031250`	`1.77031250`
`nvs07`	`0.0570`	`0.1980`	`0.288`	`4.00000000`	`4.00000000`
`nvs08`	`0.0880`	`0.1800`	`0.489`	`23.44972735`	`23.44972735`
`nvs10`	`0.0170`	`0.1480`	`0.115`	`-310.80000000`	`-310.80000000`
`o7`	`3600.4330`	`6631.9400`	`0.543`	`151.30711666`	`181.46472807`
`oaer`	`0.0190`	`0.1750`	`0.109`	`-1.92309851`	`-1.92309854`
`oil2`	`12.6660`	`0.5040`	`25.131`	`-0.73325919`	`-0.73326001`
`ortez`	`14.8570`	`0.4840`	`30.696`	`-9532.02800006`	`-9532.03905335`
`parallel`	`245.4980`	`0.6770`	`362.626`	`924.29559125`	`924.29555066`
`pb302035`	`NA`	`3932.2400`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`pb302095`	`NA`	`3886.8390`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`pb351535`	`NA`	`1584.6850`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`4485288.00000000`
`pb351595`	`NA`	`3862.9990`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`
`prob02`	`0.0130`	`0.7280`	`0.018`	`112235.00000000`	`112235.00000000`
`prob03`	`0.0150`	`0.1750`	`0.086`	`10.00000000`	`10.00000000`
`procsel`	`0.0160`	`0.3480`	`0.046`	`-1.92309874`	`-1.92309874`
`pump`	`131.7010`	`0.1920`	`685.943`	`128893.74106318`	`134263.58532517`
`qap`	`3601.6550`	`5.7090`	`630.873`	`489734.00000476`	`395738.00000000`
`qapw`	`3600.2360`	`1.8410`	`1955.587`	`394964.00000002`	`388870.00000000`
`ravempb`	`67.9760`	`1.4190`	`47.904`	`269590.21948714`	`269590.21931531`
`risk2bpb`	`2.2250`	`0.5240`	`4.246`	`-55.87613939`	`-55.73616850`
`sep1`	`0.0920`	`0.2340`	`0.393`	`-510.08098427`	`-510.08098435`
`space25`	`NA`	`113.6170`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`484.32864420`
`space25a`	`3600.5240`	`10.4610`	`344.185`	`484.32864420`	`484.32864420`
`spectra2`	`38.6420`	`1.6700`	`23.139`	`13.97830588`	`13.97830588`
`spring`	`0.5600`	`0.3870`	`1.447`	`0.84624868`	`0.84624567`
`st_e13`	`0.0130`	`0.3660`	---	`2.00000000`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e14`	`0.1490`	`0.2140`	`0.696`	`4.57958240`	`4.57958240`
`st_e15`	`0.0190`	`0.1190`	---	`7.66718007`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e29`	`0.2550`	`0.2280`	`1.118`	`-0.94347050`	`-0.94347050`
`st_e31`	`4.3150`	`0.1350`	---	`-1.99999778`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_e32`	`138.8440`	`0.4070`	`341.140`	`-1.43040697`	`-1.43040728`
`st_e36`	`1.8430`	`0.2690`	---	`-246.00000000`	`mstat(10) sstat( 1)`
`st_e40`	`5.6410`	`0.1170`	---	`30.41421350`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`st_miqp1`	`0.0310`	`0.2000`	`0.155`	`281.00000000`	`281.00000000`
`st_miqp2`	`0.0440`	`0.2720`	`0.162`	`2.00000000`	`2.00000000`
`st_miqp4`	`0.0060`	`0.1340`	`0.045`	`-4574.00000000`	`-4574.00000000`
`st_test5`	`0.0290`	`0.3790`	`0.077`	`-110.00000000`	`-110.00000000`
`st_test6`	`0.0370`	`0.4920`	`0.075`	`471.00000000`	`471.00000000`
`st_test8`	`0.0290`	`0.1410`	`0.206`	`-29605.00000000`	`-29605.00000000`
`super3t`	`NA`	`0.6160`	---	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`synheat`	`60.3480`	`3.0810`	`19.587`	`154997.33490149`	`154997.33486599`
`synthes1`	`0.0440`	`0.1670`	`0.263`	`6.00975902`	`6.00975891`
`synthes2`	`0.5900`	`0.2650`	`2.226`	`73.03531253`	`73.03531253`
`synthes3`	`4.3810`	`0.4320`	`10.141`	`68.00974052`	`68.00974052`
`tln12`	`3601.4880`	`8804.7890`	---	`129.60000000`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tln6`	`156.6810`	`8582.6700`	`0.018`	`15.30000000`	`15.70000000`
`tln7`	`3600.4210`	`8762.7440`	`0.411`	`17.00000000`	`23.50000000`
`tloss`	`0.4650`	`1.0170`	`0.457`	`16.30000000`	`16.30000000`
`tls12`	`3607.4790`	`11222.8460`	---	`mstat(14) sstat( 3)`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tls6`	`3600.8170`	`10020.9100`	---	`20.70000003`	`mstat(14) sstat( 8)`
`tls7`	`3602.9820`	`5234.9090`	---	`22.50000000`	`mstat(13) sstat(13)`
`tltr`	`4.2540`	`0.2380`	---	`48.06666667`	`mstat(10) sstat( 1)`
`util`	`3.3870`	`0.2870`	`11.801`	`999.57875034`	`999.89730763`
`water4`	`3600.2010`	`76.9750`	`46.771`	`940.41676849`	`913.15706796`
`waterx`	`3600.0280`	`46.9720`	`76.642`	`950.97655147`	`938.86284906`
`eg_disc_s`	`3601.0130`	`11.1490`	`322.990`	`5.76053962`	`5.76053962`
`eg_disc2_s`	`3600.3370`	`5.2860`	`681.108`	`5.64210058`	`5.93637221`
`enpro48pb`	`42.3590`	`4.6670`	`9.076`	`187277.25947561`	`187277.25942201`
`enpro56pb`	`429.1680`	`33.0950`	`12.968`	`263428.30097264`	`263428.30097265`
`feedtray2`	`0.6080`	`0.1840`	---	`0.00000000`	`mstat( 5) sstat( 1)`
`hmittelman`	`2.0350`	`1.0540`	`1.931`	`13.00000000`	`13.00000000`
`st_testgr1`	`1.4540`	`0.3260`	`4.460`	`-12.81160000`	`-12.72810000`
`st_testgr3`	`11.1490`	`0.3160`	`35.282`	`-20.59000000`	`-20.46880000`
`st_testph4`	`0.0110`	`0.3650`	`0.030`	`-80.50000000`	`-80.50000000`
`nuclearva`	`1081.3210`	`0.3910`	`2765.527`	`-1.00902911`	`-1.00948507`
`stockcycle`	`310.0830`	`591.1400`	`0.525`	`120532.62166667`	`119948.68833333`

mean	69.13	33.31	---	---	---
unsolved	6.11%	11.45%